Talk

Advanced search

The most important virtue

(51 Posts)
Flyingfish2019 Wed 06-Mar-19 21:46:48

What is the most important virtue to your mind. If a good fairy gave you one perfect virtue (like perfect courage, perfect patience, perfect diligence, perfect loyality, perfect intelligence, perfect .... and so on) which would you choose and which would you choose for your children. Would it be the same one? As for me: not sure. Maybe I decide later after having read other people’s answers.

PBo83 Thu 07-Mar-19 14:04:25

Modesty and humility.

Things I fear that our current generation may grow up lacking thanks to the forced-narcissism brought about by social media and an evermore 'child-centric' society.

Damntheman Thu 07-Mar-19 13:24:56

I would choose perfect patience, for both my children and I. They can have an imperfect kindless, but a wealth of patience would make their lives so much easier/happier. My father had what felt like an infinite perfect patience and I miss that comfort.

thecatsthecats Thu 07-Mar-19 12:55:05

I second perfect wisdom. In fact, I find this an oldie but a goodie:

"Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
Courage to change the things I can,
And wisdom to know the difference."

Kindness is a weird one, not because it's not important, but because misplaced kindness can lead to inability (in children, over babied) or exploitation - which is why I put the above first. If you apply those principles first, doing the kind thing is just as often the wise or courageous thing.

kayaholly Thu 07-Mar-19 11:43:10

Prismguile I read that and went oooh that's a point and someone else said about ISIS and those are both true, then my inner arsehole pointed out that the thread was about "perfect" qualities", those are examples of misplaced Loyalty not perfect Loyalty grin but yes I take your point, I like the idea of your perfect honour it probably describes it better than loyalty. I just like people to have a good moral basis :D

Connieston Wed 06-Mar-19 23:18:50

Punctuality. Dear God why can't grown adults arrive to an agreed time.

PrismGuile Wed 06-Mar-19 23:18:07

The most important virtue is honour.

It doesn't hold as much fallibility as the others - if you're too kind you risk being destroyed under it, too honest and you may hurt people or yourself, too loyal and you become a sycophant, wisdom without temperance can lead to arrogance, too disciplined and you become unsympathetic, too much forgiveness and you're trampled on.

But to act with perfect honour, you will always know you have done the right thing.

EarringsandLipstick Wed 06-Mar-19 23:16:50

Great question! For me...calmness.
If I could stay calm, so many situations would resolve themselves. I'm improving, I think.

PrismGuile Wed 06-Mar-19 23:12:35

@kayaholly lots of people were perfectly loyal to hitler... loyalty isn't always good.

CallipygianFancier Wed 06-Mar-19 23:10:22

I'm with blackteaplease, Integrity.

RickOShay Wed 06-Mar-19 23:09:58

Kindness is not weakness.
If people were kind or kinder, the need for courage or resilience would be less.

pallisers Wed 06-Mar-19 23:09:36

I value kindness but I think the giving tree is crap and agreed with your thread. Women in particular do have to watch out for how society wants to kidnap and exploit their generosity and kindness.

I regularly read stuff on MN where women are describing situations which I wouldn't tolerate for a minute - and neither would my mother, sister or father - yet all are very kind.

willstarttomorrow Wed 06-Mar-19 23:00:34

OMGithurts - whilst I agree to some extent that kindness is sometimes be taken advantage of I think that that the example you give is far more complex. On a very simple level if someone lets you jump in front of them in a supermarket queue, lets you go ahead in the public toilets because your toddler is crossing their legs or a stranger just has a chat with you when you are having a really bad day this is kindness. Good people (and slightly flawed people) find themselves in positions where they are abused and exploited. My professional experience and supporting pyschological assements have never once concluded kindness to be the presenting concern. Typically there is some level of neediness in the victim to be loved and save which perpetuates a continued relationship. This is not victim blaming, there is likely to be a reason for an individuals emotional and mental health. Perpetrators pray on this and it is not a healthy relationship between equals. However kindness in itself does not make you a vicTim.

Flyingfish2019 Wed 06-Mar-19 22:57:38

BTW I started a thread about the giving tree. Igitte be interesting from a too much kindness perspective. www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3495583-AIBU-to-think-that-The-Giving-Tree-teaches-children-the-wrong-lesson

Stompythedinosaur Wed 06-Mar-19 22:57:21

I would choose courage. I think without it you don't have agency over your life, so you can't choose whether to be kind/loyal/whatever.

I like the Anais Nin quote "Life shrinks or expands in proportion to one's courage".

SeaweedDress Wed 06-Mar-19 22:53:42

Amen, tattooq.

Ohyesiam Wed 06-Mar-19 22:44:31

I have good self esteem and am more likely to say the second

Flyingfish2019 Wed 06-Mar-19 22:41:59

@OhyesIam Well. I am not sure. Let’s say that I am the most famous and renowned expert on... let’s say klingon language.

As a person with selfesteem I would say: Yes, of course this is my field of expertise and i am one of the most renowned experts in this fields
But as a modest person would say: Well, yes, I may speak a little klingon

tattooq Wed 06-Mar-19 22:40:37

No way would I chose kindness, for myself or DD. Women are already socialised to be kind to their own detriment, I certainly have been. No, I'd like my DD to have courage, the courage to leave a bad relationship/job/situation and to put herself forward for things that she otherwise might not, to advocate for herself and stand up for what she believes in.

WFTisgoingoninmyhead Wed 06-Mar-19 22:38:33

Perfect Respect

SeaweedDress Wed 06-Mar-19 22:37:18

No, it doesn’t, I agree, pallisers — and I’m also married to a kind man — but it’s heavily gendered in its social manifestation to the extent that female kindness is taken for granted, which is not negligible when it comes to assumptions about women ‘naturally’ being unpaid carers, and the low status of caring jobs, for instance.

Ohyesiam Wed 06-Mar-19 22:36:49

I am not sure if perfect self-esteem traditionally would be considered a virtue, wouldn’t perfect modesty be one... and they cannot both be virtues at the same time...
How come? One can feel good about oneself and be modest too. Or am I missing something?

VikingVolva Wed 06-Mar-19 22:33:57

Kindness is not a synonym for subservience.

It is a virtue in both sexes. Much under-rated, and top of my list too.

pallisers Wed 06-Mar-19 22:32:16

Agree entirely, OMG. ‘Kindness’ is socialised into women from a young age.

Being kind doesn't have to mean being a mug. I grew up in a kind home - and also one in which I was given very good boundaries, very good understanding of not putting up with shit, a strong sense of my own self-worth. I actively chose a kind man as a husband because my dad was one of the kindest men I ever met. My sister did the same. I value kindness in myself and in others and have never been treated like a mug.

SeaweedDress Wed 06-Mar-19 22:29:02

Agree entirely, OMG. ‘Kindness’ is socialised into women from a young age.

RickOShay Wed 06-Mar-19 22:28:52

Kindness includes being kind to yourself
I think it’s the most important thing
be kind, that’s it really grin

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »