Talk

Advanced search

Mary Claudia, Mary Claudine or Mary Claudette?

(34 Posts)
FreedomOfTheTess Wed 24-Apr-13 13:02:14

We've starting to lean strongly towards Mary for girl bump (due mid-July) and would like to honour my late grandfather, Claude in the middle name spot.

Our options are:

Mary Claudia - obviously Claudia is the 'go to' feminine form of Claude, but we don't think this sounds great.

Mary Claudine - this sounds better but it still isn't great.

Mary Claudette - we think this has the best sound to it, but is Claudette a bit fusty?

The only other option is to use Claude itself. In France, the name Claude is both feminine and masculine, but I appreciate we're not in France and would therefore be met with puzzling looks if we simply named her Mary Claude.

Thoughts/comments? Are there any other feminine forms of Claude you're aware of that we're missing?

KittenofDoom Wed 24-Apr-13 13:06:19

Obviously it depends on the surname, but as it stands I think Mary Claudia has the nicest flow and rhythm.

rubyhaha Wed 24-Apr-13 13:07:55

go with what you like best as she is just going to be known as Mary anyway. so for that reason claude itself would be ok.

FreedomOfTheTess Wed 24-Apr-13 13:12:09

Kitten - good point - I meant to mention the surname. Starts with a W and is 10 letters long. Has a flow similar to Whittington.

MerryMarigold Wed 24-Apr-13 13:14:47

I think Claudia is good. It doesn't have to sound fabulous as it won't be used on a daily basis and Claudia is the best name of the 3 I think (personally, would go for it as a first name - Claudia Mary sounds fantastic!).

FreedomOfTheTess Wed 24-Apr-13 13:16:49

Merry - I do love Claudia, but Mary as a FN is a better fit with our DCs' names; Jack, Alexander and Sarah.

The more I say 'Mary Claudia' out loud, the better it starts to sound.

Ruralninja Wed 24-Apr-13 13:18:22

Ooo I like Claudine!
I've got to male relatives names for middle names and I really love it, so you could just go with Claude?

CruCru Wed 24-Apr-13 13:19:35

I like Mary Claude.

KittenofDoom Wed 24-Apr-13 13:20:06

Ah, then I'll stick with Mary Claudia. It flows well. Although I think Claude would be fine as well, tbh.

showtunesgirl Wed 24-Apr-13 13:23:17

I would actually go for Marie Claudette. Marie said like "marry" in the French way. I think it flows better than Mary.

abbyfromoz Wed 24-Apr-13 13:36:41

Claudette or Claudine... Claudia sounds very American whereas Claudette and Claudine sound more French. Also agree 'Marie' has a nicer ring with that middle name... Although i do like Mary as a name.

KittenofDoom Wed 24-Apr-13 13:38:27

Claudia doesn't sound American to English ears.

abbyfromoz Wed 24-Apr-13 13:45:06

I just remember reading babysitters club as a little girl and i think one of the characters was Claudia- hence the affiliation grin

KittenofDoom Wed 24-Apr-13 14:03:55

I agree that Claudette & Claudine are more French, but I don't think OP is looking for a French name. If she was, Marie Claude would tick all the boxes.

ithaka Wed 24-Apr-13 14:07:01

I would go for Marie not Mary, purely because I have a friend called Mary and there are no words to describe how much she hates her name - she thinks it is boring, frumpy and unimaginative.

ItsYonliMe Wed 24-Apr-13 14:07:23

Mary Claude. Lovely idea and a beautiful name.

abbyfromoz Wed 24-Apr-13 14:07:28

Fair enough- will let the OP decide. Just my opinion

Michellephant Wed 24-Apr-13 14:12:59

I prefer Mary Claudette.

I don't like Claudia but that's because me and my mum know someone we don't like with a baby called Claudia and my mum refers to her as Chlamydia.

:X

Michellephant Wed 24-Apr-13 14:14:52

I also don't like the name Mary and think it is a bit boring, but it's not particularly popular so at least there wont be loads of girls called Mary at nursery/school!

FreedomOfTheTess Wed 24-Apr-13 14:46:56

Thanks for the feedback so far. Lots to chew on.

To clarify, we're not necessarily looking for a name that sounds French, it's just I'm aware that Claude is both f/m in France, so in that respect it wouldn't be wrong to use it as a middle name for a girl.

NB: My grandfather was actually half French, his mother was French, so I could perhaps use the fact I have a tiny amount of French blood to justify using Claude and not one of the feminine forms! wink

FreedomOfTheTess Wed 24-Apr-13 14:50:48

Fair dos to anyone who doesn't like Mary, but DH and I love it.

As my work colleague said to me, hearing a baby girl called Mary would be a pleasant surprise to most, as opposed to yet another baby girl being named Olivia/Ruby/Grace/Amelia/Isabella. wink

thegreylady Wed 24-Apr-13 15:21:42

I love Mary and would use Claudia for mn however Marie-Claude has a good ring to it smile

olympicsrock Wed 24-Apr-13 15:34:05

I like Mary Claude or Marie Claude best. Good choice OP. Maybe outing myself but I'm actually a Mary myself (surname also begins with W and longish like yours>>. With fairly long surname I've always been glad to have a simple classic first name that everyone understands and can spell. I've never thought of my name as boring or frumpy smile

LackaDAISYcal Wed 24-Apr-13 15:43:17

Marie-Claude would sound better imo than Mary-Claude

Or forget Mary completely (a bit old fashioned, but not trendily so) and use Anne-Claude; I know an Anne-Claude and she (and the name) are fab!

fussychica Wed 24-Apr-13 16:48:52

Love Marie Claude, Mary Claude just doesn't sound right.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now