My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

Going behind my SIL's back?

222 replies

UserLibra78 · 11/07/2020 12:20

Long story short my OH and his two sisters were given his late mother's house. One of his sister is keen to sell, the other is thinking of keeping it to rent but is not capable financially. My OH and I are actually thinking of buying another house to rent so that in a couple of years time, our ds will be able to either stay/resell.

I spoke to my dad and he is adamant about not telling them and just deal with the estate agent. I am in two minds about it as my OH and his sisters are close and I hate to put him in the situation where he will feel like he is "betraying them". However if I were to tell them now that I am interested in buying the house, they will 100% turn around and say they have decided not to sell after all.

I am sure if my MIL is still alive she will not hesitate to sell it to me, so that we will keep it in the family. But since she is gone my SIL's, who are both very vocal and domineering, will not hesitate in demanding a higher price from me. The reason why I am keen on the house is that it in in perfect location, very good price to rent and my mil had look after the house. I am sure this house is a good investment and not expected to sell anytime soon should we bought it. We will be using my OH equity to tide over any unexpected shortfalls.

What do you guys think is the best way to approach this? Should I follow my dad and jus lt offer the market price? Or should I let them know I am interested at the risk of losing this house and incur a higher price tag?

Thanks

OP posts:
Report

Am I being unreasonable?

204 votes. Final results.

POLL
You are being unreasonable
82%
You are NOT being unreasonable
18%
VettiyaIruken · 11/07/2020 12:26

How could you buy it without them knowing it's you? Won't your name be on the paperwork?

Report
lyralalala · 11/07/2020 12:32

That has to be your DH's call

If it will destroy relationships then it's not up to you and your Dad to ruin his relationship with his sisters (assume it's a joint purchase between you and DH)

Report
UserLibra78 · 11/07/2020 12:34

That's the thing. Eventually I will have to turn around and tell them I am the buyer, After they signed the paper so there's no going back, as per my dad.

I will be letting estate agent do all the work and not reveal till the end. It sounds really secretive and I hate it. On the other hand it will be the fairest way as they will not be sway by the fact that I am getting their mum's house.

OP posts:
Report
UserLibra78 · 11/07/2020 12:36

@lyralalala

That has to be your DH's call

If it will destroy relationships then it's not up to you and your Dad to ruin his relationship with his sisters (assume it's a joint purchase between you and DH)

Hi is not a joint purchase is mine (my dad is giving me the money).
OP posts:
Report
RedGirl99 · 11/07/2020 12:36

Sorry, but this sounds like an awful idea and also your name will appear on paperwork a long time before you sign the contracts so I'm not sure how you would intend to keep it secret until then!

Report
TitianaTitsling · 11/07/2020 12:37

But you are not 'getting' it are you? Unless you are trying to buy under market value?

Report
ChipotleBlessing · 11/07/2020 12:37

This just isn’t possible. As soon as you agree the sale the estate agent will send a letter with both your names on. And if it is going to cause a load of family upset, just choose a different house.

Report
Knittedfairies · 11/07/2020 12:38

I think you need to let this house go and find another to buy; I can't see this situation ending well.

Report
FieldOverFence · 11/07/2020 12:39

Jesus no, why wouldn't you just tell them you want to buy ? I don't know why you would be so secretive ? If a SIL did that to me, I would never look at her the same, even if selling the house was ultimaately a good thing for everyone

Report
Divebar · 11/07/2020 12:39

Absolutely do not do this secretly.... I would hate that it’s so sneaky. Just buy another house and remove yourself from this equation.

Report
Thesearmsofmine · 11/07/2020 12:40

It sounds like a terrible idea and will cause fallouts between your DH and his family. Why can’t you look at buying a different house?

Report
UserLibra78 · 11/07/2020 12:40

@ChipotleBlessing

This just isn’t possible. As soon as you agree the sale the estate agent will send a letter with both your names on. And if it is going to cause a load of family upset, just choose a different house.

That's the thing I want to buy my mother in laws house at the price they are willing to sell. That's the gist of it.

This is the house where my son has lots of lovely memory, and we would like to keep it and get tenants that will look after it ( which I can get) until my son can take over/sell (up to him).

It will be such a shame to sell it to an outsiders and lost forever
OP posts:
Report
PurpleButterflyAway · 11/07/2020 12:41

Why would they be unhappy with you buying the house?

Report
beautifulxdisasters · 11/07/2020 12:41

Your name will be on all the paperwork way before anything is signed and sealed OP, this is a crazy idea sorry.

Report
chinam · 11/07/2020 12:41

I wouldn’t agree to this unless your DH is happy to do some irreversible damage to his relationship with his sisters. Also if you are married, will the house not be half your husbands regardless of fact your Dad is giving you money towards it?

Report
PurpleButterflyAway · 11/07/2020 12:41

And why is it not a joint purchase? Presumably your husband wants a home that he can say is his too?

Report
Davodia · 11/07/2020 12:42

They can’t decide not to sell. Your DH is entitled to have his share. If they want to keep the house they will have to buy him out. If they can’t buy him out they will be forced to sell.

Tell them that by selling to you they can achieve a quick sale that’s guaranteed not to fall through, and they won’t have to pay any commission to an estate agent. Or they can be awkward and sell it to someone else but they’ll end up with less in their pockets. Not selling isn’t an option.

Report
Lightsareon · 11/07/2020 12:43

No, sorry OP but that's a shit thing to think of doing and would have major repercussions for your DH's family relationships. Why would they not sell to you if you were honest and said you wanted to buy it? I kind of get it tbh, I would have felt weird about other family members buying my Nan's house after she died I think, it's bad enough seeing anyone new living there but at least it's no one I have to visit and see how everything's changed. Regardless of their reasons I couldn't cause that kind of upset for my DH, there are other houses.

Report
Doggybiccys · 11/07/2020 12:43

If you do this OP, there is likely to be a family rift that will never heal. Are you and DH prepared to be cut off from his family, cousins not to see each other etc. Wether your SILs would be grabby or not knowing it was you is irrelevant as far as the relationship would end up. Are you really prepared for that to happen? Also, if you are upfront and everyone CAN agree a fair price, it avoids you getting In A bidding war with other unknown potential buyers. I think you should be upfront and prepared to sell and split profit if they ask for silly money .

Report
TidyDancer · 11/07/2020 12:44

Considering it's your DH's family who will be impacted by this then it absolutely has to be his call, regardless of where the money is coming from. FWIW I think your plan is mad anyway. If you want you and DH to have the house, you need to be open from the start and take your chances as to whether your SILs will be funny about the price. Don't be underhand to attempt to get a bargain here. Irreparable harm will be caused to family relationships and it will be your fault.

Report
RandomMess · 11/07/2020 12:45

The only way to do it is for you and DH to buy the other 2 out. In reality it will just be you but that is the angle DH will need to take.

As you are married it would be part of the marital pot anyway.

Report
GreenTulips · 11/07/2020 12:45

Put in an offer or get your dad too.

I see no harm in offering to buy something they are selling

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

WorraLiberty · 11/07/2020 12:46

This is the house where my son has lots of lovely memory, and we would like to keep it and get tenants that will look after it ( which I can get) until my son can take over/sell (up to him).

Your son didn't grow up in that house. Your son has't lost his mother.

Be upfront about what you want to do and listen to what they tell you.

It's not all about you and your son.

Report
UserLibra78 · 11/07/2020 12:47

Thanks for all your advice. If I let them know now:

  1. They decided not to sell after all and get tenants in - best option as long as they keep it
  2. They want a higher price from me - which knowing how much I want they will get, which i do not think is fair
  3. Other sister that want to buy decided she has the money after all - toughest result I am not sure whether I want to fight her
  4. There will be other houses but the main reason we toss and turn over this is because is my mil.


Guys will you suggest which is the best way to break the news to them
OP posts:
Report
WorraLiberty · 11/07/2020 12:47

@RandomMess

The only way to do it is for you and DH to buy the other 2 out. In reality it will just be you but that is the angle DH will need to take.

As you are married it would be part of the marital pot anyway.

The OP calls him her 'OH', so not sure if they're married?
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.