Help me decide between two names

[MagnumAddict]

Opinions positive and negative will really help as feeling quite stuck......

Eva Rose or Edith Rose

Essentially Eva or Edith since the middle name won't get much of an outing!

I have a preference and DH has his but we do like them both.

Thanks!

[WanderingTrolley1]

Eva. Edith a little old-fashioned, I think.

[TheWoollybacksWife]

Both are very pretty but Edith Rose is my favourite

[ilivebythesea]

Edith would be my choice, although she's in Despicable Me, isn't she? Lots of girls called Eva, Evie, Eve, Evelyn around at the moment.

[BertrandRussell]

Edith. Lovely!

[Blossomdeary]

Edith would be my choice. Lots of Evas around at the moment.

[MadameJosephine]

Edith, pretty name and not as common as Eva

[bridgetreilly]

Edith Rose. Lovely name.

[DramaAlpaca]

Eva. I don't like Edith much, I'm not keen on 'granny chic' names really. I like Edie though.

[ASDismynormality]

I would choose Edith just because Eva is very popular. Rose is also probably the most popular middle name so that would sway me towards Edith too.

[ASDismynormality]

As above I love Edie too, would use it as a nickname for Edith.

[Laniakea]

Edith by far. Eva is so over done.

[2ducks2ducklings]

Definitely Edith. It's a lovely name.

[Onedaysoooon]

Eva

[Dweet1259]

My option for a DD (I had a DS!) was Edie Rose, so classy I loved it!

[missyB1]

Edith for definite, Eva is over popular at the moment.

[BraveBear]

I like Edith, but I don't like Edie - which I think is what the majority of parents seem to be thinking of when they pick the name. My house is two buildings from the local primary school and I hear "Eeeeedeeeeee" most days round school run time, so it must be pretty popular.

So if you want her to be known as Edith, yes. Otherwise I prefer Eva.

[MajesticWhine]

Edith definitely.

[Sugarpiehoneyeye]

100% Eva Rose.

[Susiethetortoiseshellcat]

Edith. Mainly because I like the nn Edie but not Evie.

[glasshalfsomething]

Love Edith!

[Synecdoche]

I'm the same as Susie ^^

I love Edith/Edie

[Glumglowworm]

Eva Rose

[Scrumpington]

I like Eva and I like Edie.

But I do not like Edith. Granny un-chic in my book.

[ImSoUnoriginal]

Prefer Edith but don't like nn Edie. I used to like all the Eve variations but as pp have said, it's now way to popular.

[Rainybo]

Edith with Edie as a shortening. I'm not keen on Eva.