Talk

Advanced search

Sister bought house and didn't tell me

(352 Posts)
IndieRo Sat 04-Jul-20 12:09:23

So got a what's app picture from my sister last night with a picture of her new home. We speak most days so I was shocked and hurt that she never mentioned it. She said due to Covid 19 they didn't know what was happening but it's a brand new house so obviously viewed it and got mortgage before Covid-19. I'm just really hurt. Am I being unreasonable to think she should have told me.

OP’s posts: |
ReefTeeth Sat 04-Jul-20 12:10:57

Wow, how did she keep that secret when you speak every day shock

Yanbu to be upset.

vodkaredbullgirl Sat 04-Jul-20 12:11:30

Does she run everything by you?

Like she said, she wasnt sure it would go through.

SeasonFinale Sat 04-Jul-20 12:11:35

Viewings have still been taking place and also mortgages are pretty much all online applications anyway. So it does not not mean it has all been a long term plan.

Maybe she didnt want to get too excited, maybe she didnt want to jinx it. Maybe she thought her sister might be jealous and post about her online!

Freddiefox Sat 04-Jul-20 12:11:52

I think it’s very strange and indicative of a deeper problem within your relationship.

heartsonacake Sat 04-Jul-20 12:12:11

YABU. She wanted to make sure it was final before telling you.

Why would you be upset about that? confused

Shamoo Sat 04-Jul-20 12:13:50

YABU I think - maybe she didn’t want to jinx it, I don’t think it reflects on your relationship at all in its own. Are there other issues in your relationship?

Bargebill19 Sat 04-Jul-20 12:13:54

I think she didn’t want to get too excited incase it didn’t happen- and then have to tough it out with other people offering their sympathy. At least that’s what I would do as sympathy from others always makes me cry!

WiseOwl69 Sat 04-Jul-20 12:16:08

I like to keep things to myself and then share them when I’m done.

Just a touch of paranoia I’ll jinx things which is irrational I know.

Other thought which isn’t as nice... do you have a habit of criticising your sister’s decisions? If so she may have decided to present you with a done deal so she didn’t listen to your opinions on the house she liked.

I have friend like this. I’m sure she means no harm and thinks she’s being helpful, but listening to her shit on decisions I am halfway through making upsets me so I now just present her with the end product.

Ardnassa Sat 04-Jul-20 12:16:58

I think it seems reasonable - perhaps she was a bit nervous about it and didn't want to count her chickens until they hatched? I have certainly done that about some big life decisions and choices - keeping it from people I was close to until it all panned out or I had made up my mind.

MollieMaeve Sat 04-Jul-20 12:17:10

We’re in the midst of selling our home and buying another and we haven’t told anyone (not even my brother who I am very close to and speak to daily). I don’t want to tell anyone until it’s 100% a done deal firstly because I can’t be arsed with all the conversation about it if it goes wrong and secondly because I can’t really be arsed with conversation about it now. It’s one of those life events that takes over all conversation.

I wouldn’t take it personally.

CareBear50 Sat 04-Jul-20 12:17:59

I'd be upset too OP unless there's another backstory here

WorraLiberty Sat 04-Jul-20 12:18:09

Maybe she wanted to surprise everyone?

I'm not sure how you can turn her buying her home into being about you? confused

Just be happy for her not 'hurt'.

Sushiroller Sat 04-Jul-20 12:18:44

Def weird not to mention it. I'd be upset too.
Hard to say why he did it without context.

Do you own a home? Do you think she thought you might be jealous?
Or do you often give her a lot of unsolicited advice? Maybe she thought you'd be critical?

sammylady37 Sat 04-Jul-20 12:19:18

I did the very same with a sister of mine, albeit years ago, not during covid. I found the whole process of house-buying, applying for the mortgage etc very stressful and I didn’t want to discuss it with this particular sister as she is someone who would talk incessantly about it, nitpick and query every single thing and be critical too. So I told her when it was literally a done deal.

carorganiser1 Sat 04-Jul-20 12:19:17

Yabu OP there's nothing worse than someone announcing they bought a house only to find out that they actually only made an offer!!! I never tell anyone until the deal is DONE!

SpillTheTeaa Sat 04-Jul-20 12:19:41

Odd thing to be upset about. Maybe she wanted to keep it to herself. People are allowed private lives even if you do speak everyday she doesn't have to run everything past you. Just be happy for her and forget about it

ChristmasCarcass Sat 04-Jul-20 12:20:54

Did you know she was looking?

If you knew she was planning to buy a house and she just didn’t mention they’d put an offer in, YABU - maybe they weren’t sure it was going ahead.

If you had no clue she was even looking to move, then yes that is pretty weird.

SpillTheTeaa Sat 04-Jul-20 12:21:23

And what's it being a brand new house got to do with anything? Surely you'd view any house. Are you more upset she got a brand new house OP? Is that what you're more hurt about?

ScrapThatThen Sat 04-Jul-20 12:21:32

I applied for a new job and didn't tell anyone apart from dh and the dc until I was offered it. I think my family were a bit baffled, but like pps I don't like to go through the ups and downs with everyone or have to discuss it with them, I would have told them afterwards either way.

YesItsMeIDontCare Sat 04-Jul-20 12:21:39

YABU to think she should have told you, but YANBU to be a bit bewildered and upset that she didn't.

dontlikebeards Sat 04-Jul-20 12:21:51

How far through the process is she? Has she moved in? Then yes, it's a bit weird. Has she just had an offer accepted? Not weird.

dontdisturbmenow Sat 04-Jul-20 12:23:30

Did she think you'd be upset? Or trying to dissuade you to do so?

Ughmaybenot Sat 04-Jul-20 12:23:38

I think you’re being a bit unreasonable, but I understand why you feel the way you do. I tend to keep big things like that under my hat until it’s completed and a done deal too. It’s nothing against my friends or family, I just want to be sure before shouting about it... or texting about it grin

Ernieshere Sat 04-Jul-20 12:24:18

I did similar, I was so scared it wouldnt happen, I was doing it all by myself (apart from a toddler)

The application, the bank, the packing, the moving, the unpacking!

I couldn't believe it might be true, I might have some luck finally, so I kept it secret in case I failed again.

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in