Advanced search

To ask if you would marry a man with no kids?

(129 Posts)
Celebrationschocs Sun 17-Nov-19 22:55:13

If you had 3 children of your own?

AnyFucker Sun 17-Nov-19 22:56:08

Is this a pretend question ?

CareOfPunts Sun 17-Nov-19 22:56:45

Yes, I wouldn’t marry someone who had them though. At least not if they were young/dependant children

Finchy19 Sun 17-Nov-19 22:57:26

I wouldn't marry someone with them.

dontalltalkatonce Sun 17-Nov-19 22:57:34

No. But I wouldn't remarry at all. And don't tell me, 'You never know.' I've been married 3x, there is NFW I am ever doing this again.

HeresMe Sun 17-Nov-19 22:59:12

Put it back the other way would a man marry a woman who had 3 kids.

Celebrationschocs Sun 17-Nov-19 23:00:31

@AnyFucker I've always said I would never date/marry a man without children, as I'd prefer someone with children so they know what it's like. But now I don't know,

ghostmouse Sun 17-Nov-19 23:00:50

I wouldn't marry someone with young dependent kids, been there done that and never ever again.

My current dp I'd marry him tomorrow if I could. I've 4 dc and his dd is grown up now with her own life..much better

AnyFucker Sun 17-Nov-19 23:02:38

Any other insights as to his character, behaviour, past experiences etc ?

No ? Just whether he has children or not ?

Celebrationschocs Sun 17-Nov-19 23:03:02

@ghostmouse you have 4 children and you prefer someone without children? Interesting.

BinkyandBunty Sun 17-Nov-19 23:04:01

I wouldn't marry anyone if either of us had kids under 18.

user1473878824 Sun 17-Nov-19 23:04:52

I don’t have children so I suppose my fiancé should dump me because after three years I just have no idea.

dontalltalkatonce Sun 17-Nov-19 23:06:45

Why the need to blend families at all? Can't you have a relationship with someone without having to live together/procreate/complicate things?

Ellisandra Sun 17-Nov-19 23:06:49

I’d probably make my decision based on the actual individual in question.

Foghead Sun 17-Nov-19 23:09:01

I wouldn’t marry again. Especially not while the kids were young.
Can’t be dealing with all that.

JumpyLiz Sun 17-Nov-19 23:10:30

I wouldn’t have married someone with kids.

VeniceQueen2004 Sun 17-Nov-19 23:10:46

If I broke up with my daughter's father, I wouldn't have any unrelated man living in the house with my children, ever. You never know anyone, really. You can think you do but you could always be wrong. What could possibly motivate someone to take that risk just for a relationship you can conduct perfectly well outside the child's home? And if the answer is 'to have more children with the new man', then I would also never make my child the odd one out in her own household by making her the stepchild and the half-sibling in a family where all the other members are related to each other.

But to answer your question, man with no kids if you have kids is a way better option for your kids than a man with kids of his own already (unless you intend to have more kids with him).

SignOnTheWindow Sun 17-Nov-19 23:12:22

I had 2 young DC and married a man in his 40s with no kids. I cannot find words enough to express what a wonderful father he is to them and husband to me. He did go a bit pale the first time he changed a nappy though...

HeadsShouldersSneezeandColds Sun 17-Nov-19 23:12:54

Maybe. I wouldn't rule out a relationship/marriage based on that.
Genuine question- those who were saying "not if they were young/dependant"- why?

dontalltalkatonce Sun 17-Nov-19 23:13:02

Oh, back when I had no kids, though? I wouldn't even date a man who had kids at all. Instant dealbreaker. Would be no relationship because I wasn't going there. If he lied and didn't tell me right away, extra fast dump. Nope.

VeniceQueen2004 Sun 17-Nov-19 23:13:37

@Celebrationschocs - why do you say @ghostmouse reply is "interesting"? She has 4 kids! Prioritising their mental wellbeing and physical safety, from a risk management point of view, surely it makes sense to look to reduce the number of new people they haven't chosen that she brings into their lives?

Celebrationschocs Sun 17-Nov-19 23:14:13

But to answer your question, man with no kids if you have kids is a way better option for your kids than a man with kids of his own already (unless you intend to have more kids with him).

That's interesting you say that, why is that?

HowDeepIsYourGlove Sun 17-Nov-19 23:16:07

@VeniceQueen2004 because children are never abused by their own family members are they hmm
You never know anyone, really could also be applied to your own husband then?

Boom45 Sun 17-Nov-19 23:16:12

I don't think I'd marry/live with anyone at all while my kids were young. I've seen a few of my friends go from happily dating to unhappily trying to fit a man they loved into their home and family and never yet seen it work out well. The closest anyone has got has been with men without children - then at least they haven't had the clash of parenting styles and 4 different parents to accommodate when organising holidays and working hours etc

user1473878824 Sun 17-Nov-19 23:16:14

@Ellisandra The most normal response on this thread. Everyone’s a paedo at best and having a life will ruin your childrens’, apparently.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »