Talk

Advanced search

Selah or Sybil?

(21 Posts)
JanuaryJuniper Thu 29-Oct-15 18:33:04

Which do you prefer as a sister to Eli and Aphra?

I had a recent thread in Sybil, I know it's marmite but myself and dh love it and I think it goes well. I see it as elegant, others see it as major granny name though!

But, I LOVE that Selah is Hebrew like Eli and Aphra. It's meaning is also beautuful! It's pronounced Say lah btw.

Castledolorous Thu 29-Oct-15 18:58:43

I think they are both lovely names. I do like Selah best but it might be tricky for people who don't know how it's meant to be pronounced blush

JanuaryJuniper Thu 29-Oct-15 19:17:27

Yeah I could see pronunciation being an issue with Selah alright!

Though my ds heard me suggest it to dh and said uh that's an awful name how about Greta....I think my name obsession is rubbing off on him blush

celtictoast Thu 29-Oct-15 19:31:04

I like Sybil.

ApplesTheHare Thu 29-Oct-15 19:33:32

Selah is beautiful but be prepared for forever explaining how to pronounce it. I have a Sylvie which I thought was a standard name and people get it wrong all the time confused

Snossidge Thu 29-Oct-15 19:37:59

Selah goes better with Eli and Aphra. I doubt telling people how to pronounce it will be an issue because they will mostly hear the name before seeing it written.

JanuaryJuniper Thu 29-Oct-15 20:23:21

Oooh Sylvie....now that is beautiful!

villainousbroodmare Thu 29-Oct-15 20:59:56

I really like all three! (inc Sylvie!)
but Selah possibly goes better with your others.

mangocoveredlamb Thu 29-Oct-15 21:06:33

All gorgeous!!

(How do you mispronounce Sylvie? hmm)

WaitroseEssentialPancetta Thu 29-Oct-15 21:17:13

Selah looks lovely written down but telling people she's called sailor might get odd looks?

JanuaryJuniper Thu 29-Oct-15 22:24:04

It's Say lah not Say ler confused

Indole Thu 29-Oct-15 22:29:13

Sybil much better in the UK. And Saylah/Sayler are not going to be much different in lots of accents.

JanuaryJuniper Thu 29-Oct-15 22:33:29

Yeah I suppose some people don't really pronounce the r at the end of sailor which would make them sound the same.....though I secretly like Sailor as a baby name aka Liv Tyler, though for a boy!

ApplesTheHare Fri 30-Oct-15 10:12:17

Mango the most common mistake is saying 'Sylvia' and then after that take your pick. We've have everything from Salvia (?) to 'Silver'. We are in the north though, and January everyone with a northern accent would pronounce it 'Sailor' but it's still beautiful so don't let that put you off!

ApplesTheHare Fri 30-Oct-15 10:13:03

Also is you already have an Aphra you must be used to correcting people! smile

celtictoast Fri 30-Oct-15 12:33:40

I was thinking it might be confused for Sailor as well.

MrsCaecilius Fri 30-Oct-15 13:21:52

Saleh - too much like sailor to me too.

Sybil is pretty, although a bit too Downton Abbey, which is why I think I prefer Sybilla. Sylvie is a lovely alternative.

mrssmith79 Fri 30-Oct-15 13:44:43

Sybil reminds me of that movie from the seventies. I know that's not in the least bit constructive but I had to get it out grin

rainydaygrey Fri 30-Oct-15 13:47:24

Selah/Sailor sound more or less the same in my accent.

Nothing wrong with that though smile It's lovely and a good match with the other 2 names.

welliesandleaves Fri 30-Oct-15 13:58:01

Sybil always reminds me of the Chalet School books and I like it for that reason. I think other people will associate it with Downton Abbey which is another nice connection.

And yes, you will get people who will think of the Sally Field film or Fawlty Towers, but not that many I shouldn't think.

SeveredHeadsDragOnTheFloor Fri 30-Oct-15 14:05:05

I would automatically pronounce Selah as See la from just seeing it written down. That might get annoying after a while but I doubt it's a major problem.

I prefer it to Sybil although my judgement might be clouded by being of the Fawlty Towers generation so I associate it with older people.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now