help!! baby girl needs a name!

[user1483906389]

Hi, I'm due a baby girl any day now but really struggling with names. I have a daughter called Lucy and want a traditional name that goes well with this. I would like opinions on the names - Sophie and Amy.
Sophie - too popular?
Amy - too plain?
New name suggestions welcome too please.

Thank you.

[solittletime]

What about Alice?
Just throwing it in!
You'll get a better idea what suits when you see her.

[Katkin14]

Sophie and Amy are both lovely. I think Amy's due a comeback. Sophie never really went away.

How about Elizabeth? Classic and lots of lovely nickname options.

[MyCatLikesToSitInBoxes]

Sophie and Amy are both lovely. Another one which comes to mind which you might like is Clara.

[BangBelly]

Sophia is nicer than Sophie, I think.

Amy is nice.

Lucy and...

Emily
Polly
Chloe
Esme

[Rainbowqueeen]

Love your suggestions and those of PPs. I don't think Amy is a plain name at all.

Also want to throw Anna and Emma into the mix as options.
Congratulations on your LO!

[Moonshine86]

Pearl

X

[MerryMarigold]

Personally I really dislike Amy. I just find it very twee and nasal, not sure why. Also sounds bad with Lucy - too many 'ees' going on.

I like lots of other traditional names (though wouldn't choose myself) like Charlotte, Emma, Juliet, Mary.

I quite like Sophie and don't actually know that many little ones, though lots my age (born in 70s).

[dontpokethebear]

I think Alice too! Lucy and Alice sounds very sweet.

[MerryMarigold]

Oops, not Mary with Lucy - though it is a classic.

[Mrsjudelaw66]

Claire
Phoebe
Victoria
Emily
Charlotte
Marnie

[user1483906389]

Thank you everyone. It's so nice to hear opinions from other people. Some of them names were on our shortlist - think I will put them back in 😊 Does Alice sound too posh with Lucy?

[shaggedthruahedgebackwards]

Another vote for Alice & Lucy

Classy rather than posh IMO

[Sophronia]

I like Lucy and Sophie

[empirerecordsrocked]

Outing myself but I have an Alice amd Sophie and I'm an Emily, great names!!

[SoftSheen]

Alice is lovely.

Have you considered Harriet?

[1horatio]

Alice and Lucy is lovely.

I do secon Harriet. Or maybe Emma? Or Anne?

[Purplebluebird]

I love Amy! Sophia is also nice :)

[dotdotdotmustdash]

Hannah, Sara or Leah would be my picks.

[BellMcEnd]

Penelope
Caroline
Sally
Leah
Sylvia.

I love the name Lucy - was on my list but I had boys!

[AbernathysFringe]

Lucy and Esme
Lucy and Ellen
Lucy and Cara
Lucy and Jessica

[BellMcEnd]

(I also think Alice sounds great with Lucy )

[AlwaysTeaTime]

Alice and Lucy is beautiful!

[Yika]

Sophie and Amy are both lovely names. What about Sarah, Sara, Nina, Catherine?

Or Miranda, Elise, Natalia, Eve, Isabel?

[nuttyknitter]

I've always loved the name Alice but can't get past the association with the remastered Smokie track 'Who the Fuck is Alice'.

[Awwlookatmybabyspider]

I wouldn't say Amy was plain. Its quite unusual now. I don't think its ever been over popular.