Talk

Advanced search

Eliza as a sister for Ella - too similar?

(20 Posts)
xBIBIx Sun 26-Feb-17 22:16:26

We have a DS1 and DD2 Ella, l love Eliza for daughter 2 - do you think the names are too similar and 'unfair' (as hubby says) on Ella?
Also like:

Camilla
Alana
Lia
Carmen

gtyrfctsrght Sun 26-Feb-17 22:18:01

Too similar!

Lia is ok. I don't care for the others.

GirlElephant Sun 26-Feb-17 22:19:11

I also think quite similar. Alana is pretty however I prefer the spelling Allana

wobblywonderwoman Sun 26-Feb-17 22:19:22

Fad too similar .. Not mad on the others either.

What about Ella and Anna?

Sugarpiehoneyeye Sun 26-Feb-17 22:19:53

Love Carmen. ❤️
Ella and Carmen.

weasle Sun 26-Feb-17 22:20:20

Too similar. As are most of your others. Anna good.

MakeLemonade Sun 26-Feb-17 22:21:25

Way too similar. Carmen might work but the others are quite similar to Ella too.

Abetes Sun 26-Feb-17 22:22:07

Too similar but so are your alternatives, except Carmen.

CatsCruncher Sun 26-Feb-17 22:26:46

I don't think they're too similar. Might get confusing when you get letters addressed to 'Miss E XXXX' when they're older though. Not keen on Carmen or Camilla.

Jooni Sun 26-Feb-17 22:30:33

Eliza is lovely but way too close to Ella. Go with Carmen - it's fab!

KoalaDownUnder Mon 27-Feb-17 06:12:58

Much too similar.

OddShoe Mon 27-Feb-17 06:47:05

Too similar I think. Same with Lia, Alana and Camilla.

Sparklingbrook Mon 27-Feb-17 06:48:33

It is similar but it's fine and I don't know why it would matter. confused

SantasLittleMonkeyButler Mon 27-Feb-17 06:51:47

Yes, sorry, much too similar.

I like Alana and Lia but they are also quite close to Ella.

If you like Alana, do you like Arianna? Taking the "l" sound away might help.

Thelastusername Mon 27-Feb-17 06:56:19

They are both possible nicknames for Elizabeth. I'd say they are too similar because of that.

HelenDenver Mon 27-Feb-17 07:01:07

Yes, too similar, as is Lia

Rockaby Mon 27-Feb-17 07:01:36

Sorry, but I think they are far too similar. I know Ella is a traditional name on its own, but aren't they also both shortenings of Elizabeth? Aside from that Eliza is just Ella with an extra iz sound in the middle.

Carmen is nice. I'd go with that.

PanannyPanoo Mon 27-Feb-17 07:03:53

We have very similar taste.
Clara and Jemima were also on our list I think either would be lovely with Ella.

ICJump Mon 27-Feb-17 07:07:15

I have kids who's names are annograms. It is fucking nightmare. The second one took months to added to a goby database which impact health care, claims have been denied because staff can't see the difference.
It's shitty.
Still love the names but I might have chosen something else if I'd know it would be such a pain

SuperBeagle Mon 27-Feb-17 07:57:04

They're way too similar.

I also think Lia and Camilla are too close to Ella.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now