Advanced search

Amelia Shea or Sophia Shea ?

(31 Posts)
Jem2016 Fri 20-Nov-20 21:30:32

Shea is pronounced like ‘Shay’ and is the surname

OP’s posts: |
DramaAlpaca Fri 20-Nov-20 21:31:19

Sophia Shea. It's fabulous.

missmouse101 Fri 20-Nov-20 21:40:06

Sophie without a doubt. Not the awful 'mealy' sound that is Amelia.

IamnotwhouthinkIam Fri 20-Nov-20 22:11:44

Sophia is lovely and sounds cool with Shea. Amelia has a less nice to me.

Firebird83 Fri 20-Nov-20 22:17:03

Sophia Shea

MadameMiggeldy Fri 20-Nov-20 22:17:24

You obviously love Sophia. Go with Sophia.

Jem2016 Fri 20-Nov-20 22:29:26

Really like both. Feel that Amelia goes better with Shea, which was my concern in my previous post about Sophia x

OP’s posts: |
BlurredLinesBlake Fri 20-Nov-20 23:13:41

Amelia Shea sounds prettier

IamnotwhouthinkIam Sat 21-Nov-20 00:17:07

correction sound, sorry. Amelia has a less nice sound to me than Sophia.

TotalBitch Sat 21-Nov-20 09:40:08

Amelia goes better with Shea, but I prefer the name Sophia! Sorry, that's so unhelpful!

Chilldonaldchill Sat 21-Nov-20 09:51:00

With a very short surname like Shea it's my opinion that the full name would assume better if the first syllable of the first name is the emphasised one. So Amelie Shea or Sophie Shea sound better than either of your options.
But in all honesty once people have names very few other people say "oh that doesn't flow too well" - you just accept people's names don't you? I have loads of friends and colleagues who - if I sat down and analysed their first name/surname combo - I could come up with one that sounded better but I've never thought about it because they are who they are.
Go with the name you love. Neither of them is a horrible name, neither of them sounds ridiculous - pick your favourite and enjoy it!

ShirleyPhallus Sat 21-Nov-20 09:52:58

Do you have to explain how Shea is pronounced?

If people constantly mispronounce it the sound Am-ee-lia Shee-a doesn’t quite go. Sophie nicer

twinketoes Sat 21-Nov-20 09:53:30

Amelia Sophia Shea sounds great I think so have both. I also know of twins called Amelia and Sophia so to me they are equally pretty gorgeous names! My dd middle name is Sophie but sometimes wish it was Sophia it just didn't go with first name so well.

sherrystrull Sat 21-Nov-20 09:59:37

I think Sophia Shea is lovely

HillaryWhitney Sat 21-Nov-20 10:18:38

Sorry but I personally think Amelia is awful. Sophia is a great name.

twinketoes Sat 21-Nov-20 10:21:32

Also the Amelia I know is mostly called Mimi which really suits her and is a sweet nickname!

IsFuzzyBeagMise Sat 21-Nov-20 10:22:28

Amelia Shea sounds better to me.

firesong Sat 21-Nov-20 10:52:31

I don't like Amelia for some reason, but I like it when it's spelt Emilia. Not that it matters, it's you who has to like it! smile

I prefer the name Sophia but I think Amelia flows better with Shea.

Enderline Sat 21-Nov-20 11:25:35

Amelia Shea is much nicer.

TotalBitch Sat 21-Nov-20 11:29:02

Yeah, you could also go Emilia Shea. They are very similar when I say them, but I know Emilia goes down a lot better on MN than Amelia! Both are nice names. Popular, but then so is Sophia, so I don't imagine popularity bothers you very much. It wouldn't bother me either FWIW.

MercyBodle Sat 21-Nov-20 11:34:13

Sophia is fabulous with Shea, (better than Amelia), and is a much nicer and more interesting name than Amelia.

TickTickClock Tue 24-Nov-20 23:04:34

I prefer Sophia as a name, but Sophia Shea sounds far too close to Sophie O'Shea. Say them both out loud, one after the other, and you'll see what I mean.
I think you're setting your baby up for a lifetime of confusion and muddled identity.

(PS. How many more threads do you plan to make about this name?!)

JamieFrasersSwingingKilt Tue 24-Nov-20 23:35:04

I actually know an Amelia Shea! She's a child of a family friend aged 5. The name works well and everyone knows how to pronounce Shea.

JemimaTiggywinkle Wed 25-Nov-20 08:04:29

Agree that Sophia Shea sounds like “Sophie O’Shea”.

IsFuzzyBeagMise Wed 25-Nov-20 13:26:04

Sophie O'Shea sounds better than Sophia Shea (not that it's relevant as the surname is Shea).

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in