Saying please and thank you(12 Posts)
This is an
argument discussion that comes up every couple of weeks in our house, and it's to do with saying please and thank you. If, for example, I am asking my DH to make me a cup of tea I'll say 'please' because he's doing me a favour. However if DS's nappy needs changing when he's around I'll just ask him to do it because I've already changed 3 dirty nappies in the last hour. Same goes with dishwasher/ other household tasks that need doing between us when he's not at work. He always gives me a 'look' waiting for me to say please. But I don't think this is doing me a favour, it just needs doing so I resent having to say please. I point out that no one ever says to me 'please look after your child today' 'thank you for doing the food shopping/ cooking dinner.' I just do it, cos it needs to be done. On the odd occasion he does something without me having to ask I do say thank you. But really it's a shared responsibility. I guess it's how you the view meaning of please/ thank you. I want DS to grow up being polite but also not to think woman do all the work and have to 'ask nicely' for help. Thoughts?
I always say please and thank you, regardless of what it is.
It is a total bugbear we have with our DC. They are a tween and a teen now. Even though we've been reminding them constantly since they could talk, they are still not keen on 'please' or 'thank you' and often have to be prompted. Drives us mad - we're in manners' Groundhog Day in our house!
I think you're confusing two issues. I would always say please if asking someone to do something - it's a total habit.
However why do you have to ask him to change nappies at all? Doesn't he notice? Is he an idiot?
Tbh I would say please, however I use please and thank you way too much, as in, with strangers, if I'm ordering food say, I say please after every item. I hate that I cant not say it . Its a disease!
DH never changes nappies either, drives me insane. If we are both home he wont do a nappy unless asked specifically. On my weekend lie ins (we take turns) when I get up dd is always in a wet nappy .
I would always say please and thank you though if he also says it to you. If not then I'd leave him waiting with that raised brow!
I would always say please and thank you in those situations, but then so would DH. He is just as likely to ask me to do a job as I am to ask him (or unlikely really because we both just crack on and don't need to be asked).
Presumably your DH always says please and thank you since it's so important to him? If so, then surely your DC are not learning that women have to ask nicely for help, but that both partners should be polite. The only way that this would be an issue is if you are always having to ask your DH to do things because he never takes the initiative himself. If that's the case, then it isn't the pleases and thank you's that are the issue. It's the fact that all these mundane tasks are your responsibility by default unless you expressly ask for help. That's what will teach your DC the wrong lessons.
I would say please on those occasions if I was asking someone to do something whether it benefited me or not. I also say thank you if someone cooks me dinner and exdh always said thanks for dinner when I cooked his dinner.
Ok IABU will say please in future
through gritted teeth he does do nappies and household tasks, but only if asked (unless he's left alone with DS, if I'm there he assumes I'll do it.) he sometimes says thank you for dinner and would be nice if he did it more often, maybe I'll point that out. Thanks for your replies!
If I ask someone to do something (whatever the reason) I would say please.
However I wouldn't necessarily say thank you for the chore type requests but I would for the cup of tea, pass the salt type requests.
I have to say that I always say please the first time but not after that if I'm ignored!
And I will say thank you once it's done.
DH and the kids are the same as we lead by example. DH and I will thank each other (and the kids) for any household jobs done where it's helped out someone. For example, cooking, washing up, unloading the dishwasher, taking washing upstairs, etc.
None of us are perfect though so it does slip sometimes.
I think I would say - ds needs his Nappy changing - and no please
I wouldn't say please for giving my DH a nudge to do some chores.
I however say please when he IS doing me a favour like putting a wash on when he is up early and on his way to work.
Getting each other a drink or serving one another a meal gets please and thank yous though.
op I'm the same as you I think!
I wouldn't say "please can you change dd's nappy"
I'd say "nappy needs changing!" If he didn't notice and then I'd say thanks for that afterwards, just like he'd say to me I hope!
They say happy couples communicate what they want and take the time to appreciate their partner, so if that means taking the time to say thank you, even if it's something small, I'm going to say it sounds corny but if you don't want to say please and thank you, maybe a comment like,
"That was speedy" "you handled that well" "the living room looks nice"
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.