Talk

Advanced search

Help DH and me solve this silly maths argument

(160 Posts)

MNHQ have commented on this thread.

ADayGivingMeHope Sun 04-Jun-17 21:34:53

Ok it's not an AIBU but we need this argument settled!!

I am 30.

I just said to my DH that I am MORE than half his age...
We are talking about someone on TV who is 70
DH says I am LESS than half his age.

Half his age is 35. I am 40 years younger than him so surely I am MORE than half his age?

DH says half his age is 35 and I am 30 so I'm less than half his age...

Tell us who is right please!

ClopySow Sun 04-Jun-17 21:35:41

Really?

Twodogsandahooch Sun 04-Jun-17 21:35:42

DH

OuiMerci Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:08

Your DH.

Hassled Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:11

You are more than half is age. You are 40 years younger, which is more than 35 years, which is half.

ClopySow Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:13

Your husband is right

TizzyDongue Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:15

Your DH is right.

BusyBeez99 Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:19

Less than is right

PotteringAlong Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:30

DH

headhurtstoomuch Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:29

I'd say 'less than half his age'

TheFifthKey Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:39

DH I'm afraid! It's means older than half his age - in fact I'm not sure I even follow the logic of your thinking, sorry!

BlackSwan79 Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:40

Your DH is right

Hassled Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:48

Oh my god I've confused myself. I've had wine.

Paddybare Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:49

Your DH is right I'm afraid.

TyneTeas Sun 04-Jun-17 21:36:57

I think you are right

Less than half is smaller than the half

TizzyDongue Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:04

30 is less than 35.

AlternativeTentacle Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:05

Less than half his age of course.

WingsofNylon Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:17

You are less than half his age. But you are more than half his age younger than him.

Angiefernackerpan Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:27

Your DH is correct. Half his age is 35, you are 30. 30 is less than 35.

Naicehamshop Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:28

Your dh.

annandale Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:33

Your dh.

fanfrickintastic Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:34

DH is right.

If you were more than half his age you'd be 35+ but I can see why you think it.

Think of it like a cake, if you asked for more than half the cake, how much can would you expect?

StressedMover Sun 04-Jun-17 21:37:40

You are correct!

Untangled07 Sun 04-Jun-17 21:38:00

Your DH

ClopySow Sun 04-Jun-17 21:38:10

To be more than half his age, you'd have to be over 35

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now