A girls name to go with Polly

[Phoebe47]

I have a daughter named Polly (age 3) and my second daughter is due in 5 weeks. Finding it difficult to choose a name. So far considering Isla, Josie, Harriet (Hatty for short), Anna and Arabella (Bella for short) but not sure any of these are quite right. We like them but do not love them as we do the name Polly. Any opinions/suggestions?

[exoticfruits]

Eliza

[catwithflowers]

Imogen

[BlueChampagne]

Zoe
Iona
Lucy

[custardsky]

Nell
Ruth
Alice

[wedontplaywithelectrics]

Harriet/Hatty sounds a good match to me

[Yonilovesboni]

Dolly

[MoonHare]

Love Polly.

Like Harriet best from your list.

How about Thea, Martha, Esme, Libby (if you don't mind another 'ee' sounding ending), Anita, Esther, Thalia, Tabitha, Claudia.

[GwendolineMaryLacey]

Sybil :)

[SpottyTeacakes]

Anna

[DonkeysDontRideBicycles]

Josie or Harriet sound a nice pairing with Polly.

I was going to suggest Megan or Fiona.

Have often suggested Phoebe on Baby Names Whether or not this is your real name it is nice to see a Phoebe posting.

[shockers]

We have a Polly, a Hettie (rather than Hattie) and a Josie in our family, over three generations!

I like Pippa with Polly (but I'm biased because it's my name )

[thewarmestowl]

Polly - Anna... Personally I wouldn't although love these names, just not together. Isla, although lovely, is very popular especially compared to Polly. Josie, Hatty and Bella are all great names.

My first thought, however, was Tess.

[Shybairns]

At school when I was a girl there were two sisters called Polly and Alice. So, Alice?

[sarahandemily]

I like Martha with Polly. They sound quite different but same no of syllables and dont both end in an ee sound

[dadofnone]

Anna?

[Ham69]

Moonhare's suggestion of Esther made me .
Absolutely adore the names Polly and Esther, just not together!

My suggestions would be:
Harriet
Tabitha
Jemima
Sylvie
Clara

[rundontwalk]

Jemima? Talia?

[Ruprekt]

Polly & Eliza

Polly & Beatrice

Polly & Ava

Polly & Grace

[wearingpurple]

I have a Polly. Won't say what her sister's name is for fear of outing, but some of the names on my list were Jemima, Alice, Florence, Eleanor. I like Isla on your list - or what about Iris?

[ppeatfruit]

Millie

Molly

Mandy? Maybe a bit twee but they're old fashioned names like Polly

[sleepdodger]

Nancy

[MoonHare]

Ha ha - accidentally genius! If only I could claim to have done it on purpose........ Polly - Esther.

[olivertheoctopus]

Loooooove Harriet/Hatty and goes v well with Polly. What about Nancy?

[wonderwooman]

Jemima
Verity
Cecily
Violet
Matilda
Marnie (my all-time fave girl's name - of course I only have DSs!)