Advanced search

To ask if you have ever learnt a foreign language on-line?

(13 Posts)
Fairyliz Sun 11-Feb-18 15:47:27

I am retiring shortly and one of the things I would love to do is to learn a foreign language (probably Spanish).
I don't ever think I could become proficient at it but would like to be able to hold simple conversation/request things in bars and shops. I always feel so ignorant when I am abroad that I can't speak any of the language.
Has anyone ever used an on-line method to do this and if so which one? How long did it take you to become confident enough to start a simple request?

YouTheCat Sun 11-Feb-18 16:01:52

Try Duolingo. It's free and there are loads of languages to choose from.

ForalltheSaints Sun 11-Feb-18 16:18:54

No, thought about it but decided I could never do this, so went for a fortnight's intensive course.

Frazzled2207 Sun 11-Feb-18 16:23:45

Duolingo is good and free and a good start. However you'll never get confident without combining this with a proper interactive approach IMO.

user1497357411 Sun 11-Feb-18 16:26:25

I didn't learn another language online, but when I suddenly had to use German for work, it was very nice to find so many good videos on Youtube and I also found a good homepage where I could rehearse German grammar.

user1497357411 Sun 11-Feb-18 16:29:22

Oh sorry, I should have mentioned, that I had studied German earlier and had been almost fluent but then hadn't used it for more than 20 years.
That meant that I also spent some time watching vidoes, that were very basic. They rehearsed sentences like "This is my sister", "I would like to buy a beer" and "How old are you?".

DullAndOld Sun 11-Feb-18 16:33:47

Duolingo is a start but that is all.

You can only learn a different language (note the choice of words, ie 'another' not 'foreign') through "meaningful input". (thank you Krashen).

Therefore the only Spanish I remember are the words I learnt to deal with situations I was pushed into, when staying there.

If there is no "meaningful input" then yes you can learn a few words but you will forget them almost immediately.

For example in Greek I can say 'your house stinks and your son is crazy'. Because I needed to learn those words for a specific situation.

Do you see?

carefreeeee Sun 11-Feb-18 16:33:52

I like YouTube videos such as lightspeed Spanish. You need to practise speaking and listening and common phrases whereas duolingo gets quite boring although it's good for testing yourself. I do evening classes as well - I'd never be motivated enough otherwise

lidoshuffle Sun 11-Feb-18 16:35:35

I tried Duolingo, but found it very slow and repetitive. It didn't have any lists of conjugations etc so I never felt I got the proper foundations of a language, just umpteen repititions of asking for a coffee etc.

FithColumnist Sun 11-Feb-18 17:21:22

DullAndOld what the hell was that context?!

DullAndOld Sun 11-Feb-18 17:23:04

grin landlord issues...

Pengggwn Sun 11-Feb-18 17:41:05

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FithColumnist Mon 12-Feb-18 00:02:45

DullAndOld, I dread to think.

However, I've tried learning Polish through Duolingo and got reasonably far- because it was my entertainment on the bus to work. Now I no longer get the bus to work I can just about remember how to say "she is eating two apples", but nothing beyond that. For what it's worth I already spoke six languages to a reasonable degree of fluency and so am "good at languages"(TM), and I have dabbled in about twelve more. However, without any real motivation (or Krashen's "comprehensible input"- I'm a bit dubious on this), nothing has ever stuck. I am still a proud owner of "Teach Yourself Babylonian", though, and can still recognise a G-stem even if I don't know what it bloody means.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: