Talk

Advanced search

DH wants our son to have his name spelt the Scandinavian way, AIBU to say no?

(205 Posts)
rdud Fri 29-Mar-19 17:26:19

We have agreed on a name we like, but there is the common spelling in the UK and then alternative spellings for other cultures. There is a spelling that is common in Scandinavia and DH would like that spelling (originally for there) but I think it will just cause an issue. Baby will have a british surname as DH took mine (does not like his father) and so that's our family name and because of this he would like it to reflect his heritage. I'm still not convinced that is better for our son who will have to spell it out. AIBU?

RatherBeRiding Fri 29-Mar-19 17:28:05

Depends on the name! I think if there is a common UK spelling and a less common Scandi one but they sound the same (or very similar) your child will have a lifetime of correcting how people have spelled his name.

Imfinehowareyou Fri 29-Mar-19 17:28:08

You're going to have to tell us the name or give a good alternative exame as it's impossible to help otherwise.

PolarBearDisguisedAsAPenguin Fri 29-Mar-19 17:28:23

Unless it is a really bizarre spelling, I think YABU.

Imfinehowareyou Fri 29-Mar-19 17:28:29

*example

GottenGottenGotten Fri 29-Mar-19 17:29:41

I'm kind of with your dh on this one, as long as it isn't ridiculous. As he has your surname, it would be nice for his father's heritage to be marked in some way.

Can you give us an example of how different the spelling would be? That might change my opinion!

grasspigeons Fri 29-Mar-19 17:30:10

I have to spell out my name which is one of the most popular names in my generation and is the standard spelling. So unless the spelling is ridiculous i think it doesnt matter and is a nice nod to your dh

SqueakyPigs Fri 29-Mar-19 17:30:13

What’s the name, OP? I think an alternative spelling could be nice

flitwit99 Fri 29-Mar-19 17:30:17

I think dh has good reasons for wanting that spelling so I would be more likely to consider it. It's not like he just wants to spell it that way to be different.

TillyTheTiger Fri 29-Mar-19 17:30:39

My friend had this issue with her son Oskar, her DH has some Swedish heritage but they live in England and I know they've found it annoying having to correct the spelling all the time.

drivingmisspotty Fri 29-Mar-19 17:31:05

I think it’s quite interesting to have it spelt the Scandinavian way and unless it will be really difficult for English speakers to read/ looks like a swear word I think it is a nice connection to that side of his heritage. Too early to tell how your DS will take it - he might feel fed up having to spell it all the time or he might relish being different/ the connection to his dad.

00100001 Fri 29-Mar-19 17:31:20

yep - we're going to have to know the name.

nocoolnamesleft Fri 29-Mar-19 17:31:23

Alternative spelling? Probably fine. Alternative letters? (I understand the Dano-Norwegian alphabet has 29 letters) Probably not okay, as will be so difficult to write correctly on anything official.

mindutopia Fri 29-Mar-19 17:31:29

I think it’s fine unless it requires a letter not in the English alphabet. I work with lots of Scandinavian colleagues and I can’t type their names properly because they use a letter that doesn’t exist on my keyboard. If it’s just an unusual spelling (no weird scandi letters), then I’d probably be fine with that as you all use your surname.

AuntieStella Fri 29-Mar-19 17:32:11

Depends on the name

For example - Erik is a dashing Viking, Eric is a sad character in a sitcom.

If you don't like a name, then keep looking for one you both live. If it matters to your DH to have a name which reflects his heritage, then those are the ones to look at

museumum Fri 29-Mar-19 17:32:20

It depends on the name. Something like oskar I think is fine - just say “with a k”. But if something that is really tricky to read when seen written I’m less sure.
On the whole I’d say it’s usually nicer to have a name that reflects a parents heritage.

Nevth Fri 29-Mar-19 17:34:32

I'm sorry but please make sure you don't do this. I was born in a Scandinavian country and have a name that is very very similar to an English name (and pronounced the same) but with two different letters. It is INCREDIBLY annoying. I look with envy at my friends with really unusual names - at least they are always asked how their names are spelled. I miss out on emails at work as people assume the usual spelling despite me telling them, I can't give my name to anyone on the phone without them getting it wrong. I'm considering changing the spelling of mine to the English version - it's just too much hassle in every day life.

Nonnymum Fri 29-Mar-19 17:35:17

I think he should have the Scandinavian spelling to reflect that part of his heritage, I assume you live in the UK and he has a UK surname so it's only right he should also have something to reflect the Scandinavian part of his heritage.

12thofnever Fri 29-Mar-19 17:38:19

Agree with others, as long as it’s not completely ridiculous and difficult then it would be a nice thing.
If you really don’t want it then as a PP said, you both need to agree on a name you both like

rdud Fri 29-Mar-19 17:38:43

An example is Joseph / Josef

LizzieBananas Fri 29-Mar-19 17:40:13

I agree with above posters.

Unusual letters like ø å will be tricky. Otherwise a spelling variation is perfectly normal.

SilverySurfer Fri 29-Mar-19 17:40:19

Is it something like Harald/Harold or Erik/Eric? If your DH is Scandinavian it wouldn't be unreasonable for him to want your son to have a Scandinavian name. Maybe you could have first name Scandi and middle name English then reversed if/when you have a second child?

Merril Fri 29-Mar-19 17:41:17

I'd go with what your DH wants, tbh. He's taken your surname so I agree it's a nice nod to his heritage (unless it's something totally bizarre and becomes a rude word or something).

For the record, I have a quite common everyday name that can be spelled about 10 different ways and people sometimes spell it wrong/ask me to spell (including MIL who has known me around 18 years). It's not really a problem.

Tilikum Fri 29-Mar-19 17:42:37

I think having the Scandi spelling would be a nice way to reflect his heritage (as long as the name isn't a rude word in English).

Normandy144 Fri 29-Mar-19 17:45:16

I think you have good reason to use the Scandinavian spelling as a nod to your DH and your sons heritage. As he doesn't get to use his surname (completely his own choice of course) then i think this makes absolute sense.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »