Sibling girl name for Grace and Jude.

[L0UL4]

Hi, I’m needing some help.
I have a daughter who is called Grace and a Son called Jude. I have found out I’m having another Girl. We decided on the name Erin weeks ago.
But then partners sister found out she was pregnant and has now chosen the same name and won’t change even though she is only 8 weeks pregnant.
We did like the name Edith too but I’m just wondering what are people’s thoughts on which name goes better with Grace and Jude.
Erin or Edith?
Or something completely different.
Thank you

[VintageGirl89]

If she is only 8 weeks pregnant she wont know the gender of baby and she may have a boy or change her mind on name by then anyway. Stick with the name you like and don't discuss names with anyone!

[SquigglePigs]

I think both work with the sibling names.

[L0UL4]

@VintageGirl89

If she is only 8 weeks pregnant she wont know the gender of baby and she may have a boy or change her mind on name by then anyway. Stick with the name you like and don't discuss names with anyone!

Thank you for your reply vintagegirl89.
I didn't tell her the name we had until she mentioned she had Erin as her girl name.
She has the name for a boy and a girl for when she finds out. But I don't want to cause any family drama if her baby is a girl and I name my baby Erin. But because she has told everyone her names at 8 weeks. People are going to think we copied her name as no one else knows ours.
Baby names cause so much family stress :/

[11MrsLuther]

I actually think Edith goes better with Grace and Jude, love Edith and shortened version Edie.

[RandomMess]

Romilly

[BlueJeanBabeh]

Both lovely names. What about Eve? Lois? Elin (too close to Erin maybe?), Gwen?

[mylittleavalon]

Prefer Erin to Edith, but as vintagegirl said she doesn't know what she is having yet. Other names you might like: Fern, Darcy, Elspeth, Helen, Iris, Lois, Sian, Nieve

[Curlysusie]

Love Edith/edie also Olivia/olive go nicely with grace x

[daisypond]

Edith goes better.
Esther or Hester are even better, if you like those.

[strandedatthedrivein]

Carrie first sprang to mind to go with your other DC.

Elodie? It's seems quite popular this year.

[L0UL4]

@mylittleavalon

Prefer Erin to Edith, but as vintagegirl said she doesn't know what she is having yet. Other names you might like: Fern, Darcy, Elspeth, Helen, Iris, Lois, Sian, Nieve

Iris was on my list but my partner ruled it out. I never thought of Elspeth. That's quite different. Thank you.

[Borris]

I know a Jude with a sister Eadie

[123Dancewithme]

Edith goes better.

[Whatsyourflava]

Edith and Erin are both gorgeous names but I prefer Edith and think it goes perfectly with sibling names

[Whatsyourflava]

Eliza?

[Whatsyourflava]

Emmy?

[Mish85]

I much prefer Edith. It's a lovely name.

[Iminaglasscaseofemotion]

You go with the name you prefer and screw the sil. If anyone asks you tell them no you've had that name picked out for weeks. I wouldn't be giving up the name I chose for my baby because someone else in the family, due after me decided they want that name too.

[Spied]

Love Erin.
Eva?

[Nellydean21]

Darcy.

[Herr2008]

Claire?

[LilacSloth]

Not keen on Edith at all.

Grace, Jude and Esme
Grace, Jude and Clara
Grace, Jude and Hazel
Grace, Jude and Caroline
Grace, Jude and Genevieve

[Chilldonaldchill]

Edith is gorgeous.
I'm not a fan of Erin to be honest.
I love the previous suggestion of Elspeth too.

[UnicornPug]

We almost used Eris, which I loved. It was too ‘ssss-y’ with our middle and surname though- think Eris Mavis Bestly. I was convinced she’d have a lisp if we called her that. It’s a gorgeous name though and fits with Grace and Jude. Means goddess of destruction which would have been apt for my dd.

[DepuisToujours]

Edith is much nicer than Erin imo. Erin is nice enough, but Edith is more elegant and goes better with Grace and Jude.

Erin's siblings are names like Holly, Amy, Oliver, Ryan, (I know this is nonsense btw and siblings don't have to match each other etc etc, but in my mind these names have a similar feel)!