Talk

Advanced search

Phoebe, Poppy or Holly?

(66 Posts)
babysoon1 Mon 20-Sep-10 09:54:37

Opinions gratefully received? only got 2 weeks or so left now! I know people think poppy suits baby more than adult, but surely that will change with the next generation as there are so many of them??

thighsmadeofcheddar Mon 20-Sep-10 09:55:21

I like Holly the best.

BuntyPenfold Mon 20-Sep-10 10:28:02

Love Holly, dubious about Poppy, not Phoebe because school calls them Beefy. Beefee, Febee, geddit? <sigh>

rachel234 Mon 20-Sep-10 10:34:18

I only like Phoebe. I find Poppy to close to Poopy and Holly to Christmassy.

hulabula Mon 20-Sep-10 10:42:57

Pheobe is lovely. Classic and underused.

Not keen on Poppy or Holly - they're both a bit too cutesy for me.

Rhubarbgarden Mon 20-Sep-10 11:14:52

Holly, by a long way.

Katz Mon 20-Sep-10 11:16:26

I'd have to say Phoebe

EauRouge Mon 20-Sep-10 11:17:55

Phoebe. I know too many dogs called Poppy and Holly for it to be a person name for me.

SirBoobAlot Mon 20-Sep-10 11:20:00

Phoebe.

mopsyflopsy Mon 20-Sep-10 11:27:56

Another vote for Phoebe.

Poppy and Holly are too trendy/fashionable for me. I prefer more classic elegant names.

cuppatino Mon 20-Sep-10 11:29:57

Phoebe, Poppy is cute but not sure for adults. Holly is meh....

emmyloo2 Mon 20-Sep-10 12:25:16

Phoebe or Holly. I like both of these. Probably prefer Phoebe.

Poppy is cute but not really for adults. Plus a little bit trendy for my tastes. The other two are much more underused in my opinion.

MarshaBrady Mon 20-Sep-10 12:28:06

Holly

Sunlightdances Mon 20-Sep-10 14:27:48

I know a few adults called Holly and love the name Phoebe. I think you're right about Poppy; I associate it more with cats than I do with people, and definitely more with children than adults.

timetomove Mon 20-Sep-10 15:03:15

I know an 8 year old Phoebe and she has never been called beefy so far as I am aware (although she isn't). She does sometimes get Feeble (she is a bit) but I think in an affectionate way. Also Fifi or Fee. Great name.

MyMamaToldMe Mon 20-Sep-10 15:12:32

Love Phoebe - great name

NiceCuppaT Mon 20-Sep-10 16:33:42

Phoebe is awful, I just don't get it!! Feebs = urgh!

Holly is nice but better for a Christmas baby.

Poppy I like, and she will be fine as an adult with all the Millies, Tillys, Daisys, Maisies, Lilys etc...

mo3g Mon 20-Sep-10 16:37:52

I only like poppy not keen on phoebe and think holly Christmas as others have said good luck

SacharissaCripslock Mon 20-Sep-10 16:44:48

Phoebe.

Rockbird Mon 20-Sep-10 16:54:51

Phoebe is pretty, Poppy is horrible and Holly is dull.

sophiesmummie Mon 20-Sep-10 19:20:55

I don't really like any, but if I had to choose, I'd say Pheobe. But it won't translate will into other languages imo.

Mumcah Mon 20-Sep-10 21:04:10

I love Phoebe

Rach109 Mon 20-Sep-10 21:41:43

Holly

DirtyMartini Mon 20-Sep-10 21:45:06

Phoebe -- classic (Shakespearean & all) and classy.

Poppy: used to like it as is quite pretty, but too much "of the moment" now, starting to get on my tits because of trendy associations. Bodenesque.

Holly: edging towards naffness

NotanOtter Mon 20-Sep-10 21:46:08

Phoebe classy

others not

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now