Advanced search

AIBU to ask if you sometimes wonder if God thinks humans are a bunch of fools

(72 Posts)
ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:23:53

Because of the idiotic things we do. Do you know they hymn Dear Lord and father of of mankind?
AIBU to think about those things?

somewhereovertherain Sun 17-Jun-18 23:25:18

As it’s a fictional being it’s all irrelevant

confuzzled42 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:26:21

I think He despairs and lives in equal measures.

ComeToTheCoast Sun 17-Jun-18 23:26:57

As it’s a fictional being it’s all irrelevant

You didn't expect serious answers on MN did you op?

confuzzled42 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:27:03

Loves that should say - obviously- although lives works I guess!

TakeawayTakeMeAway Sun 17-Jun-18 23:27:55

I don’t believe, but I know that lovely hymn and know what you mean.

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:28:11

Okay, somewhereovertherain, as an atheist you probably don‘t. For an atheist the question why are we so foolish is also easily answered with: cause evolution made us that way, isn‘t it?

StorminaBcup Sun 17-Jun-18 23:29:21

But we are a bunch of fools. And I don't believe in God.

MrsTerryPratchett Sun 17-Jun-18 23:31:04

Well it's all nonsense.

But if it wasn't the issue is this. God may have the power to help and/or cares to. The problem of evil is that God either cares and can't change things or can change things and doesn't care to.

Not a good and powerful God in either case. Maybe Norse/Greco-Roman God...

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:31:59

Takeaway So happy, somebody understands. Cannot really explain it in words. I am not overly religious but I am fear God sometimes shakes his head and despairs over humanity.

m0therofdragons Sun 17-Jun-18 23:32:56

I imagine he walks around doing this 🤦🏻‍♀️ a lot

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:33:31

CometotheCoast Oh, i got some great and serious answers here on MN on other threads. Some not so serious and some mean ones too, but I got some great answers here.

lardymclardy Sun 17-Jun-18 23:33:43

Have you not read The Shack? God looks after all of us and cooks a mean jumbalaya, but only the chosen few get to find their murdered children.
What was the question?

StorminaBcup Sun 17-Jun-18 23:33:44

I know the hymn you mean too. It was a staple in our school chapel service.

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:36:28

The shack, no, I did not read that. What is it?

SilverySurfer Sun 17-Jun-18 23:36:53

I doubt he's shaking anything since he doesn't exist.

Heratnumber7 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:40:50

I heard a lecture once which posed the theory that God (if he exists at all) is a malevolent God, rather than the benevolent one we're lied to believe in.
'Twas very interesting.

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:43:11

Herat, I think that idea is scary, not interesting.

user1471517900 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:55:16

God created us in his image though. So either he thinks its going fine. Or he has made a whole bunch of errors which then doesn't really tie in with being a God.

user1471517900 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:56:12

He did score a pretty good free kick against Spain though.

ConfusedWife1234 Sun 17-Jun-18 23:56:59

Spain. Sorry, what.

PatriciaBateman Mon 18-Jun-18 00:00:39

I think that despite all it's flaws, humanity is an absolute diamond of a speciman when it comes to the world and Nature in general.

Every creature I see is either prey or predator. Nature is cruel, merciless, bloodthirsty, and wantonly wasteful (particularly of life).

I expect nothing less than for humanity to reflect all of this. It's a miracle to me that there are some human beings who wish to rise above all of it, who want to think of something other than themselves and their pleasure/survival. They may be a minority, but I think it's incredible (truly) that they exist at all.

The universe, and this world are very dark places. Amongst humanity, there are at least a few beacons of light. I have great hope for us.

ConfusedWife1234 Mon 18-Jun-18 00:03:35

That is an interesting think to say and think about, Patricia. Never looked at it this way, but I do not think all animals are mean and selfish. Many dogs for example would die for their human families.

Heratnumber7 Mon 18-Jun-18 00:05:22

Confused the lecturer spoke about Wars and famine and earthquakes etc being sent by God and how we struggle against his malevolence, rather than how he helps us overcome accidental/unplanned evils.

I don't believe in God, so didn't find it scary. It was interesting to hear a theory opposite to the usual one preached that God is on our side.

PatriciaBateman Mon 18-Jun-18 00:07:26

Confused I don't think all creatures are mean and selfish either. But they do priortise their pleasure and survival (or family/offspring's survival) above else.

When it comes to dogs (I agree with you), I find it interesting that:
a) it is primarily their "family" (human) they are willing to die for and
b) these are the dogs that have been socialised by humans (ie. our 'good' parts have rubbed off on them)

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: