Advanced search

To dislike red nose day

(65 Posts)
jdoe8 Tue 14-Mar-17 09:25:04

Just seems to be people doing it for their own personal gain (even if that is just to feel good about themselves), more useless plastic that will end up in landfill and take ages to degrade and more junk food to a nation where 70% of adults are obese or overweight.

I wouldn't mind but its hard to avoid if you have kids, its pushed onto them both at school and in the media.

londonrach Tue 14-Mar-17 09:41:22

I agree. Im sure it goes against what mn think but i totoally agree (puts on flame proof clothes)

Flypaperforarseholes Tue 14-Mar-17 09:49:06

Even if some people do take part in Comic Relief in order to "feel good about themselves", the money raised still goes to fantastic causes, awareness is raised, children are encouraged to think of others...hard for me to see that negatively.

jdoe8 Tue 14-Mar-17 09:51:44

Even if some people do take part in Comic Relief in order to "feel good about themselves"

Well that was just me being diplomatic and not saying selfish reasons.

Thanks Rach glad I'm not alone.

Doyouwantabrew Tue 14-Mar-17 09:53:02

It's a bore fest of celebs. Just give quietly every month to charity.

Notso Tue 14-Mar-17 09:53:24

Not sure I see the connection with plastic and junk food.

I'm always on the fence with people doing stuff for charity.
On the one hand there is an obvious need for the money that's raised, I don't think many people would just give money otherwise.
On the other I get fed up with people wanting to do something for themselves but getting everyone else to donate.

WhoDoDatLikeDat Tue 14-Mar-17 09:55:16

I hate it with a passion

Littleballerina Tue 14-Mar-17 09:55:58

Junk food?

Surely red nose day is about fundraising and awareness?

specialsubject Tue 14-Mar-17 09:56:16

Not at all sure about comic relief overheads and the huge amount of plastic. Better than nothing, but my donations also go to more efficient charities.
Plastic noses in plastic wrappers - no.

AllllGooone Tue 14-Mar-17 09:56:36

Can't bare it op. Ds has to "wear red" which means I'll have to go and buy him something red, as the only red clothing he owns is his uniform.hmm

TryAnotherUsername Tue 14-Mar-17 09:57:28

Jeez I hate it, tbh I hate all charity days

When your a kid it's great fun but as an adult I'd just rather donate without all this hooplah

We have "Wear red and donate a silver coin day" this year, so your getting 5p! Plus my kids uniform is red anyway?? So if I send them in blue do I not pay?? hmm

Don't get me wrong I'm all for charity, regularly give to nspcc but the endless celebs telling us to donate "whatever you can" pisses me off!! How about they donate a couple of million each??

troodiedoo Tue 14-Mar-17 09:58:47

I don't care for it either. Nor children in need or dry January or any of them. Charity is big business. They sit on a lot of the money in investments.

There's a list somewhere online of charities that it is actually worthwhile giving to.

ChippyTea16 Tue 14-Mar-17 10:07:03

I'm the same. Really get annoyed at celebs begging the public to give money. I'm sure they do donate and everything but I feel like it really pulls on people's heart strings and people who can barely afford to look after themselves end up donating money they can't afford. This is general though, not specific to Red Nose Day but generally I feel the same!

Soubriquet Tue 14-Mar-17 10:08:54

I don't like that a portion of the donation goes to line the pockets of the already wealthy with the charity only benefitting from a small percentage

user1489179512 Tue 14-Mar-17 10:13:59

So called "celebrities" being more tedious than usual. I ignore it all.

GrumpyOldBag Tue 14-Mar-17 10:14:39


I hate it too.

seems to be horribly exploited by local supermarkets too.

Megatherium Tue 14-Mar-17 10:15:34

he endless celebs telling us to donate "whatever you can" pisses me off!! How about they donate a couple of million each??

Contrary to popular belief, most celebrities aren't stinking rich. If by lending their support they can help to raise several million, I can't see the problem.

Ellisisland Tue 14-Mar-17 10:16:14

The celeb thing really annoys me. I had a friend who worked for a charity as a fundraiser and she said so many celebs were more than happy to front a campaign or do some publicity but getting money out of them was impossible. Since hearing that it has made me very cynical about the whole thing. I know there are some very generous celebs, but I wonder if all of the ones who get involved actually donate anything

PickledCauliflower Tue 14-Mar-17 10:19:13

I agree that it is a celebrity borefest.
It doesn't inspire me to give to charity. I give what I can to a few chosen charities (not a huge amount I admit), but charities I know enough about and how the money is spent.
I would rather read a newspaper or magazine article about a particular charity (or charities) then watch a celebrity on tv talking about it.

Starfish28 Tue 14-Mar-17 10:23:55

I hate it as well. There are better charities out there and the plastic for landfill is just grim. I am incredibly uncomfortable with the videos they use to get people to donate as well. This charity highlights why using such emotive videos reinforces stereotypes

TheNaze73 Tue 14-Mar-17 10:25:43

It's not even remotely funny

LovelyBath77 Tue 14-Mar-17 10:29:27

When is it? Another things to worry about forgetting.

Dreamingdreams Tue 14-Mar-17 10:30:26


I agree with try, chippy and troo.

I hate them too. If all the "celebs" gave 1% of their yearly earnings to these causes they wouldn't need to bother the public, who can often ill afford to donate.

I also hate the way they tell you how much you should donate rather than leaving it entirely up to you.
If I want to donate, I'll do what I already do, and give by dd on a monthly basis.

I do question exactly how much of what's raised actually goes to the cause and gets used (not just sitting in an account somewhere or spent on expenses/wages, etc).

WorraLiberty Tue 14-Mar-17 10:32:03

What's the connection with junk food?

Are red noses being sold in fast food outlets or something?

Ifailed Tue 14-Mar-17 10:37:16

It was a good idea when it first started, but now it is far too commercialised with retailers jumping on the bandwagon to be seen to be doing good (it's just another marketing campaign) and 'celebs' getting their face out there on telly.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: