Talk

Advanced search

Can't decide between these two girl's names

(33 Posts)
marmiteontoast76 Fri 07-Aug-15 14:39:59

Harriet or Rosa. I love them both equally for a first name.

Love the flow of Rosa Catherine and Harriet Eliza though.

Or if I love them both should probably keep them both.

Surname similar to Platt. So which flows better? Harriet Rosa Platt or Rosa Harriet Platt?

LibrariesGaveUsPower Fri 07-Aug-15 14:41:14

Will this be your only/last child?

I know quite a few people who regret using up their two favourite names on the first!

marinacortina Fri 07-Aug-15 14:41:55

Rosa. No contest.
Harriet always sounds a bit rattly to me.

marmiteontoast76 Fri 07-Aug-15 14:42:12

Yes my third and last child.

marmiteontoast76 Fri 07-Aug-15 14:45:45

Forgot to mention in post - the way I feel about Rosa is the way I felt about Eva ten years ago. Starry eyed. Is it about to rocket in popularity like Eva did? Not that it should really matter anyway.

I like names that work well internationally which I think Rosa does but not sure about Harriet.

Time to stop over thinking!

happymummyone Fri 07-Aug-15 14:47:21

Harriet, can be hattie while young but also a grown up name later on. It may be just me, but I associate the name with nice people!

Glindathegoodwitch Fri 07-Aug-15 14:48:32

Rosa is lovely. But I prefer Eliza Rose smile

Hadmeathello Fri 07-Aug-15 14:50:41

Love Harriet.

MameHootieBench Fri 07-Aug-15 14:53:39

Rosa for me, because of your surname. Harriet 'Platt' sounds like a machine gun going off.

SingForBacon Fri 07-Aug-15 14:53:46

I think Rosa is set to increase in popularity for sure, I know one 5yr old Rosa and two baby Rosas. I also know a Rosalind pronounced Rosa-Lind. It is a beautiful name though and it depends if popularity bothers you, I know it doesn't for many (and why should it, surely it is a good thing that lots of people like your child's name!!)

I prefer Harriet though. I love Hattie as a nickname.

CrystalMcPistol Fri 07-Aug-15 14:59:29

Harriet Platt sounds like one of those formidable mono-bosomed Yorkshire women from Last of the Summer Wine.

Go with Rosa. So much nicer.

MaddieUK Fri 07-Aug-15 15:06:07

I prefer Rosa!

DurhamDurham Fri 07-Aug-15 15:27:45

I love Harriet, but I also like Rosa........I'm aware that's no help to you whatsoever!!

Sophronia Fri 07-Aug-15 15:40:50

Both are nice, but I prefer Rosa.

IsadoraQuagmire Fri 07-Aug-15 15:57:02

Rosa, because it's one of my middle names and it's much prettier than Harriet.

LibrariesGaveUsPower Fri 07-Aug-15 16:29:52

I like Harriet a lot but don't like it with the surname. I think the t and tt sound odd together. Almost makes you want to say Harri-at Platt. Depends how similar the surname is.

So Rosa.smile

Romeyroo Fri 07-Aug-15 18:49:00

Also a vote for Rosa, it is lovely. I like Harriet but not as much. I like the nn Hattie, though.

Romeyroo Fri 07-Aug-15 18:49:28

But maybe not Hattie Platt!

AnnieOnAMapleLeaf Fri 07-Aug-15 18:50:02

Rosa. I'm sorry, but Harriet sounds like a 90 year old woman.

confusedandemployed Fri 07-Aug-15 18:50:14

I ADORE Rosa. But then, that's what I named my DD wink It still gives me pleasure every time I say it.

I've never been too keen on Harriet.

Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost Fri 07-Aug-15 21:29:27

Rosa. Harriets are everywhere.

marmiteontoast76 Fri 07-Aug-15 21:35:45

Thanks for all the comments.

Love the machine gun going off one!

MameHootieBench Sat 08-Aug-15 21:50:03

Was that what you were aiming for, OP? grin

sweetpeame Sat 08-Aug-15 22:01:52

I detest Harriet, it's boring and stuffy. Definitely go for Rosa.

MrsBungle Sat 08-Aug-15 22:07:23

Rosa. I don't know any Rosa's. I'm really not keen on Harriet.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now