Talk

Advanced search

Oliver, Rudy or Dylan

(53 Posts)
Irisincense Sat 11-Jan-20 18:10:04

We have to names our son next week. We can’t chose between Oliver , Rudy and Dylan. Opinions please! 🙂

Winkywoop Sat 11-Jan-20 18:12:15

They're all nice!

I'm sure people will tell you Oliver is too common (most popular boys name however many years in a row etc etc)

But I think that's my favourite of the 3 smile

Whynosnowyet Sat 11-Jan-20 18:13:14

Dylan unless you love Ollie and Rudy isn't my cup of tea. Rude Rudy.....

Zoflorabore Sat 11-Jan-20 18:14:44

When I was pregnant with ds ( 17 in March so born in 2003 ) I had 2 boys names- Oliver and Dylan smile and we went with Oliver NN Ollie. He really suits his name and often asks for more....

devilishlygood Sat 11-Jan-20 18:25:22

I have a Rudy...so I’m biased!! But Dylan was my second choice, and it only lost out because our surname has Ls and Ys that made Dylan a little tongue twistery

Ellmau Sat 11-Jan-20 18:56:40

Oliver.

PlantPotting Sat 11-Jan-20 19:02:57

Oh wow you have amazing taste I really love all 3!!!

HettytheHoover Sat 11-Jan-20 19:07:58

Rudy.

Refreshingly different. Nicknames like Rude Rudy could occur for any reason tbh

PlantPotting Sat 11-Jan-20 19:24:13

Yeh a name like Rudy isn’t startlingly unusual these days. It’s a bit different but if you’re going to get teased I highly doubt it’d be based on your name (whether it’s Oliver... Rudy... or even Fox or Wolf)

Lavenderblues Sat 11-Jan-20 20:03:39

OMG not Rudy - it sounds like a rude-y!

I like Dylan. Oliver is overused.

PlantPotting Sat 11-Jan-20 20:12:32

Rudy isn’t that shocking these days @Lavenderblues - it’s entered the mainstream and has increased from being outside the top 1000 names to being number 271 and is on the increase! There’s a Rudy at my daughters school and a friend of a friend had a Rudi (both boys) x

cptartapp Sat 11-Jan-20 20:17:15

Rudy is dreadful, the one I know gets teased. Dylan is, dare I say a naughty boy's name round here, so popular as it is I'd go Oliver.

yikesanotherbooboo Sat 11-Jan-20 21:03:32

I have a soft spot for Dylan. I'm a bit tired of Oliver and think Rudy carries a risk in that the little boy has to 'carry it off'.
Purely my personal opinion!

Thefaceofboe Sat 11-Jan-20 21:16:53

Rudy is my favourite. I hate Dylan and I don’t know why. Oliver is common but I do like it... I know 6 Olivers under 5

PlantPotting Sat 11-Jan-20 21:19:09

Impossible to predict who will get teased. There was a girl at my school with surname Dick- no teasing. But Abigail was constantly teased and called “Abi National Bank”

SaorsaSolasta Sat 11-Jan-20 21:23:58

My favourite is Dylan, also like Oliver. Not keen on Rudy

Grufallisfriends Sat 11-Jan-20 21:32:44

Rudy is awful! And full name Rudolph not any better...

I'd choose Dylan.

Grufallisfriends Sat 11-Jan-20 21:34:20

Rudy is so teasable as it sounds like Rude-y, someone rude! The opposite of Nicey grin

miamiibiza Sat 11-Jan-20 21:38:00

Rudy definitely

poppydaisys Sat 11-Jan-20 21:38:39

Oliver is so overused imo, it's a little dull.

Rudy is awful, sorry.

Dylan is quite nice.

Gogolego Sat 11-Jan-20 21:43:13

In order of preference
1)Oliver
2) Dylan
3) Rudy

But it was a close call between Oliver and Dylan

lopdedop Sun 12-Jan-20 00:59:27

Great names, all of them. My favourite is Rudy. I know one, grown up, he spells it with an I though. He's really cool, and loves his name.

Jossina Sun 12-Jan-20 03:28:18

Either Oliver or Dylan. Please not Rudy unless it's a nickname.

poppydaisys Sun 12-Jan-20 08:54:00

I know an older Rudolph who hates the nickname Rudy so is generally known by his full name.

Flymetothestars Sun 12-Jan-20 09:17:49

I love all 3 names

Favourites are Oliver and Rudy. Closely followed by Dylan

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »