Talk

Advanced search

To insist that drama is not a valid choice for GCSE's

(192 Posts)
FaintlyBaffled Mon 19-Feb-18 20:09:39

....when the student in question has never expressed the faintest interest in the subject in nearly 14 years hmm
DS has his heart set on taking GCSE drama. I maintain it's a bonkers choice given that his only acting experience to date was as a leaf in a school assembly in yr2.
To compound this, he is planning to give up a subject that has interested him since he was a toddler, as it falls in the same block as drama. He has a natural gift at this subject and has just received glowing reports in his most recent review.
I'm wary of opening hostilities over something that I can ultimately win in the short term (I have to sign the form to say I agree with his choices) but that he could win in the long term by flunking the subject. We've so far agreed not to do anything until we've discussed this in more detail with the school, but he's unusually truculent about the whole affair. AIBU to put my foot down and insist that he doesn't "waste" an option on this?

BarbarianMum Mon 19-Feb-18 20:12:13

He has no experience of acting since Y2. Has he not done drama at school since Y7 then?

Amoregentlemanlikemanner Mon 19-Feb-18 20:13:39

And the alternative subject is.......?

MerryShitmas Mon 19-Feb-18 20:13:45

Yes, YABU. Let him choose. So long as he maintains A-C's particularly in English maths and science he will have no lifelong issues even if drama is never used ever again.

ShangriLaLaLa Mon 19-Feb-18 20:13:54

It’s a common misconception that drama GCSE is all about acting. Yes, there are practicals but much of DDs syllabus echoes the work she’s going in English Literature.

Perendinate Mon 19-Feb-18 20:14:38

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

condepetie Mon 19-Feb-18 20:14:49

Drama's often compulsory 1 hour a week from year 7 to 9, right? It was at my school. Has he done drama lessons at all? Does he like the teacher? The subject he's good at - does he enjoy it, does he like the teacher?

It's not a waste, whatever happens. Drama is a great subject with the right teacher.

papayasareyum Mon 19-Feb-18 20:14:54

they do lots of GCSEs nowadays. When my kids were taking options I encouraged them to take one subject for pure pleasure or enjoyment, one which wouldn’t help with their career choices or sixth form choices, but just because they wanted an easier, more relaxing subject to study
(I took gcse drama and it was the highlight of my school week!)

notmyredditusername365 Mon 19-Feb-18 20:14:59

What do you think is wrong with a drama gcse?

BossWitch Mon 19-Feb-18 20:15:34

GCSE options really, really don't matter.

VandelayIndustries Mon 19-Feb-18 20:15:35

It’s hard this options business because there isn’t much actual choosing to be done.

Are his friends doing drama? That’s what I’d suspect.

My dd is quite academic but wanted a fun subject for one of her options. Either music, art or drama.

Moonandstars84 Mon 19-Feb-18 20:15:49

Yep my dd is doing the same text in drama and English lit.
Win win.

mamaryllis Mon 19-Feb-18 20:15:55

Ahaha ha! Are you me???
Ds1 did this to me last summer. Going further even. Suggesting that actually he might like to take a performing arts degree. (Slightly different scenario as he us two years older and finishes school in a year and a half.)
He has now settled slightly and is considering being a maths teacher and running the drama club. He seems to think he’s an undiscovered star. Sheesh.
I am doing lots of ‘you must do what you want to do honey, but keep as many doors open’ (ie don’t close them by doing drama you fruit loop)

missmoz Mon 19-Feb-18 20:16:07

YABU.

His life, his choices. Maybe this is a sign he's always wanted to try drama but hasn't had the confidence. Also you won't have seen him act in his Y7-Y9 classes so you're information is out of date.

Slightlyperturbedowlagain Mon 19-Feb-18 20:16:19

What is the subject he’s going to drop in favour of drama?

CougheeBean Mon 19-Feb-18 20:16:22

Well it’s his choice really. GSCEs barely count except for some a level choices. Drama can be great for confidence, shame about the subject he’s gifted at though. Maybe he could contine that or take up drama outside of school? That would probably liven up a CV more than a gcse anyway.

Notevilstepmother Mon 19-Feb-18 20:16:36

Is one of his friends doing drama, or someone he fancies?

Does he know there will be essays?

I’d certainly want to have a conversation about it, with school and with him, but personally I think insisting isn’t the best idea.

halcyondays Mon 19-Feb-18 20:16:58

yabu, let him choose.

JustDanceAddict Mon 19-Feb-18 20:17:01

My DD is doing drama gcse and my ds will probably too, but they’ve both done drama out of school. Ds is particularly good. You do have to be reasonably good at acting as some of it is practical and assessed, some is critically analysing theatre/shows. There’s a lot of group work so the ‘working in a team’ ability helps too.

humblesims Mon 19-Feb-18 20:17:25

It’s a common misconception that drama GCSE is all about acting. Yes, there are practicals but much of DDs syllabus echoes the work she’s going in English Literature
Exactly this. And more; drama teaches you skills of public speaking and presenting yourself well in general which is hugely useful later in life with job interviews and networking etc. Dont dis the drama Mama!

AtiaoftheJulii Mon 19-Feb-18 20:17:40

What's his reasoning?

3 out of my 4 have done/are doing drama GCSE, and yes, there's much more to it than acting. But it seems like an odd choice for him?

Daffydil Mon 19-Feb-18 20:17:52

I did gcse drama. I was shit at it and got a shit mark. It was a lovely dossy lesson (that attitude will be why I got a shot mark!) but I did learn some useful relaxation techniques that I still use. And we saw some excellent productions on theatre trips.

Doesn't seem to have held me back at all though grin

FaintlyBaffled Mon 19-Feb-18 20:18:01

barbarian he's only started in yr9 as we still have the three tier system here.

We've been advised about the weight of extra curricular effort that drama would entail. This concerns me as he is a musician so has a reasonably heavy burden in that area anyway.

upsideup Mon 19-Feb-18 20:18:33

YUBVU let him chose what he wants.

Notevilstepmother Mon 19-Feb-18 20:18:54

Drama is very good for confidence, and it can help with presentations in the future. Often at university or job interviews they will have to present in front of an audience and this is nerve racking.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: