Talk

Advanced search

Should the teacher be saying this to 5/6 year olds?

(264 Posts)
ThisIsMyUsername02123 Sun 19-Nov-17 21:18:55

Hello.

Just a quick one, really. My 5 year old never used to say this to anyone considering it's never really said in the home - "use your common sense!"

I asked him, "who says that?," to which he responds "[Teacher's name]."

Do you think that a Year 1 primary school teacher should say things like that to 5/6 year olds, considering how rude and abrupt it is to say something like it? Personally, I find it quite ridiculous considering the fact that not even DS15's Year 10 secondary school teachers say things like that.

Cheers.

Anasnake Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:02

It's not rude.

NapQueen Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:27

I think you are being daft.

W1a Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:36

It’s pretty standard!

Changerofname987654321 Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:38

I think it depends on the context. If the teacher says it a polite way as a response to a question then they are giving the child permission to make their own decision.

TheApprentice Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:43

Whats wrong with that?

Rainbowandraindrops67 Sun 19-Nov-17 21:20:54

Yabu - it’s a perfectly fine thing to say and not rude at all

GerdaLovesLili Sun 19-Nov-17 21:21:07

If only common sense was more common.

RainyDayBear Sun 19-Nov-17 21:21:43

I think there are bigger things to worry about in the world. And I say things like this to my secondary school age classes, I have no idea how it would be considered rude!!

TheOriginalNNB Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:07

In a world where our 5/6yr olds are set ridiculous educational targets, being encouraged to access their common sense makes sense, really!

Moussemoose Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:13

Ffs use your common sense.

shakeyourcaboose Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:26

What is rude? Unless its being used inappropriately are they not being asked to think about something to come to their own conclusion?

TowerRavenSeven Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:32

Yabu if she is saying it to them, but I wouldn't be happy if he then said it to me.

EastMidsMummy Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:47

Rude? What's rude about it?

Lucked Sun 19-Nov-17 21:22:50

I don’t think it’s bad, teachers have to be abrupt sometimes like telling them to be quiet and shout if they are misbehaving. It’s not like it’s s bad suggestion unless you mean he is being sarcastic.

My 5 year old son tries to take his trousers off before his shoes on a daily basis, I have certainly had a word about common sense!

ThisIsMyUsername02123 Sun 19-Nov-17 21:24:07

But the thing is, the tone with which he's imitating his teacher makes her sound pretty nasty... Seems a bit iffy to me - but I don't know, probably am a bit sensitive. confused

isittheholidaysyet Sun 19-Nov-17 21:24:17

Have 5/6 year olds developed common sense yet.

Seems a silky thing to say to that age group.

isittheholidaysyet Sun 19-Nov-17 21:24:33

*silly

ineedamoreadultieradult Sun 19-Nov-17 21:24:56

It depends how it is said as to if it is rude or abrupt, but I would say it's a fairly standard response.

Child: 'shall I put my coat on?'
Teacher 'its November use your common sense:

Child 'ive finished with the paint shall I put it away:
Teacher 'use your common sense's

Child 'this felt tip has ran out, shall I throw it away'
Teacher 'use your common sense'

Not rude at all.

Anasnake Sun 19-Nov-17 21:25:36

You're being silly and need to use your common sense grin

steff13 Sun 19-Nov-17 21:26:49

YABU. My goodness I would hate to be a teacher.

isittheholidaysyet Sun 19-Nov-17 21:26:49

Are children in schools allowed to use common sense?
Mine seem to have to follow all kinds of rules which make no sense at all.

BewareOfDragons Sun 19-Nov-17 21:26:56

hmm Sadly, common sense is lacking in many...

PaperdollCartoon Sun 19-Nov-17 21:26:59

How is it rude?! Yes YABU

CorbynsBumFlannel Sun 19-Nov-17 21:26:59

Not ideal and not a very respectful way to speak to a child tbh but pretty standard ime. If the aim is to try and get kids to problem solve for themselves there would be many more polite ways to say it.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: