Talk

Advanced search

To think men dressing up as women, is equivalent to blacking up?

(109 Posts)
crunchymint Mon 21-May-18 18:25:06

Men dress up as women for a laugh. It is about laughing at a stereotype of a woman. In the same way a white person blacking up is enacting a stereotype of a black person. Both are wrong.

Hamandcheesebaguette Mon 21-May-18 18:25:41

Errrr ... I see your sentiment but YABU.

RiddleyW Mon 21-May-18 18:27:34

I have a friend who says this and she makes a pretty convincing argument but I have seen drag acts that I’ve really enjoyed.

crunchymint Mon 21-May-18 18:28:54

My gran used to really enjoy the Black and White Minstrel Show. It was still racist.

Pengggwn Mon 21-May-18 18:30:17

In a way, I see your point.
Women are an oppressed class. Men dressing as them for kicks is definitely...odd. But I'm not sure it's harmful.

BMW6 Mon 21-May-18 18:30:34

I don't agree that dressing in women's clothes is to ridicule women.

But I do think that just putting on the clothing of the opposite sex does not turn you into that sex, any more than wearing black make up means you are then black.

dinosaursandtea Mon 21-May-18 18:31:07

If we’re talking drag, they don’t dress up as women. They dress up as drag queens. People who wear ‘women’s’ clothes but ID as male aren’t dressing up like women, they’re just wearing dresses/skirts etc. And trans women or AMAB non binary people aren’t men dressing up as anything.

Straight cis twats doing it as laddish banter though, like on stag nights, can fuck off though.

BeUpStanding Mon 21-May-18 18:31:20

YANBU

RiddleyW Mon 21-May-18 18:31:31

I take your point and it’s possible I am just a bit brain washed. I just can’t seem to align the obvious derision of minstrel shows with drag.

Ferrero83 Mon 21-May-18 18:31:45

'Blacking up' hmm is this a term that people use?

YABU

Whattheactualfuckmate Mon 21-May-18 18:32:47

YABU

RiddleyW Mon 21-May-18 18:32:51

Blacking up is absolutely a term - I’m amazed you’ve never heard it.

Racecardriver Mon 21-May-18 18:33:56

The problem with black face is the historical context. That context didn't exist when it comes to cross dressing so much. Let's put it this way. Only an ignorant person would be offended by a blacked up Morris dancer. This is because they don't understand why Black face is a bit off. The why is important.

crunchymint Mon 21-May-18 18:34:06

You think drag queens don't ridicule women? You have never heard all the common references to fish in drag acts?

ChazsBrilliantAttitude Mon 21-May-18 18:37:33

I struggle with some drag acts. I do think there is quite unpleasant female stereotyping in some of them. So I get the point you are making.

FortyFeet Mon 21-May-18 18:38:34

Drag would be a lot more palatable if all the blokes/characters didn't come across as such titanic twats.

Moonkissedlegs Mon 21-May-18 18:39:17

I agree that some drag acts are horrid stereotypes of women. All the OTT bitchiness and sexualisation.

Hmmmm, it's a difficult one really.

crunchymint Mon 21-May-18 18:40:31

Why do you think women do not dress up as men for comedic affect?
It is because men who have higher status dressing up as women who have lower status, has comedic impact. It is ridiculing that a man would dress up as someone with lower status.
Same concept with white people dressing up as a black person for comedic affect.

BarbarianMum Mon 21-May-18 18:40:44

YABU - dresses, stockings, floral prints, make up, high heels, long flowing locks - none of these "belong" to women any more than trousers and dms "belong" to men. People can dress to suit themselves.

KERALA1 Mon 21-May-18 18:41:28

I totally agree OP and cannot understand why there is not more equivalence between racism/sexism, race hate/misogyny.

GalwayWayfarer Mon 21-May-18 18:44:16

You should do some research into the social history of drag queens OP - they've been on the front line of fighting for the rights of women, gays and POC for decades.

JesusInTheCabbageVan Mon 21-May-18 18:45:48

YABU. Historically, women have had a bad time too, but how does it compare to slavery, segregation, the KKK, lynching, the disproportionate number of black men imprisoned and put to death in America, and shot by police, the disparity in wages, wealth and prospects, Moseley, Enoch Powell and the rivers of blood speech, Stephen Lawrence, to name a few examples?

crunchymint Mon 21-May-18 18:48:22

Women were legally slaves in Britain until recently. They did not own any belongings, not even the clothes they wore, they could be legally beaten and raped by their Husband, they could be committed to an asylum by their male relative, and some women were sold in "bride markets".

When have drag queens ever fought for women? I can not think of one single example.

ProperLavs Mon 21-May-18 18:49:00

Loads of women are being murdered by their male partners all the time.

eightfacesofthemoon Mon 21-May-18 18:49:10

@JesusInTheCabbageVan
Really! Why don’t you look up the oppression of women properly.
I think the op is BU. But still, to say that what some minorities have endured is less bad than other minorities is a load of rubbish.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: