Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

To email this teacher?

(290 Posts)
LadyWire Wed 08-Nov-17 17:07:17

My DD is 18 and at 6th form college. To avoid dripfeeding she has ASD, depression and anxiety. She is extremely emotionally underdeveloped compared to her peers.

Her a-level English teacher told a tale today about seeing a cat being hit by a car and hitting it with a tennis racquet to "put it out of its misery" before throwing it to the side of the road. He then kept referring back to it throughout the lesson.

DD has come out of college inconsolable. I've emailed the teacher telling him that a) what he did was appalling and b) it's not an appropriate subject to speak to a class about. AIBU to be angry enough to contact him or should I have ignored it? Tbh I'm tempted to report him to college and to the RSPCA.

yawning801 Wed 08-Nov-17 17:11:46

YADNBU to report him to the college, but I would see what they say before contacting the RSPCA.

LadyWire Wed 08-Nov-17 18:52:54

Thank you. I'm going to wait for a reply from him before deciding my next move. DD is inconsolable.

LadyWire Wed 08-Nov-17 18:52:56

Thank you. I'm going to wait for a reply from him before deciding my next move. DD is inconsolable.

HopefullyAnonymous Wed 08-Nov-17 18:55:21

It’s not pleasant, but preferable to leaving it to die slowly in agony I’d have thought?

BertrandRussell Wed 08-Nov-17 18:57:30

It may have been the best thing to do in the circumstances. But he was very wrong to talk about it in the way he did.

FellOutOfBed2wice Wed 08-Nov-17 18:59:02

Are you sure it wasn’t a joke?

Purplepeonies Wed 08-Nov-17 19:04:23

You may be waiting a while for a response as he may not directly email you back. Depends on the policy but it might need to be passed on to his head of department/pastoral staff.

shivermytimbers Wed 08-Nov-17 19:10:14

Could it be that he was illustrating a point with this story but your DD took it literally? If so, I would want him to be aware that this isn't an appropriate teaching style for many students who take things literally But, if he actually bludgeoned a cat to death, that's just weird and I would want him spoken to by senior management.

Storminateapot Wed 08-Nov-17 19:35:24

My DD is also 18 and in sixth form. She has no difficulties such as you describe but I know would have been equally very distressed to hear that story and I would have judged it inappropriate to discuss so graphically and repeatedly, it's not something I would want to hear either, to be honest, and I'm 50!

MrsDustyBusty Wed 08-Nov-17 19:39:46

There's a chance that there's a nuance to the story which will become apparent in his reply.

sonjadog Wed 08-Nov-17 19:39:55

I think you need some more context. Is this the explanation of a metaphor in a book? Why did he bring it up at all and keep referring to it? Surely there must have been some point in it rather than as a random anecdote?

Pengggwn Wed 08-Nov-17 19:40:56

Sorry but she is 18. If that is a true anecdote and he did that to stop the cat being in pain (and not because he is some crazed sadist) you are overreacting. She may be emotionally younger but she is a legal adult and he can basically talk to them about whatever he wants, within safeguarding limits of course.

Hercules12 Wed 08-Nov-17 19:44:29

Dd is in year 9 and I wouldn't have an issue with this.

Moussemoose Wed 08-Nov-17 19:45:27

The teacher is building up relationships with the students by sharing an incident like that he might be illustrating a point relating to many aspects of English language or his own frailty and short comings.

Life happens to teachers as well, when you are dealing with young adults sharing and discussing life events is good practice.

We have no idea about the context.

If posters jump in saying the teacher should only refer to curriculum content you are sucking the life out of education. A levels deal with life and death issues they will be discussed in class.

Classroom discussion is a way of introducing young adults to life events.

LadyWire Wed 08-Nov-17 19:45:39

She's 18 but in the lower sixth - some of her class have only just turned 16. He described where it happened as in the village where we live (college is in the nearby town) so she was also fretting it was one of our cats. Surely most people would call a vet or the RSPCA, not hit it with a tennis racquet? I'm waiting for his reply before I do anything, I'm aware that will probably be tomorrow.

MrsDustyBusty Wed 08-Nov-17 19:47:06

Surely emailing him was doing enough? What more do you propose to do?

lookatyourwatchnow Wed 08-Nov-17 19:48:43

You are being ridiculous. For a start, the teacher hasn’t done anything worthy of complaining about. Secondly, you can’t micro manage what information your 18 year old hears.

Pengggwn Wed 08-Nov-17 19:48:51

sonjadog

Could be. It could be in the context of discussing euthanasia, moral dilemmas, utilitarian ethics - loads of things. If the teacher said, "Okay, here's an example of something that happened to me..." (or, more accurately, to the cat) and then went back to it to illustrate a point in the novel or poem or play, then I really don't think that is inappropriate. Teachers aren't psychic, I don't think they can be expected to be responsible for all extreme emotional reactions. If he has previously been briefed that this (adult) student gets very upset about animal welfare then fair enough. Otherwise, it's English Lit: there isn't very much that is completely off the table!

Pengggwn Wed 08-Nov-17 19:49:48

LadyWire

Honestly? If an animal was dying a painful death right in front of me and I knew it would be hours before anyone from the RSPCA got there, I would do what he did. It's better for the animal.

headinhands Wed 08-Nov-17 19:52:38

Christ, you definitely need to talk to the school and her supporting member of staff. That’s an awful thing to have stuck in your head going round and round sad. If she lets you, give her a hug from me. 💐

Maelstrop Wed 08-Nov-17 19:52:50

My DH has told me colleagues have had to use a spade (sharp edge, one presumes) when coming across an animal that's been run over but isn't dead, quicker than a prolonged and agonising trip to a vet/wildlife sanctuary.

I'm not sure how one dispatches a cat with a tennis racquet or how this was a relevant story to the lesson? Is he aware of her SEND?

Moussemoose Wed 08-Nov-17 19:55:52

headinhands

You really think that is so awful?

Let's hope OPs daughter is not studying English Lit (King Lear), RE (crucification), History (war - any of them), Biology (natural selection) or, well, any other A level!

isadoradancing123 Wed 08-Nov-17 19:56:25

She is 18 and will have to learn to live in the real world, the world won't revolve around her needs

Moussemoose Wed 08-Nov-17 19:57:12

crucification should be crucifixion

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now