Talk

Advanced search

Niall or Tobias?

(37 Posts)
Icloud54 Sun 26-Nov-17 11:51:08

Which do you prefer? I like them both equally.

ColinsVeryJolly Sun 26-Nov-17 11:53:04

Niall is nice.

Tobias is rather pretentious.

Angelwendy Sun 26-Nov-17 11:55:13

Are you pronouncing Niall like Nile or Neil?
Tobias is nice and would more than likely be shortened to Toby which is also nice

DiegoMadonna Sun 26-Nov-17 11:55:25

Tobias. Only because I just don't like Niall.

Icloud54 Sun 26-Nov-17 11:57:16

Niall as is Nile, not Neil

Awwlookatmybabyspider Sun 26-Nov-17 12:08:52

If Tobias is going to Toby then Tobias
If not Niall

17caterpillars1mouse Sun 26-Nov-17 12:14:31

I love Tobias so much but dislike Toby

Niall makes me think of the one from one direction. Not really a fan

ThroughThickAndThin01 Sun 26-Nov-17 12:15:28

Tobias. Really nice name.

Glumglowworm Sun 26-Nov-17 12:16:00

Niall

BabloHoney Sun 26-Nov-17 14:08:30

Niall. Great name

midsomermurderess Sun 26-Nov-17 15:53:27

Niall but pronounced Neil.

BeyondThePage Sun 26-Nov-17 15:56:28

haha - both are my nephews names - the other of the 3 is Aiden.

HolyShmoly Sun 26-Nov-17 15:58:58

Niall but pronounced Neil

That's a different name hmm

Niall for me (I also love Aiden)

DullAndOld Sun 26-Nov-17 16:02:18

Niall, great name, and it's not pronounced like 'Neil' because that is a different name confused

DramaAlpaca Sun 26-Nov-17 16:03:30

I'd go for Niall.

Foggymist Sun 26-Nov-17 16:08:15

I discovered a few years ago that some people pronounce Niall as Neil, when I knew a guy called Niall by his family but all of his employees knew him as Neil confused I prefer Niall to Tobias and Neil!

lumpit Sun 26-Nov-17 16:08:29

Niall was definitely pronounced Neil in Scotland for a good wee while. My mid fifties DDad had multiple friends with the name when young.

PickleSarnie Sun 26-Nov-17 16:09:45

Niall can be pronounced "Nile" or "Neil". It's not a different name. Same name. Two pronunciations. Or will I tell my BIL he's been prouncing his own name wrong all these years?

TheodoreTheChipmunk Sun 26-Nov-17 16:10:13

Definitely Niall. Tobias would become Toby which is very popular and not nice IMO.

HolyShmoly Sun 26-Nov-17 16:11:21

Hmm, must be a Scottish thing. In Ireland it's always like Nile.

Niall of the Nine Hostages kidnapped St Patrick, so we learnt about him in school.

DullAndOld Sun 26-Nov-17 16:12:15

oh! well i stand corrected..smile
I have a brother Niall, it is pronounced by the family as 'N -eye - 'll

But hey pronounce it how you like.

DullAndOld Sun 26-Nov-17 16:13:38

yes we are Irish also Holy, well Brit-Irish..smile

midsomermurderess Sun 26-Nov-17 16:23:39

The Niall I know, Scottish, says it like Neil.

HolyShmoly Sun 26-Nov-17 16:35:06

So it definitely seems like a Scottish/Irish divide. Interesting. I wonder if there are many other names that are like that.

Patal Sun 26-Nov-17 16:36:50

Love Tobias with the no Toby

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now