Talk

Advanced search

To judge when reading this article?

(227 Posts)
MissSunny Tue 08-Sep-09 09:55:21

Message withdrawn

JodieO Tue 08-Sep-09 09:58:17

Yes you are being unreasonable and rude imo.

southeastastra Tue 08-Sep-09 10:00:21

and where i live i have met some very well off courtneys and aleishas.

what paper was this in?

JodieO Tue 08-Sep-09 10:00:49

Probably the daily fail.

LaurieFairyCake Tue 08-Sep-09 10:02:04

This was talked about yesterday. Most people thought teachers shouldn't be taken part in daft, divisive un-scientific surveys.

TheDMshouldbeRivened Tue 08-Sep-09 10:02:04

chavs and pikies hmm

MissSunny Tue 08-Sep-09 10:07:23

Message withdrawn

Itsjustafleshwound Tue 08-Sep-09 10:08:17

Wasn't this some Bounty sponsored survey??

What is it with the UK and its obsession with class and benefits???

3000 opinions out of a population of 60 million - I don't think so ...

MissSunny Tue 08-Sep-09 10:11:49

Message withdrawn

Itsjustafleshwound Tue 08-Sep-09 10:18:41

You used some pretty emotive, derogative terminolgy in your posting which IMHO doesn't make it a discussion ...

kormachameleon Tue 08-Sep-09 10:22:04

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LissyGlitter Tue 08-Sep-09 10:23:26

Isn't pikey a really horrible racist term for Irish travellers? I've never heard it used in any other way...

Ineedmorechocolatenow Tue 08-Sep-09 10:23:53

Bloody hell....

I've been teaching over 10 years and have had my fair share of revolting girls. I've taught some revolting Emmas and Charlottes in my time (some gorgeous ones too), and some lovely Courtneys and Caseys. It's all a load of tosh.......

GooseyLoosey Tue 08-Sep-09 10:26:33

I read this in the Metro this morning. They had list for "worst behave", "most popular" and "highest achievers". Some of the names were on all 3 lists (like Jack and Charlie) from memory so not sure how much it can be relied upon. Interestingly, I don't think there was any overlap on the lists of girls' names, so I guess that people have stronger associations with many girls' names than boys' names.

claw3 Tue 08-Sep-09 10:31:15

Who made this list, Father Christmas

AxisofEvil Tue 08-Sep-09 10:31:16

The whole name/behaviour collelation isn't new. My mum taught and I remember her saying her heart would sink when she came across classes with high numbers of particular names as they tended (tended mind, not definitely were) to be worse behaved. Freakonomics has some interesting stuff on babies names and how the socioeconomic groups using particular names changes in time.

AxisofEvil Tue 08-Sep-09 10:31:57

*correlation

hanaflowerhatestheDM Tue 08-Sep-09 10:32:41

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MermaidSpam Tue 08-Sep-09 10:34:23

Love, you weren't doing too badly until the sarcasm kicked in ("We have 60 million teachers in the UK now then do we?").
Now I think you're just being rude....

SolidGoldBrass Tue 08-Sep-09 10:40:24

I wouldn't trust a survey like that anyway: it depends on subjectivity and class prejudice (people do not call children 'Chardonnay', the name is a parody). Bad behaviour covers a huge range - is the 'naughty' child the noisy one, the one with ADHD or the sophisticated little sociopath whose particular talent is dropping other kids in it? Which 'bad' behaviours were being assessed here? And how many of the teachers had the full range of social classes in their schools anyway and were not just making assumptions about the type of children they don't ever see?

MissSunny Tue 08-Sep-09 10:44:18

Message withdrawn

Nancy66 Tue 08-Sep-09 10:44:47

I read this - there was a short thread on 'in the news.' Certainly it doesn't take a genius to work out that the subtext is that middle class children are better behaved.

Still think it's bad taste though. I'm sure most 4/5 year olds are naughty given half a chance whether they're Hugo or Lambrini.

MissSunny Tue 08-Sep-09 10:45:52

Message withdrawn

Jimmychasesducks Tue 08-Sep-09 10:46:56

what is a pikey?

TitsalinaBumsquash Tue 08-Sep-09 10:49:40

Im a Charlotte and i was a little cow at school, i did everything i could to be expelled, i was rude, abusive, sarcastic, viloent..... i must have failed my 'upper class' name hmm

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now