Advanced search

Please please say I can have Clementine

(245 Posts)
IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:23:57

Hi MNers

A few years ago I posted asking whether I should name my baby Clementine. The answers were a resounding no.
I'm now back again, because I clearly can't take a hint.
So...our surname is Harrowdyne. Can I use Clementine (ending 'tyne' ) or am I once again deluding myself?
Feel free to hand me a grip if I need it.

OP’s posts: |
ArthurandJessie Mon 29-Jun-20 19:25:25

Sorry op I dont think it goes with the surname !

SavageBeauty73 Mon 29-Jun-20 19:27:05

You can't do that with your surname!

Ickabog Mon 29-Jun-20 19:27:19

I'm really sorry OP, but it's a no from me. You have a lovely surname, and Clementine is a beautiful name, but they just don't go together.

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:27:30

Ok. I'm 1 down so far...kinda expected it. But...I'm staying optimistic until the last!

OP’s posts: |
IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:27:56

Oh a few cross posts there...hmmm

OP’s posts: |
Toilenstripes Mon 29-Jun-20 19:28:22

Clementine is a great name. So what if it rhymes with your surname! She’ll probably get called Clem or Clemmie anyway.

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:29:11

I love you Toilen

OP’s posts: |
icedaisy Mon 29-Jun-20 19:29:30

I actually like it.

Clementine harrowdyne. Sounds like a character from a lovely wind swept book.

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:30:00

And you daisy.

OP’s posts: |
MikeUniformMike Mon 29-Jun-20 19:30:10

They rhyme and Firstname Surname doesn't flow that well, and outside the home that's who she will be.
A middle name won't break it up.

It's up to you OP. I wouldn't but if you and the father-to-be are happy with it, then no reason why you can't.

What makes you like it?

Bubbletrouble43 Mon 29-Jun-20 19:31:42

Didn't bother the parents of Dave Davies. Go for it op.

Ragtime69 Mon 29-Jun-20 19:31:52

I LOVE IT! excellent name

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:32:25

I always have going back years. Some inexplicable magnetic attraction that I can't explain. I just love it. But I hate that our surname rhymes.
Not that it makes a difference but our surname is spelt Harrodine.
Which is also massively outing since there are almost no other people in the country with that name. By meh.

OP’s posts: |
icedaisy Mon 29-Jun-20 19:32:27

I have just finished a book where the little girl was clemmie for short.

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:33:15

Ooh, this is going better than last time. I'm going to need to print this out as a keepsake.

OP’s posts: |
allfurcoatnoknickers Mon 29-Jun-20 19:33:25

How about Clemency instead?

MikeUniformMike Mon 29-Jun-20 19:33:44

What's wrong with Dave Davies? Are you having a pop at the Welsh there Bub?

I know a Steve Stevens.

Nonnymum Mon 29-Jun-20 19:33:52

It's a lovely name. But not with a rhyming surname.

thewisp Mon 29-Jun-20 19:34:32

I love it! I think it goes really well with your last name. And she can always go by Clem / Clemmie.

If you love it OP, don't let other people on here put you off. This is the website where owning a toilet brush is akin to murder after all.

IdentifyasTired Mon 29-Jun-20 19:34:38

Clemency I also really like but the association with death row and pardoning makes me doubt. Plus it's more out there than Clementine. I think...

OP’s posts: |
MikeUniformMike Mon 29-Jun-20 19:34:41

Clemency is lovely, use that. Top suggestion @allfurcoatnoknickers

Sober4Summer20 Mon 29-Jun-20 19:34:43

Clementine is my absolute favourite girls name and I think it sounds lovely with your surname. My husband really doesnt like it so we chose a different name for our daughter but I think it is really pretty and I love Clem as a nickname xx

GlennRheeismyfavourite Mon 29-Jun-20 19:35:16

Always loathed the name - will end up with Clem or Clemie- which rhymes with phlegm!!!

MikeUniformMike Mon 29-Jun-20 19:35:22

And she won't get jokes about satsumas.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »