Talk

Advanced search

In Scotland Wales and Ireland (UK bit)

(288 Posts)
JazzAnnNonMouse Sat 10-Sep-16 07:55:50

Is it more common to have a very scottish Welsh Irish name or a more English easily pronouncible one in a say a class of kids?
Does this depend on areas eg close to borders are more anglicised? Or just those with english connections (family possible moves etc)
There are so many names that are so beautiful that I'd never heard of before reading them on here but theyre almost never pronounced how I expected grin

CaitAgusMadra Sat 10-Sep-16 07:56:53

Ireland (UK bit)???? Can we assume you are referring to Northern Ireland

longdiling Sat 10-Sep-16 07:59:26

I'm not sure what you're asking really. Are you asking if it's more common to have Welsh names in Wales and Irish names in Ireland?!

Ginmakesitallok Sat 10-Sep-16 08:01:30

You do know that we speak English in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland?

SaoirseLikeInertia Sat 10-Sep-16 08:08:04

Areas that border NI aren't known for being very anglicised, seeing as they are all in Ireland (the non UK bit)

BikeRunSki Sat 10-Sep-16 08:10:54

OP, my brother teaches in a largely Welsh speaking part of Wales, and he says his classes are about 50/50 Welsh and English names, and a few from other nationalities in the class. His own children have English first names and Welsh middle names - with our Irish surname (although Irish connections are long gone).

wobblywonderwoman Sat 10-Sep-16 08:11:14

Ireland is not the UK and that's quite offensive

Notso Sat 10-Sep-16 08:16:33

I live in Wales though it's mostly English speaking in the area I live in. I find most of my Welsh speaking friends have called their child a name that works in English but spelled to fit in with the Welsh language. For example Anni, Harri, Elinor, Tomos.
Where as more of the children I know with Welsh names like Mabli, Deryn, Rhys etc are from English speaking families.
There are more children I know with 'regular' names James, Stanley, Poppy than anything else though.

wigglesrock Sat 10-Sep-16 08:19:06

Ireland (UK bit) ? Really? - Dicky, ill thought out title.

JazzAnnNonMouse Sat 10-Sep-16 08:19:21

Yes of course I know you speak English!

I'm asking whether it's more common to have a very Welsh Scottish Irish name ie one with spelling that requires previous knowledge of the name or language origin etc or whether they're becoming less popular over time whether there's a border change whether having English family influences etc as people move around more now etc.

I can never remember whether it's northern ireland or southern Ireland which comes under UK - Irish history is something I was never taught at school but I'm learning more and more about it recently (too young to remember any conflict). Ireland was always ireland to me... confused I didn't even know it was split until I was an older teenager! Crazy really.

I was born in Scotland but my parents chose a non specific origin name because they were moving back down south.

I've never lived in Wales Scotland or Ireland at an age to remember so don't know what it's common to be called there whether the 'harder to pronounce' names are becoming more unpopular which would be a shame as there are so many beautiful names often with lovely folklaw surrounding them. It would be a shame for them to die out.

Also is there anywhere that could tell me the language rules ie in aisling the noise is a sh sound - is that across the board that that's what noise those letters make?

I'm really trying not to offend but it's interesting and I'm ignorantrying and I'd like not to be smile

FrancisCrawford Sat 10-Sep-16 08:20:26

Lots of children in Scotland have Gaelic names just because their parents like them than for any reason of Gaelic heritage.

In the same way that lots of people have names that were originally French but are now just thought of as names.

And then some parents decide to call a baby girl "James".

JazzAnnNonMouse Sat 10-Sep-16 08:22:24

I thought part of Ireland was part of the UK? Is it not?! Is it part of great britain and they're different? confused

GruffaloPants Sat 10-Sep-16 09:00:40

Ireland is a completely independent country.

Northern Ireland is a separate country, part of the UK.

There is no such place as Southern Ireland.

Ireland suffered occupation and oppression. It upsets people to,have it regarded as part of the U.K. or called "Southern Ireland".

Maybe we need to pin this somewhere on mumsnet?!

JazzAnnNonMouse Sat 10-Sep-16 10:24:46

I'm really sorry if I offended anyone.
Thank you for clarifying gruffalo. .

Irish history clearly needs to be taught in england!

FrancisCrawford Sat 10-Sep-16 10:36:45

The U.K. Is the United Kigdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Ireland (the whole island) was never a part of Great Britain. It goes back to the Act of Union in 1800,

Ireland comprises 5/6 of the island of Ireland. Northern Ireland came into being at Partition in 1922.

Why isn't the history taught in English (and Scottish and Welsh) schools?

Possibly because the UK government doesn't come out of it very well?

eachtigertires Sat 10-Sep-16 12:25:30

It used to be taught as part of GCSE history - the conflict in Northern Ireland was part of the coursework section when I did it (at an English secondary school). That would have been in about 2007/2008.

Ginmakesitallok Sat 10-Sep-16 13:41:35

It's not irish history- it's basic geography!

Spindelina Sat 10-Sep-16 13:47:46

This is off topic, but what is the correct term for the island comprising Ireland and Northern Ireland?

Stevefromstevenage Sat 10-Sep-16 13:53:59

In Irish schools the 'non UK part' there is a mix of English/Irish children's names. The number of Irish names rises and falls as trends change but I think there are probably always more English names outside of all Irish speaking schools.

Funny how pages and pages of the Irish curriculum, primary and secondary school, are devoted to the lead up to partition and what followed. Maybe some of this knowledge would have been useful when voting on Brexit.

Stevefromstevenage Sat 10-Sep-16 13:54:58

Spine the island is Ireland.

Spindelina Sat 10-Sep-16 14:00:39

So OP's phrase 'Ireland (the UK bit)' is correct in as much as it refers to the bit of the island which is in the UK? And the shock is that she doesn't know which bit that is?

titchy Sat 10-Sep-16 14:03:05

'I don't know what countries are in the UK cos I was never taught at school' Jesus... Google it ffs and don't blame someone else for your ignorance.

MaudGonneMad Sat 10-Sep-16 14:03:43

Yeah the OP is technically correct.

The island of Ireland is partitioned into the Republic of Ireland (a sovereign independent state) and Northern Ireland (part of the United Kingdom).

In practise many people use 'Ireland' to refer to the Republic of Ireland.

Spindelina Sat 10-Sep-16 14:06:40

Just checking! Thanks.

Spindelina Sat 10-Sep-16 14:13:20

I've heard it called 'the island of Ireland' quite a lot, and wondered if that was the correct term rather than just a bit of clarification to avoid confusion with 'Ireland' in the sense of ROI.

I'm guessing that which one you think of when you hear the word 'Ireland' is a complex political / sociological question.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now