Talk

Advanced search

If someone didn't post anything about BLM

(145 Posts)
022828MAN Sun 07-Jun-20 17:33:43

If someone you know didn't post anything on SM about BLM would you think that it was unreasonable or not?
I've recently had a disagreement about this but don't want to say just yet which person I am in the situation to get a clear picture.
So,

YABU - Yes it's completely unreasonable not to post about it

YANBU - No, not everything needs to be posted to social media

OP’s posts: |
LadyLeucadia Sun 07-Jun-20 17:34:47

Not everyone is performative. 🤷‍♀️

BigDramaShow Sun 07-Jun-20 17:35:48

No because posting on social media doesn’t have a major impact unless you have a large platform like celebrities. I’d rather they sign petitions, attend protests etc. (I’m BAME btw)

GreyGardens88 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:35:56

YANBU

lockitdown Sun 07-Jun-20 17:36:15

How odd. Why should everyone post it on their SM?

RiftGibbon Sun 07-Jun-20 17:37:22

If you're sharing a petition then fine, social media is a good place.
However it is not necessary to document every thought and feeling on fakebook.

BankofNook Sun 07-Jun-20 17:37:35

Some people like to keep their SM free of political and social issues. I wouldn't judge someone for not posting about it.

Dotty1970 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:38:11

No, that is their perogative isn't it.
I suppose especially if they don't usually post a lot etc..
Also some people don't know what to say, how to express in the right way without offending or coming across wrong maybe

Hedgehog44 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:39:30

I haven't posted a thing about it and me posting something won't make the blindest bit of difference to anyone. I don't think it makes me a bad person. The same group of people on my FB have competitive caring and I find it irritating.

Home42 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:39:50

My SM is apolitical. I share small details of family life, photos and things for the benefit of friends and family. I don’t post about BLM or any other political issues, doesn’t mean I don’t care!

Laaalaaaa Sun 07-Jun-20 17:40:16

I posted nothing about it and don’t intend to. I do not believe it to be unreasonable. Many people are only posting it for likes - lots bloggers and insta famous nobodies posted the blackout Tuesday yet continued to post all over their stories. Nothing sincere there in my opinion.

Justgivemewine Sun 07-Jun-20 17:40:35

Yanbu

I would estimate the majority of my fb friends haven’t posted anything but I know them well enough to know this doesn’t mean they don’t care. That’s just now they use fb.

FangleBangle Sun 07-Jun-20 17:41:00

I haven't posted on social media about this. I think anyone who says not posting about it means that they're clearly racist or whatever needs to sign themself up to the bloody Stasi and stop being ridiculous.
I don't put much about current affairs on my profile because I see it's usually utterly pointless, often divisive and clutters up Facebook with virtue signalling. Doesn't mean I haven't had discussions, thoughts, donated, changed my behaviour elsewhere. I just don't imagine anyone give much of a shit what I think and I don't want to feel under pressure to put everything I think on social media.

ScarfLadysBag Sun 07-Jun-20 17:41:03

I don't really notice who isn't posting about it 🤷‍♀️ I haven't because I don't think I have anything unique to say and I'd rather there was more space for black voices right now than another middle-class white woman writing #BLM. If I speak about it, I want to be educated and add something meaningful, not just tick a social media box of 'posted a status update so am now absolved of any further action or thought'.

SharpieInThe Sun 07-Jun-20 17:41:47

I haven't posted anything.

I have been following accounts and making a more conscious effort to listen. I don't consider myself a racist, however I have learned a lot of the issues stem from people who aren't racist not doing enough.

So for now. I listen and learn.

Payday this week. I will be donating.

BendingSpoons Sun 07-Jun-20 17:42:08

I didn't post anything as
1) I barely post anyway. I only have Facebook and post a few times a year
2) It's a bit of an echo chamber. My Facebook friends generally have similar views on things

I did however post on our work Facebook account (seen by clients).

FudgeBrownie2019 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:42:27

Is this like the not-clapping-on-thursday-night-shaming that happened a few weeks ago?

People can choose how they use their SM. I'd say it's just as important to have real life conversations about black lives matter as SM ones.

LockdownMayhem Sun 07-Jun-20 17:43:05

I would guess from the way you worded your op that you are the person who didn't post anything on social media... I don't think everyone needs to post every last thought. You can be supportive in many ways without everyone having to know about it. I didn't go out and clap for the NHS once, but I did spend many weeks sewing scrubs and scrub bags, which literally no one apart from my long suffering husband knows about 🙂

Lifeaback Sun 07-Jun-20 17:43:07

Personal social media pages are just that- personal. It’s down to people what they chose to post, some people might not feel like posting anything performative but may still be signing petitions, donating money etc. For this reason alone I haven’t judged any of my friends who haven’t posted about it.

Redcrayons Sun 07-Jun-20 17:43:34

YANBU - No, not everything needs to be posted to social media

and I’m not just restricting this to BLM movement.

Herecomestreble1 Sun 07-Jun-20 17:44:33

I'd be more concerned about the people who posted but didn't follow up with donations, signing petitions, writing to their MP etc.

sleepyhead Sun 07-Jun-20 17:44:58

I've been having lots of conversations with my children about what's going on, racism, why "black lives matter" is the slogan and "All lives matter" is inappropriate, Uk's role in the slave trade and the wider issue of the British Empire and colonisation and how we benefited off the backs of others even if our ancestors were working class.

I think that's more productive than a Facebook post.

lljkk Sun 07-Jun-20 17:46:00

I know some folk who refuse to put anything on their SM. I find it refreshing.

iklboo Sun 07-Jun-20 17:46:43

People don't all need to post about BLM on their social media. It's not compulsory and we live in a fairly free country where we can choose what to do. It doesn't mean you're racist if you don't wish to post about it.

Calling someone out on not posting about it is just dickish bandwagoning.

BadAlice Sun 07-Jun-20 17:48:05

SharpieInThe

I haven't posted anything.

I have been following accounts and making a more conscious effort to listen. I don't consider myself a racist, however I have learned a lot of the issues stem from people who aren't racist not doing enough.

So for now. I listen and learn.

Payday this week. I will be donating.

Pretty much this. I hven’t posted but am paying attention to what others have to say an considering my behaviour and the impact it has. I don’t feel like I have enough authority on the matter to contribute any original thoughts of much value and think there is the danger that if you just blindly share and copy, you aren’t actually taking the information in.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »