Please critique these boys names, need to make a decision - our gorgeous son has been born!

[Whichonetochoose]

Our list is as follows, please critique and give your opinion:

• James
  
• Edward
  
• George
  
• Theodore
  
• Frederick
  
• Thomas
  
• William
  

His sister is called Elizabeth :) Thanks in advance!!!

[marmiteontoast76]

They are all lovely. I'd go with James Edward. Congrats!

[IoraRua]

Congrats!
I don't like Theodore, it just seems a bit too current iyswim. Lots of little Theos out there!
The others are all absolutely fine. I like Edward, Frederick and James the most, though I'm sure I would go for two siblings having the same initial. It's too matchy imo.

[IoraRua]

That should be I'm not sure

[Pixi2]

James or George.
Congratulations.

[ChippyMinton]

Edward

[MitzyLeFrouf]

Congratulations OP!

Edward would be my choice. Eddie is sweet.

[ExBallerina]

Congratulations!

Thomas is my favourite. Thomas Frederick.

[Kim82]

I'd go with George or Thomas. Theodore and Frederick are also lovely but there are loads of Theo's and Freddie's around at the moment.

[hattymattie]

James Edward, although they are all nice. Theodore would be shortened to Theo.

[Mummamayhem]

George is the best

[CakeRattleandRoll]

Edward
Theodore
George

In that order.

[CPtart]

William, Edward and James I love. In that order.
Not keen on the others.

[RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie]

All nice except George.

I'd put them in this order:
Edward
Frederick
James
William
Theodore
Thomas

[TheCraicDealer]

OP, why have you not attached a photo to this thread?! Smooshy newborn!

I don't think you can go wrong with any of them but James, George and William are v close to me personally. And Edward nn Teddy might be too cute to resist!

[smartyclogs]

James

It's lovely.
All the others except Thomas are a bit too popular for my liking, I know lots of boys with the names on your list. I only know adult James'.

[Error404usernamenotfound]

George or Edward biased

[CrumpetHead]

Love James or Thomas, ds2 is due Christmas Eve and is gonna have James as a middle name, we were going for Thomas James originally but have chosen something else now

[Lweji]

Any, although Theodore and Frederick are my least favourite.

[ChipsandGuac]

You have all 3 of my sons names there so very good choices!

[NameChange30]

James - love
Frederick - like (nn Freddie is cute)
Theodore - like (but popular as a PP said)
Thomas - a bit boring but OK
William - goes well with Elizabeth
George - NO! Don't like the name. Plus wouldn't give my son the same name as a recently born prince, for fear of people thinking I'm a huge fan of the royal family.

[NameChange30]

Oh I forgot Edward. Don't think it goes with Elizabeth.

[celtictoast]

They're all nice classic names.

Theodore Edward
James Theodore
Edward George

[TangledUpInGin]

William Thomas without a doubt

[MitzyLeFrouf]

'All the others except Thomas are a bit too popular for my liking, I know lots of boys with the names on your list. I only know adult James'.'

I know tons of little boys called James. I'm sure it's still a top 10 name. And probably always will be.

[MitzyLeFrouf]

I do like James though and would put it second in the list after Edward.