Talk

Advanced search

To be horrified that you can get homepathic treatments on the NHS

(276 Posts)
brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:02:16

It seems extraordinary that with the NHS experiencing major funding problems and people being turned down for treatments on the grounds of cost that we're paying for people to have this kind of therapy.
If you read the theory behind it it's obviously bogus and the results of all the trials that have been done have consistently shown it to be no better than placebo.
The only way to justify it that I can see is as a form of faith healing and I wouldn't expect my GP to tell me to see my Priest least of all make a generous donation to the roof fund.

MitchyInge Fri 31-Jul-09 15:05:24

is it actually free on the nhs? we have stuff like that at our gp surgery but you have to pay for it

SausageRocket Fri 31-Jul-09 15:06:08

If you live in Hove, shouldn't you be hovelad ?

wasabipeas Fri 31-Jul-09 15:06:32

YANBU, it is such a giant load of nonsense, and when I rule the world, anyone who subscribes to that nonsense will be denied the vote
but prepare yourself for the wrath of the devotees on here...

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:07:43

I should be Hovelad but I guess I'm selling out to Brightons more glamorous image.

wasabipeas Fri 31-Jul-09 15:10:02

Mitchy, there is an NHS homeopathic hospital in London.
It is a few doors down from Great Ormand Street hospital and is funded by the NHS
When you think that Great Ormond Street has to appeal to the public to get enough money to buy essential equipment to save the lives of gravely ill babies and children, it makes me beyond furious that the homeopathic place receives state money

EccentricaGallumbits Fri 31-Jul-09 15:12:46

YABU sometimes homeopathy works. sometimes conventional medicine works. the most appropriate treatment fo the health issue needs to be chose whether complementary or conventional.

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:13:03

That's exactly what I mean. Disgusting waste of money. Surely scientifically proven and statistically validated interventions should be adequately funded before we piss money away on these snake oil salesmen.

ExtraFancy Fri 31-Jul-09 15:14:19

we will end up like this

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:14:41

EccentricaGallumbits - Homeopathy has been consitently proven not to work by rigorously administered trials. It's no better than placebo. A respirator for a premature baby is not a matter of faith or placebo.

SausageRocket Fri 31-Jul-09 15:14:44

Thought so.

bigstripeytiger Fri 31-Jul-09 15:15:31

I agree. There is no evidence to suggest that homeopathy has any specific effect. Providing homeopathy is a waste of NHS resources.

Pruneurs Fri 31-Jul-09 15:16:00

I think it's probably quite a shrewd idea on the part of the NHS.

It is known that placebo is a powerful tool.

Ethically, medics aren't allowed to knowingly prescribe placebo.

Homoeopathy is widely accepted by the public.

Either homoeopathy works or it is placebo, it doesn't matter which, and it is cheap.

It's win-win for the NHS.

[cynic]

fluffles Fri 31-Jul-09 15:17:53

i agree, if any 'complimentary' treatments are made available they should be those with some evidence such as acupuncture, massage or manual manipulation.

while i have some time for herbalism... homeopathy i have no time for AT ALL!!!

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:18:21

Homeopathy is not cheap if it requires a honking great hospital on Great Ormond Street. If people want a placebo they can buy it from your friendly neighbourhood charlatan out of their own pocket.

BadgersArse Fri 31-Jul-09 15:18:26

If i cry ONE drop into water then waft it abotu you, will it affect you no

its a pile of shit

arolf Fri 31-Jul-09 15:23:27

bloody hell, I thought the London one was being shut down, but have just been googling it, and it's being rebuilt for £20 million!
http://www.uclh.nhs.uk/Our+hospitals/Royal+London+Homoeopathic+Hospital.htm

WTF?!

It 's just such a load of bullshit, and yes it may sometimes 'cure' people who are not actually ill, but it's not real medicine!

According to the NHS choices website:
"Despite the lack of clinical evidence, homeopathy remains a popular complementary therapy and it is available on the NHS. In the UK, there are several NHS homeopathic hospitals and some GP practices also offer homeopathic treatment. Homeopathy is also practised privately.

There are several associations for practitioners of homeopathy which have a range of positions on the integration of homeopathy with orthodox medicine. See the ‘useful links’ section for more information about this.

Unlike doctors, nurses, and other conventional healthcare professionals, homeopaths do not have to be registered with a regulatory body. The ‘Complementary and Natural Healthcare Council’ is a voluntary organisation which practitioners can register with, but they do not have to. "

Gah! This is really not good for my health, I feel like my eyes are popping out in a fury. Maybe we should start a petition to stop free homeopathy treatment on the NHS?!

wasabipeas Fri 31-Jul-09 15:23:40

Pruneurs, according to the website for the London homeopathic hospital "it has recently undergone a comprehensive £20m makeover"

That doesn't make it 'cheap' in my book...

Pruneurs Fri 31-Jul-09 15:25:57

Brightonlad you miss my point

A couple of sessions with a homeopath could save the NHS from paying for multiple consultations with a GP - for low-level malaise, depression, etc. Whether it works or not (I don't believe it does), it is known to exhibit placebo effect, and that is what they are harnessing, no doubt!

MarshaBrady Fri 31-Jul-09 15:26:21

Yanbu it is a load of crap and annoying.

Pruneurs Fri 31-Jul-09 15:26:28

No agree about the hospital

arolf Fri 31-Jul-09 15:27:24

here's a nice petition

petitions.number10.gov.uk/right-to-choose/

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:28:41

Pruneurs - you're assuming that the homeopath doesn't charge heavily for their time and won't offer other diagnoses diverting the patient from more effective medication.
They're also completely unregulated so any scary witch doctor type could set up and pedal any old thing.

mrsruffallo Fri 31-Jul-09 15:28:45

It compliments conventional medicine by offering an holistic approach to illness.
YABU
Nothing to be horrified about

brightonlad Fri 31-Jul-09 15:29:54

arolf - She's asking for homepathic treatment for LUNG CANCER!!!! That's pretty f*cking brave!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now