Keep two, dump two

Keep Alice and Anna.
Dump Anya and Zara.

Oh you've really whittled it down! I was on your other threads I think, but possibly a different username.

Keep: Anna and Zara
Dump: Alice and Anya

But I actually really like them all, so struggling to choose!

I like them all apart from Anya. I’d probably choose Alice and Anna.

Keep Anna and Zara.

Keep Alice and Anna.

Keep
Anna
Alice

Dump
Zara
Anya

In order of overall preference

I would keep Anna and Alice, but I also like Zara.

Dump Anna and Zara
Keep Anya and Alice

Keep Alice and Anna lovely names ❤️

All are lovely so it's difficult.

Keep Anna and Anya (if you can't make up your mind, why not have Anna nn Anya as they do in some Slavic countries? 2 great names in 1!)

Sadly dump Alice and Zara - Alice is so timeless, that for some people it could seem dull, and others can't get past Zara the clothes shop or Zara Phillips/Tindall. Anna and Anya seem to have less associations.

I'd keep Zara and Anna, if it weren't for the fact that I know of 3 baby girls born in the last 8 months, and all of them are called Anna.

So I'd go for Zara

Keep Zara and Anna
Dump Anya and Alice.
All lovely names though.

Dump Anna and Alice
Keep Anya and Zara

Keep Anya

I think keep Alice and Anna.
Dump Anya and Zara. Mind you I do like Zara...

Just keep Anya

Keep Alice.

Keep Anya and Alice
Dump Anna and Zara

Dump Anya and Anna
Keep Zara and Alice

Although I like Anna too, just not as much as Zara and Alice

Keep Alice and Zara.

Keep:
Anya
Anna

Dump:
Alice
Zara

Alice -dump
Anna -keep
Anya- keep
Zara - dump

Oh that's rough!

I love Alice so would choose that.

I'd definitely dump Anya although I like it.

Zara or Anna?

I'd dump Anna because Zara is different.

Keep - Alice and Zara
Dump - anya and Anna