What names with these siblings?

[CheerfulYank]

I'm not pregnant! Just curious. :) And I want one more at some point

DS1 is Samuel Robert (Sam)
DD is Margaret Rose (Maggie)
DS2 is William Oliver (Will)

What "goes"? I know siblings don't have to match, but I would think it'd be strange to have another and name it Rayleigh or Haddix or something. (Which are kids I know. Damn Americans )

Bonus points for names with A and M. They're DH and my initials and we accidentally called our first 2 names containing those letters. We kept it going for #3. It's not vital but I don't know if another would feel left out without it.

[Tricerasaurus]

Nice traditional names you have.

Thomas (Tom) goes nicely with Sam and Will and it has an M and an A.
James
Edward

Elizabeth (Beth)
Amelia (Millie)
Catherine (Kitty)
Matilda (Matty or Tilly)

[CheerfulYank]

Those are good ones! :) Thomas is really nice. So is James. It's my theoretical go to for the next baby (along with possibly Emma for a girl) but it is also FIL and BIL's name.

I do love Matilda (and Max for a boy) but those both seem too "something" with Maggie.

I would also be open to putting a name with A or M in the middle if there were a first name I really liked that didn't have either. I love Elizabeth and Phoebe and they don't have them. Would Elizabeth make me look a bit obsessed with the royals, though? :)

[RickOShay]

Oh nice selection
What about
Anna

Audrey

Alexandra or Alexander

Miranda

Maud

Also like Rosalind, Joesph and Sarah.

[CheerfulYank]

I love Maud! I don't know if I want to repeat initials but it would be a nice middle.

Alexander has always been on DH's list. I actually really like it but it's SO popular here. Although most of the ones I know are at least 8 so maybe it's dying down a little. Especially give the fact that I don't even want to try to have a baby for two or three years! :o

Rosalind is so pretty! Anna and Joseph are out due to family members with those names.

[pilates]

Albert and Madeleine
Arthur and Molly

[Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost]

I remember you having Will.
How old is he now.
Joshua (Josh)
Francis (Frankie)
Joseph (Joe)
Gabriel (Gabe)
Charles (Charlie)
Matthew (Matt)
Micheal (Mike)
Nathan (Nate)
Richard (Richie)
Vincent (Vinnie)

Helena (Nell Lena)
Francesca (Frankie)
Harriet (Hattie)
Patricia (Patsy)
Winifred (Winnie Freda)
Charlotte (Lottie)
Suzannah (Suzie)

[CheerfulYank]

He's just one now, Lighthouse. Here he is! This was just a few days ago; we were watching a parade :) He's the squishiest, happiest little thing.

Hattie is one of my favorite names! I love Susannah and MIL is Suzanne so it would be nice but I don't know about having a Susie and a Sam. I do love the nn Zuzu though!

Pilates I love Madeleine but I know she'd get Maddie and Maggie and Maddie is too much. :o Still I do love it, especially after Madeline L'engel. (That has to be the wrong spelling but I'm too lazy to Google.)

[Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost]

Aww. He's so gorgeous. I could eat him all up.

[ConkerTriumphant]

I have a Susannah who is a Susie, a Susie-anna, a Zanna, a Shoshana and a Susannah-Joanna-plays-on-the-piano dependent on our mood!

[Sophronia]

How about...

Andrew
Benjamin
Charles
Edward
Henry
Isaac
John
Jonathan
Laurence
Louis
Luke
Nicholas
Nathaniel
Patrick
Peter
Timothy

Alexandra
Agnes
Charlotte
Caroline
Catherine
Esther
Emmeline
Eleanor
Frances
Hannah
Josephine
Julia
Louisa
Lucy
Rosalind
Rebecca
Tabitha
Victoria
Vivienne

[SabineUndine]

Anna Mireille
Alice Mirella
Annis Mirabelle

[Mottled]

Lots of names with an A & M

Adam
James

Maria
Miriam

[BikeRunSki]

Cheerful! I remember a thread like this a couple of years ago when you "weren't pregnant".

My Sam is about the same age as yours (maybe a year younger) and my DD is Amy. I think Sam and Amy go very well. Anna is also awesome, it goes with everything in all languages. Adam too.

[CheerfulYank]

Bite that tongue Bike :o I really and truly am not but I think DH and I both know we're not done. And I take forever to decide names so I might as well get a head start!

Amy is nice! I hadn't thought of that one.

[CheerfulYank]

Love Miriam, Mottled !

[Horseshoe1]

Amelia
Naomi
Jemima

Cameron
Callum
Benjamin

[MummyMaisy]

Alexander
Benjamin
Charles
Elliot
George
Nathaniel

Annabelle
Claire
Francesca
Georgia
Jemima
Penelope

[RickOShay]

Also thought of Louisa.

[Just5minswithDacre]

Annabel May just popped in my head when I read that. Any good?

I always think of your DC as tiny Pilgrims Fathers (and Mother) Bugsy Malone style.

And you can't have a first name that doesn't shorten now and break the pattern.

[Just5minswithDacre]

Louisa is a great name.

[GinnyMcginface]

We have five sons and Samuel is the oldest. Other names (and I've mixed in middle names too to save it being quite do identifying) are Jacob, Alexander, James, Gabriel, Joseph, Benjamin.

[Just5minswithDacre]

How 'not pregnant' are you exactly?

[CheerfulYank]

I almost named DD Louisa! I love Lulu. I honestly love Louisa Maud but it would out me as the obsessive Anne of Green Gables fan that I am. :o I love Frances as well. Any good?

Who are you 5Minutes?! I know I know you! I am totally not pregnant at all by any stretch of the imagination :)

[CheerfulYank]

Annabel May is beautiful and I love Annie. I may write that one down!

[RickOShay]

Love Louisa Maud. Also Frances. What about Dorothea? Great heroine.