What do you think?

[Lcw29]

We have these as possible names fir our second boy. It needs to go with his brothers name Josiah....
Other suggestions welcome
Logan
Jason
Liam
Daniel
Eli
Jared
Joel
Jonas
Theodore
Jamison
Milo
Lewis

[Leopardprintboots]

Josiah is such a gorgeous name. You have a great list for your 2nd

Logan - ok
Jason - ok
Liam - love
Daniel - love - a total classic
Eli - one of my favourite names, I adore it. Favourite
Jared - don’t like the sound of it
Joel - potentially too similar?
Jonas - same as above
Theodore - love this name
Jamison - I only know of it as a surname. Not keen
Milo - adore it - joint favourite
Lewis - adore it

I think you’ve got an excellent list there and I think you should stick with one of those names but I’ll make some extra suggestions below just incase

[Leopardprintboots]

Ellis
Miles
Seth
Cole
Wilf(red)
Otis
Otto
Eric
Barnaby
Sidney
Casper
Rudy/Rudi
Dexter
Nathan/Nathaniel - Nate
Blake
Bodhi
River
Angus

[Spied]

I think Jared, Joel and Eli 'go' best with Josiah.

[NoSauce]

Elijah nn Eli would go. Not keen on the others.

[Sherrybabyy]

I love Eli and Theodore

[Leopardprintboots]

I love Eli in its own right as a name, not so much Elijah though I like both

[daisypond]

Daniel

[mondler]

I like eli and Daniel. What about Jonah?

[MountainPeakGeek]

Eli "goes" the best, in my opinion, and it is a lovely name, but out of your list - if you hadn't mentioned wanting to pick something to go with your ds1's name - I'd say Daniel is my favourite.

[IckleBear]

Eli

[MrsBertBibby]

Eli never looks like a full name to me. Prefer Elias. It's nice though.
Daniel is great, can't go wrong with a Daniel.

Both go well with Josiah. Your J names are too samey, Logan and Liam I really dislike.

Theodore Milo and Lewis are all good (Theodore/Theo a bit popular just now) but I don't think they sit as well with Josiah

[TatianaLarina]

Like Theodore and Milo.

[EugeniaGrace]

My favourites are Theodore, Daniel and Eli.

Liam would be better as a shortened form of William (Liam on it’s own feels like to much of a nickname alongside Josiah which I find quote formal). The one starting with J while I’ve named in themselves, sound to similar to Josiah.

[Leopardprintboots]

I know a little Eli and he’s the coolest little chap ever - made me love the name even more

[BackforGood]

I was going to say exactly the same as @MountainPeakGeek

Personally, I think life is a LOT easier if you don't have the same initial as your sibling - so I'd rule out all the names you've got that start with a 'J'

[EleanorShellstrop100]

Logan - fine
Jason - very dated
Liam - just think of Gallagher
Daniel - fine
Eli - love
Jared - dislike
Joel- dislike
Jonas - like but prefer Jonah
Theodore - cute nicknames but don’t like the full name
Jamison- strongly dislike
Milo - cute
Lewis - don’t like but I like Louis

[BingThing]

I like -
Eli
Theodore
Milo
But above comment is correct Theo is really popular - I have one and I regret it a little bit to be honest - although I do love the name. We nearly chose Elias, Elijah & Asa if that helps.

[fantasmasgoria1]

Logan or milo.

[lowlandLucky]

Josiah and Daniel match

[lowlandLucky]

Ishmael would also match