Talk

Advanced search

Married name is same as DSD's mum and she objects

(377 Posts)
Breakfastclubcrazy Sat 06-Oct-18 07:55:24

I’ve name changed as I’ve written a few posts and combined they could be a little bit outing.

Had a conversation with soon to be step daughter last night, she’s 13, almost 14. I’m due to marry her dad in December. She was asking me about names and I said I’d be Mrs .... the same surname as her and her dad.

She told me I couldn’t be, as her mum is Mrs ..... now I’m not in the least bit insecure and understand why her mum is still Mrs ...... but surely I’m not BU to also call myself Mrs ....?

What do you think? Before I’m hammered I don’t care what her mum is calling herself one bit, I care what I’ll be called and I want to take my new husband’s name.

CherryPavlova Sat 06-Oct-18 07:57:21

You are being completely reasonable. The norm is still to change your name on marriage (although you don’t have to). Your stepdaughter will just have to get over herself.

Holidayfromreal Sat 06-Oct-18 07:57:57

Take his name, at 13 she should be old enough to understand that that's generally what happens when people get married.

LeGrandeFluff Sat 06-Oct-18 07:58:23

Rather wierd thinking on dsd part. However why not suggest a completely new name to your fiancée, for a new partnership? He may not want to because of his daughter however.

runsmidgeOMG Sat 06-Oct-18 07:59:35

Is this just a misunderstanding from DSD point of view? Maybe she thinks there should only be one (her mum) I'd kindly talk to her and say that whilst her mother will still be referred to as such, her DF is marrying you now which entitles you to the same name. She might find this hard to process, it can't be easy for a teen watching their parents get remarried so tread carefully and be kind smile congrats on your upcoming wedding

Ignoramusgiganticus Sat 06-Oct-18 08:00:45

Perfectly normal. Ask her whether she'd prefer you to take his name or for him to take your name. That might make her think.

NonaGrey Sat 06-Oct-18 08:00:56

Her paternal Grandmother is Or was also Mrs X as are any aunts or cousins who married into the family.

And unless it’s a very unusual name there are lots of other women out there called Mrs X.

Her Dad needs to have a chat with her, she sounds like she needs some reassurance and attention.

OneEpisode Sat 06-Oct-18 08:01:18

You get to choose your name, I just wanted to say it isn’t the norm in all social groups in the UK. It’s not the norm at the top of the social/education hierarchy; (for example Elizabeth Windsor) and it is not the case for all ethnicities/religions. None of my Spanish friends change name for instance.
You can choose.

kitty1013 Sat 06-Oct-18 08:03:14

Of course you can take his name if you want to!
I have a DSD and a DSS, I married their dad when they were 6 & 10 respectively, this was 11 years ago. From my experience there are some things that are open for debate - what's for dinner, what shall we watch at the cinema , etc, and then there are "grown up " decisions eg what house shall we buy, what will my married name be- where you have to be clear that these are decisions her dad and you make jointly, you will keep her informed but it's not her decision to make.

As you travel through the teenage years you need to know your boundaries. It can be easy to want to bend over backwards to keep them happy to show you are not an evil stepmum but then it all backfires , as they can't make all the decisions! You'll end up feeling resentful and walked over. There is a balance. This one isn't her decision to make. Just let her know what's happening and then discuss it no further.

Hope that doesn't sound harsh! I hope your fiancé is with you on this. You must always present a united front.
Kxx

AuntBeastie Sat 06-Oct-18 08:03:19

Just keep very gently explaining it to her and she will come round. It’s just an adjustment for her.

LaBelleSausage Sat 06-Oct-18 08:05:02

I came here thinking that you and the ex had the same first name so upon marriage to your DP there would suddenly be two Petunia Higgenbottoms (or whatever your name might happen to be) which would be a little strange.

If its just the surname then not strange at all.

I can understand why she would keep it so she has the same surname as her kids but that’s no reason for you not to take it!

flumpybear Sat 06-Oct-18 08:05:05

You're doing no bad deed here! I've only just realised my ex step mum would have been in the same name situation, it was never even considered or thought of - perhaps it's just one of those things children think about that's not really a thing - can her dad talk to her?

ZenNudist Sat 06-Oct-18 08:05:32

Change your name if you want.

This is a non-issue. 13yo is wrong and will have to get over it. Get her dad to talk to her and explain thiz is normal.

Breakfastclubcrazy Sat 06-Oct-18 08:06:03

I strongly suspect the thought has been planted by her mum. They divorced several years ago and I met DH2B about a year after the divorce. She hasn’t had a long term boyfriend, maybe she doesn’t want one, but she hasn’t quite moved on and has tried to make things difficult in the past. I’ve heard she’s not entirely happy about our marriage. She stalked me for a little while although I think that’s stopped. She did turn up at our wedding venue at exactly the same time as we did for a wedding meeting. She was there for a coffee with friends! Erm!

So I think this idea came from mum to be honest.

NeeChee Sat 06-Oct-18 08:07:27

I wouldn't want to take my partner's name for this reason, ExW is still Mrs "Smith", and that kind of puts me off. Also, not sure I even want to be a Mrs lol.
But, everyone is different, it is entirely up to you smile

JenBarber Sat 06-Oct-18 08:07:52

Why is the ex still Mrs X? Has she kept the name of a man she divorced? If so it sounds as though she's not over the break up and getting her daughter to meddle.

That's odder.

Ignore. Do your own thing.

JenBarber Sat 06-Oct-18 08:09:28

Just read your update. She still thinks she's his wife.

She stalked you? Nut job. I'd run from the lot of them.

sandgrown Sat 06-Oct-18 08:10:03

I kept my married name when I got divorced so I was the same as my children. When OW married ex Dh I am.not sure she liked being the second Mrs S but who cares!

Breakfastclubcrazy Sat 06-Oct-18 08:10:46

I guess she still wants to be Mrs ... because of her daughter. I’m divorced and couldn’t wait to get rid of his name (I have an older daughter) but everyone is different.

Breakfastclubcrazy Sat 06-Oct-18 08:12:15

I’m not the second Mrs .... I’m the only one married to him, or soon will be. She can call herself it, but she’s not his wife. No seconds here.

Dollymixture22 Sat 06-Oct-18 08:13:41

I wouldn’t stress about the name. It’s not really about that - you and your fiancé need to talk to this girl and make sure she is comfortable about the marriage. Of course you won’t put it off to make her happy but she is either feeling torn beciase if loyalty to her mum or she’s not totally happy about this.

Figure it out, make sure she isn’t feeling left out and make sure she can cope lethal any negativity from her mum.

Divorce is really hard on children. Some will need counselling to work through all he emotions. Make sure this girl knows you are in her side and understand this is tough for her and her mum.

Dhalandchips Sat 06-Oct-18 08:13:42

@jenbarber I've kept my ex's name purely because I don't want to pay for a new bloody passport! Definitely over him!

Kr1stina Sat 06-Oct-18 08:14:59

Why is the ex still Mrs X? Has she kept the name of a man she divorced? If so it sounds as though she's not over the break up

Em I’m guessing because it’s now her name as much as his. And it’s her child’s name.

She CHANGED her name. She didn’t borrow it like a library book.

70isaLimitNotaTarget Sat 06-Oct-18 08:15:30

I would sign myself as "The Current Mrs X" if ExW is going to be chintzy .wink

Sounds like it is from ExW . I'm sure your DSD has friends who are in families with Ex / Step/ family members.

FrancisCrawford Sat 06-Oct-18 08:16:27

Very strange for a 13 year old not to be aware that it is traditional for married women to take their husbands name. Sounds like she was deliberately trying to get a reaction from you.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »