Talk

Advanced search

Jack or Caspian?

(39 Posts)
JuJuW06 Fri 10-Feb-17 17:01:01

Little boy is 2 days old. Looking for opinions on Jack and Caspian. Which would you go for? Thank you x

ThroughThickAndThin01 Fri 10-Feb-17 17:04:48

I like Jack, even though it's popular.

RedSauce Fri 10-Feb-17 17:07:06

I like Jack but I prefer Caspian.

Jooni Fri 10-Feb-17 17:28:10

I like both, but Caspian feels quite OTT. Depends which way you want to go really. I think I'd go with Jack personally.

Congratulations! flowers

MiniAlphaBravo Fri 10-Feb-17 17:30:12

Jack

JunebabyT Fri 10-Feb-17 17:34:16

Personally jack. I do like caspian but it is quite a brave choice. What about Casper too ?

pilates Fri 10-Feb-17 17:53:52

Jack, one of my favourite boys name.

Positivitee Fri 10-Feb-17 18:03:05

Caspian. Jack is terribly over used and surely has a lot of negative connotations?

Lehinch Fri 10-Feb-17 18:22:24

Definitely Jack. I think Caspian is a bit twee.

Congratulations on your new baby flowers

Sugarpiehoneyeye Fri 10-Feb-17 18:48:54

Jack.

BobbieDog Fri 10-Feb-17 18:49:52

Jack

Caspian reminds me of casper

Ilovecaindingle Fri 10-Feb-17 18:50:49

Caspian
Jack is boring!!

mum2be2boys Fri 10-Feb-17 18:51:25

Congratulations! Another vote for Jack. Caspian makes me think of the character in the Narnia series.

ArriettyClock1 Fri 10-Feb-17 18:52:55

Both nice but Jack - so common! I would go for something less prolific so it's Caspian for me.

rattieofcarcassone Fri 10-Feb-17 19:58:25

Caspian! I love Caspian, DH vetoed it for us though sad

KlingybunFistelvase Fri 10-Feb-17 20:09:43

Jack is nice, but I much prefer Caspian. It's lovely!

Ordinarily Fri 10-Feb-17 20:12:34

Jack was the no.1 boys name for years, so Caspian is more unusual. I also think of Jack as being quite nicknamey, as although it's a "stand alone" name too, it's traditionally a nickname for John.

Sophronia Fri 10-Feb-17 23:51:45

Both very different in style and feel. I definitely prefer Jack, it's much more down to earth.

Ankleswingers Fri 10-Feb-17 23:54:43

Love Jack grin

SuperBeagle Sat 11-Feb-17 02:37:52

Jack.

If it were between Jack and Caspar, I'd choose Caspar. I don't like Caspian.

octoberfarm Sat 11-Feb-17 03:22:25

I have a Casper Jack so love both names, but would have gone for Caspian had it worked better with our last name. Have you tried imagining him grown up, and thinking about which you feel would work better then? Sounds silly but I always think of names on a wedding invite, or saying I do, or introducing himself in a business setting, and that helped me get a feel for the long term too. Both are fab though, and congratulations!

lazydog Sat 11-Feb-17 04:16:50

Caspian. It's really unusual, but I do like it. I prefer it to Caspar too. Jack is just too popular and a bit boring...

BradleyPooper Sat 11-Feb-17 04:19:29

Caspian. I used to live a mile from the Caspian Sea....

CaoNiMa Sat 11-Feb-17 06:14:53

Extremely different names!

If you want him to blend in, go with Jack. Lovely strong but very popular name.

Caspian is gorgeous but it's a showstopper. Nobody will forget a Caspian!

Garnethair Sat 11-Feb-17 07:03:35

Caspian. Love the Narnia books

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now