Thank you for all your lovely comments (I was expecting a couple of negative ones so I am v pleasantly surprised!). I think we are edging back towards Rowan. I like the fact it's relatively uncommon but not too out there. It's also nature inspired and we love the outdoors, it also go's with our girl name choice (if we had another and got a boy/girl sibling set).
I love them all. You have great taste. I have Arthur on my list and might steal Rowan too. Rowan is much less common than Arthur around here and I like that about it. I would have Joseph but its taken by a relative.
Rowan! I have a Rowan and a Joseph... love both their Names but especally Rowan, I think because it is not so popular. Took a few family and friends by surprise when we chose it but although we took a few days to decide we have never looked back! GooD luck with your deciding!
Thank you to those who have replied. We were dead set on Rowan initially but had a bad reaction to it when we mentioned to a close family member (wish I hadn't disclosed it!). We have so many lovely little boys in our family group and close friends so a lot of boy's names have already been taken (William, Isaac, Jacob, Theo, Henry, Harry, Freddie, Alexander, Oliver, Tom, Daniel, James, Samuel .... The list go's on!). It makes picking a bit more tricky! 2 of the 3 on that short list are middle names of close relatives already!