Talk

Advanced search

Running out of time...

(29 Posts)
blahthisistoohard Mon 29-May-17 11:41:08

Girls name needed with five weeks to go, never wanted to leave it this late but we're finding it very hard.

Would be grateful for thoughts on the below;

1. Martha
2. Elodie
3. Edie
4. Lois

SuperBeagle Mon 29-May-17 11:43:25

I like Martha best, followed by Edie.

Not a fan of Elodie (but love the similar Eloise).

Strongly dislike Lois, which is Family Guy and Malcolm in the Middle to me.

Mothervulva Mon 29-May-17 11:49:21

Martha.

Sandsnake Mon 29-May-17 11:57:33

Another vote for Martha or Eddie. Lois to me is also Family Guy! Elodie I dislike - norm entirely sure why though.

blahthisistoohard Mon 29-May-17 11:59:20

Do you think Edie is strong enough as a stand alone name?

BikeRunSki Mon 29-May-17 12:01:53

I like them all, but always think that Elodie is too French if you have no French connections; also that Edie is really an abbreviation of Edith.

29Palms Mon 29-May-17 12:05:23

No, I think giving an abbreviated or diminutive name is short-changing them. You are not naming a child, you are naming a person, and should give a name that will suit them at any age.

Mothervulva Mon 29-May-17 12:05:35

I know a couple of Edies that are just Edie. I think it is a name in its own right now, although it's my least favourite of your choices.

blahthisistoohard Mon 29-May-17 12:07:43

Hmm @29Palms that was exactly my concern, but I don't like Edith. We did think Elodie could be shortened to Edie but I guess it will just become Ellie, which although it's a nice name I really don't want sad.

Mothervulva Mon 29-May-17 12:12:07

I think you can shorten Elodie to Edie.
Funnily enough my DH wanted Edith for one of our daughters, but I said no due to not wanting Edie as a shortening.

Thatextrainch Mon 29-May-17 12:16:05

I prefer Lois

29Palms Mon 29-May-17 12:17:31

Eden
Edwina
Edina
Edna

Probably not to your taste either.

Sophronia Mon 29-May-17 12:25:16

I love Martha, and Lois is ok. Not keen on the other two.

blahthisistoohard Mon 29-May-17 12:26:07

No sorry @29Palms smile, did consider Eden but I don't think it's quite soft enough for my liking (if that makes sense)

Sugarpiehoneyeye Mon 29-May-17 12:57:24

I'd go for Lois, from your list.
Lois Eden.

29Palms Mon 29-May-17 13:02:55

Martha and Lois from your list, then.
I've only ever met one Lois, although it seems to have increasing mentions on here, so may be coming into fashion. I think it's Biblical, like Martha.

Elodie is too frilly for me, and sounds like a chopped-off version of Melody.

smithin Mon 29-May-17 17:05:41

Elodie is lovely

Rockaby Mon 29-May-17 19:17:38

Love Martha. Not mad about any of the others, but Lois and Elodie are ok. Dislike Edie.

Epipgab Mon 29-May-17 22:44:35

I like Edie, not so keen on the others. How about Edana, nn Edie?

Ada
Eloise
Louisa
Melissa

blahthisistoohard Mon 29-May-17 23:14:19

So Martha the favourite?

CocoLoco87 Mon 29-May-17 23:29:56

Martha is my fave, then Edie as nn for Edith

Nonameyet1 Tue 30-May-17 08:39:40

I like Lois, it's pretty and not too popular. Love Edie too.

17caterpillars1mouse Tue 30-May-17 08:44:31

Martha - really pretty. I only know one
young Martha (3yr old)

Elodie - I want to like it, it looks pretty and has a nice sound, but I just find it a bit meh. Plenty love it though

Edie - I like it as a nickname for Edith but not as a stand-alone name

Lois - pretty in an understated way

Martha is my favourite, followed by Lois

DonkeysDontRideBicycles Tue 30-May-17 14:35:41

Lois or Martha from your list.
Edie in 4th place. Sorry I just think E D when I hear it.

(Eloise as someone mentioned earlier is cool and pretty).

Pemba Tue 30-May-17 14:48:16

Elodie is lovely
Also like Edie (if short for Eden or Edith)
Martha is OK and I know it's popular but somehow it seems a bit dull
Not that keen on Lois somehow

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now