Advanced search

Think you've decided on a name? Check out where it ranks on the official list of the most popular baby names first.

Olivia or Sophia?

(27 Posts)
mrsemmacrowden Sat 04-Jul-15 17:12:56

Hello everyone!

I'm new here and thought I would ask for some advice smile

I'm expecting another little girl and can't decide on her name.

I have my son, Elliot James and my daughter, Emilia Grace. I have many rules for deciding on a name; as you can see, their first names are 6 letters and their middle names are 5 letters, so I'd want the same for my 3rd child. Also, I wouldn't want it to begin with the same letter, as I have now used the same letter for both genders - if that makes any kind of sense! It's stupid, I know blush

We are fixed on the middle name Paige and are not sure if it should be:

Olivia Paige

Sophia Paige

Our family name is Crowden star

Any advice/other names that follow my rule, would be much appreciated! x

juneau Sat 04-Jul-15 17:16:18

Those are both VERY popular names right now. I've lost count of the numbers of Sophies, Sophias and Olivias that I know.

Personally, I'd go with something a bit less popular.

DramaAlpaca Sat 04-Jul-15 17:17:05

Olivia, then all your first names start with a vowel smile smile

DurhamDurham Sat 04-Jul-15 17:19:42

I think Olivia Paige is easier to say and sounds better than Sophia Paige smile

Stoneysilence Sat 04-Jul-15 17:21:30

Much prefer Sophia Paige...

barbecue Sat 04-Jul-15 17:36:25

Both nice but I prefer Sophia Page.

Sophronia Sat 04-Jul-15 17:49:40

Olivia Paige

shitebag Sat 04-Jul-15 18:00:56

Both sound good to me smile

If you're looking for suggestions how about Alanna Paige
Alyssa Paige
Helena Paige
Hannah Paige
Laurie Paige
Tamsin Paige

ashesandfire Sat 04-Jul-15 19:03:13

I prefer Olivia to Sophia (I actually know an Olivia and Emilia sibset) but prefer Sophie to both!
Or how about Isobel, Imogen, Juliet, Bryony, Saskia, Helena?
I don't really like Paige as a mn. It seems too modern and your other names are quite classic. How about Clara, Fleur, Faith, Eliza, Marie?
Olivia Faith or Olivia Clara sound good to me

swancourt Mon 06-Jul-15 11:02:49

Sophia Olive :D

Zakken Mon 06-Jul-15 11:08:45

Olivia is super-popular and I don't much like it.

I like Sophia pronounced in the old-fashioned way, So-FYE-ah. (This sets it apart from Sophie and modern Sophia which have been very popular in recent years.) Sounds well with your middle name and surname.

TheCraicDealer Mon 06-Jul-15 12:12:31

They're both so popular, I wouldn't pick either unless you're absolutely in love with one or other. Otherwise you're condemning your DD to thirteen years of "Sophia C" or "Olivia C".

Belazu84 Mon 06-Jul-15 12:43:33

Agree with the popularity thing. How about:

Serena Paige
Jemima Paige
Cassia Paige

iamnotaponceyloudperson Mon 06-Jul-15 14:08:46

Out of Sophia and Olivia I would go with Sophia as we know so many Olivia's and only 2 Sophias.

Love the suggestion of Serena, gorgeous name. Almost worth having baby no 4 (not happening!!)

wigglesrock Mon 06-Jul-15 15:52:11

I have both smile , although I spell mine Sofia. Both of mine are the only ones in their school year, although dd3 is starting school this September and there are 3 Sofias and no Olivias in an intake of just under 60 kids.

reuset Mon 06-Jul-15 17:10:20

Sophia, though I prefer Sophie

sweetpeame Mon 06-Jul-15 17:16:43

As you'll have already gathered from previous posters, both names are currently very popular. But that shouldn't put you off unless it bothers you. I have a DD with a top 10 name and a DS with a pretty uncommon (although not necessarily unusual name) and love both. I prefer Olivia. Not keen on your middle name choice though, I don't think it goes with either name.

reuset Mon 06-Jul-15 17:21:22

I'm not liking Paige either

Zakken Mon 06-Jul-15 18:02:59

The middle name is not up for discussion.

SkodaLabia Mon 06-Jul-15 18:38:54

I much prefer Sophia to Olivia.

Iliveinalighthousewith2friendl Mon 06-Jul-15 21:03:21

Olivia Paige Crowden Flows beautifully. Plus Sophia is getting tedious, now. Olivia not as heard of now a days
Your dcs have gorgeous names btw.

reuset Mon 06-Jul-15 22:27:29

The middle name is not up for discussion.

'Fixed' is not, not up for discussion. I'll comment on Paige as a potential middle, for the choices above, if I wish to, Zakkered <smiles sweetly>

Zakken Tue 07-Jul-15 00:02:31

I think we'll let the OP be the judge of that. The already-chosen middle name has got fuck all to do with you.

GlitterTwinkleToes Tue 07-Jul-15 00:15:43

I love Sophia Paige, but am very biased as it's Dd name grin

BikeRunSki Tue 07-Jul-15 00:26:07

Olivia, because Sophia will sometimes be misheard as Sophie.

Louisa Alice ?

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: