Talk

Advanced search

Harper / Piper

(43 Posts)
bobmycat Sat 24-Feb-18 23:45:32

Which do you prefersmileThanks!

SuperBeagle Sun 25-Feb-18 00:06:03

Piper, definitely.

I don't like Harper at all.

AnyaMoondial Sun 25-Feb-18 00:06:21

Piper

bobmycat Sun 25-Feb-18 00:14:55

Also do you like / dislike them and why?smile

Awwlookatmybabyspider Sun 25-Feb-18 00:56:05

I love both but forced to choose id go with Harper.

JeSaisPas Sun 25-Feb-18 04:48:27

Harper. No reason, I just think it's a lovely name.

joystir59 Sun 25-Feb-18 07:01:50

Orange is the new black?

MrsGinger Sun 25-Feb-18 07:09:52

I love Piper

LascellesMoustache Sun 25-Feb-18 07:12:03

Piper. But mainly because I'm an Orange is the new black fan.
I like both though. I think it depends what goes best with your surname or other sibling names if you really can't choose between the two

EllieMe Sun 25-Feb-18 07:12:46

A bit too American for me. There are much nicer names out there.

17caterpillars1mouse Sun 25-Feb-18 07:13:43

I don't like Harper but Piper is nice. I only know 1 Piper who is 1

Countingsheeeep Sun 25-Feb-18 07:19:50

Piper....Harper is too celeb for me

WowserBowser Sun 25-Feb-18 07:26:42

I loved Harper until Vicky and Dave had one.

I would go for Piper I think

MumOfTwoMasterOfNone Sun 25-Feb-18 07:28:31

Just about to say the same as the PP. I loved Harper and wanted to use it myself, until the Beckhams used it sad

Annabelle4 Sun 25-Feb-18 07:29:12

Harper

coffeemugged Sun 25-Feb-18 07:30:35

Piper because I'm a Charmed fan.

I'd like Harper more if the Beckhams hadn't used it. They've tainted it imo.

SwinginFromTheChandelier Sun 25-Feb-18 07:31:04

Harper.

Yeahsureokay Sun 25-Feb-18 07:32:58

Yes, I just think of the Beckhams now, and would assume people are copying.

Piper is nice.

ChocolateCrunch Sun 25-Feb-18 07:35:50

Piper, as it sounds nicer than Harper to me. Also, the Beckham connection would put me off choosing Harper.

TERFette Sun 25-Feb-18 07:37:10

They’re both revolting, sorry!
But I’d sooner call my child after an acclaimed author than a drug mule, so it would be Harper for me.

Scrumptiousbears Sun 25-Feb-18 07:39:08

Neither. I'd never use a name a celeb has chosen. It just screams of chaviness. Piper also sounds like your are trying too hard. Sorry.

BoredOnMatLeave Sun 25-Feb-18 07:41:06

Harper sounds like a dog name to me, sorry.

Piper is quite nice

Elfyn Sun 25-Feb-18 09:10:13

Piper!

DancesWithOtters Sun 25-Feb-18 09:25:21

I don't like either but at a push I'd choose Harper because of Harper Lee, even though the Beckhams have tainted it.

Topseyt Sun 25-Feb-18 09:33:20

Both are equally awful. Sorry.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: