To want to buy Christmas presents?!(29 Posts)
My DP has just announced that we need to "start telling people we're not buying Christmas presents this year" something I have not agreed to. I agree money is going to be tight this year. We have a baby due January, moved into a house 9 months ago and he has decided he needs a new car, which we are currently hunting for.
However, he has upset me mainly as he singled out my parents, saying I spend too much on them (usually £40-50 each). However, my mum has done free childcare for us since DD1 was born. They help us a lot both financially and with things like moving house etc.
AIBU to want to buy Christmas presents for close friends and family? I agree maybe we should tell our grandparents not to buy us anything and we won't in return. But to not buy anyone anything seems like such a grinchy thing to do?! I don't know whether I am upset because I'm pregnant and hormonal or whether I am justified. I feel like Christmas is going to be rubbish now, because he's going to be a grump if I buy presents
Quite honestly if your parents have done all those things for you you should buy or make them something, I think your husband is being most unreasonable, it's fine not to buy for the rest of the family but for people who have suported you like that.....really? have a stern word with him and ask him how he would feel if they withdrew childminding or wanted the money they gave you back.
Compromise. Halve the budget?
I spend £10-15 per person for family at Christmas. More for birthdays but not much more. They know we don't have much money.
So, it's ok to buy a car for HIM, but not ok to buy presents for your family who provide free childcare and money?
I'd compromise. You buy presents for your family, but not for him.
Still buy presents but halve it. You can buy something nice for £20 or something worth £40 in a sale. Next year you could be on the look out for these all year round. That is what a clever friend of mine does!
Op cost out that childcare for him it may bring him up short. I pay £5 an hour for a childminder. It’ll make £20/30/40 quid pressie pale into insignificance. Or make something? Are you a good baker/knitter/sewing/photographer?
I would start making hampers maybe?
That’s what I’m doing this year. It’s now because you’ve clearly put in a lot of effort and it can be quite cheap
I think your DP is being massively unreasonable and mean. How much more would it cost if you were paying your parents for childcare? Buying them something nice is almost a ‘thank you’ maybe explain this to your DP. I get he’s trying to save money but in the grand scheme of things £40 isn’t a lot.
If my partner told me I couldn't buy Christmas presents for my mum and dad, I'll tell him where to go.
A discussion about spending a bit less, as you're going to be short of money would be entirely reasonable, but just deciding something like this isn't on.
Yanbu at all. As you’ve said your parents provide a lot of practical support as well as childcare, has he forgotten about this or does he just take them completely for granted ?
If a new car is affordable then gifts for your parents should be within budget too. It would be different if you were buying for dozens of extended family members but not buying for your parents when you always have in the past and they provide so much support seems mean. Have you pointed all this out to him?
I'd tell him fine no presents but that you won't be taking free childcare either so no new car and likely lots of other things have to go.
I'd be very hurt that he thought it ok to take their financial and physical help and not want to even get them a Christmas present. I'd have to rethink if that was the kind of person I wanted to be with, the answer would be no.
Yes I did point out to him that they do a lot for us and I am buying them gifts as a thank you. And don't get me started on this bloody car he's getting! He does travel for work so needs a "safe car". Apparently that means he has to buy a Mercedes
I am sticking to my guns about my parents. If he doesn't want to buy anything for his that's fine. They don't help us out really.
Thank you all for making me feel sane again. I know Christmas has become very commercial, but it's also a lot of fun and I look forward to it now that we have DD.
If he brings it up again I will just tell him he's welcome to tell his family we're not doing presents for them, but that's just not how we roll in my family. If we can afford a Mercedes we can afford £20-30 gifts for loved ones.
What will it look like after your parents giving you money and saving a fortune on childcare. It will look grabby and selfish. I don't even feel 50 is enough
I know! I genuinely don't understand how he doesn't see how ridiculous he is sometimes!
He needs a Merc?? Wow. Ok I already thought he was BU but bloody hell, who on earth tells their parents they can’t afford to do Christmas gifts as they’ve always done in the past and then drives away in their Mercedes .
Op I know this is only a snapshot and I’m not trying to over analyze but if he’s generally inclined to make solo decisions about how money is spent do you need to have a conversation about that? You mention having dd and you’re due a baby soon so presumably you won’t be earning for a while. I’d want to be sure there isn’t some notion of “well it’s my money so I get to decide” going on there.
Glad you have decided to tell the cheeky bastard to piss off.
I’m actually very much in favour of reducing the mad extravaganza of Christmas spending but this is different. I would tell extended family that you are going to not buy/ have a small budget this year due to the baby etc. They will probably be relieved. Your parents certainly do deserve a decent gift. Buy whatever you like. Something strong and German?
And remind him he is not your boss?
Your DH is buying himself a Mercedes but doesn't want you to buy your parents (who offer free childcare) Christmas gifts.
Are there underlying issues with their relationship? I find it hard to understand this level of selfishness.
I can understand cutting the gift budget if you're cutting your budget in general. I buy a lot of things in charity shops -you can get brand new stuff (ex-gifts probably) or just good quality things. I've never not given presents, just toned it down. People have been just as pleased.
Wow, he is being massively unreasonable! If my husband made the same suggestion, I'd tell him to get a cheaper car if he wanted to save money. To not get presents for people who help you out so much just seems so unappreciative and disrespectful. As PP said, save cash by not buying him one, see how he likes it.
Oh and get DD to make them cards. You don't say how old she is but last year DS was 1 and a half and I got a pack of card and got him to scribble on it with gold and silver pens. The effect on dark card (black, blue, green and red) was really effective. I then chopped it and wrote a message in each. Made it really personal.
So essentially he’s funding his Mercedes using the money you save on childcare? But you can’t buy them a present to say thank you
So he can buy himself a merc but he can't buy presents for people who look after his kids for free! Selfish bugger! I'd wipe the floor with him. Tell him he'll have to lower his expectations - they're getting presents and he's getting a Micra, and you think it will reflect his personality. And tell him you'll throw in a personal reg that spells out Scrooge for him while you're at it.
I’m tryong to reduce our Christmas and birthday spend. We’ve gotten to the point where my SIL and BIL and is just pass cards to each other with £30 in. Might just as well keep the money in your own bank account and give a card.
I’d love us to move to a secret Santa type thing where you buy a decent gift for one person out of the group.
No need to buy a Merc - a Nissan micro has an ncap rating of 5. So does an insignia. Spend the rest on prezzies!
I hope he has insisted you have a safe car too presuming the children travel in your car sometimes?
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now »
Already registered? Log in with:
Please login first.