Talk

Advanced search

Good sleepers are less intelligent kids???

(164 Posts)
SparklyFuckingBusinessFairy Thu 19-Jan-17 08:31:30

Chatting with a colleague yesterday about our babies (16 months old), and she was moaning that her DS never sleeps. DD is a pretty good sleeper these days, usually sleeps for 10-12 hours. Then she said smugly, "of course, they say poor sleepers are much more intelligent," at which I was a bit shock. Even if you think that, even if it's scientifically true, you don't say it in those circumstances.

However, it is certainly true that her DS is very advanced; he walked at 10 months and says loads of words, whilst DD is bang on average so far and just has a few words that all sound the same (cheese, sneeze etc).

What are your experiences - are good sleepers and easy going kids generally less smart? Or can I tell her to get stuffed with her smugness?! And was she as rude as I thought she was, or was I being hypersensitive and perceiving criticism where there was none?

Scarydinosaurs Thu 19-Jan-17 08:34:12

She was rude, and stupid.

Also- the assumption that children that were advanced as babies and will continue to be advanced as young people/adults is also untrue. This misconception only leads to disappointment at parents evening in year ten when parents sit their scratching their heads that their slack jawed son will only scrap passes and say "but he walked at 10 months!" 😆

Areyoufree Thu 19-Jan-17 08:34:15

Splendid. I might have been barely functioning for the past 5 years, but at least my child must be a fucking genius.

whifflesqueak Thu 19-Jan-17 08:34:31

I have a perfectly average 2.5 year old who has never slept a full night in his life.

perhaps he'll blossom into some creative savant.

more likely your colleague is trying to make herself feel better about the sleepless nights.

YakiUdonYumYum Thu 19-Jan-17 08:34:31

Well, mine used to sleep a solid 12 hours a night when they were primary aged, and they're very academically able... less so socially hmm It also depends on how you define intelligence.

I'd tell her to stuff it, damn cheek.

Popskipiekin Thu 19-Jan-17 08:35:09

I'll be astonished if there is a serious link! But to add in my experience, for what it's worth, DS is an excellent sleeper and distinctly average in the development department grin Crawled at 11 months, walked 14 months and is clearly behind his peers with speech.

TronaldDump Thu 19-Jan-17 08:36:28

It's just something we tell ourselves to try and make having a bad sleeper more palatable. Otherwise it's just unrelentingly shit.

She was BU to say it to you but it wasn't about your child, it's about how she copes with sleep deprivation. Go to bed tonight and have lots of lovely sleep and don't give it a second thought!

DoJo Thu 19-Jan-17 08:38:01

It's one of the tiny semi/maybe/non truths that you Cong onto when you're on your knees with tiredness. She may have been insensitive but she probably wasn't saying it as a dig at you so much as an attempt to try and make herself feel better.

Bluntness100 Thu 19-Jan-17 08:38:18

I have a super intelligent nineteen year old. I'm not exaggerating, straight a or a star all the way through school, never a b blighted any certificate, I never pushed her once, now studying law at one of the countries top law schools.

Slept through from eleven weeks. Hardly a broken nights sleep ever. She does love her bed. Always has done. Your friend is just trying to console herself. 😃

DoJo Thu 19-Jan-17 08:38:39

Snap Tronald!

harderandharder2breathe Thu 19-Jan-17 08:39:07

I was always a good sleeper and am generally considered academically intelligent. I'm shit at plenty of other things like sports though.

Gardencentregroupie Thu 19-Jan-17 08:42:27

I was a brilliant sleeper apparently, and was an extremely clever child. My 2.6 year old is badly speech delayed, average on most other measures (hard to tell if she's clever when she can't fucking talk ) an absolutely dreadful sleeper, and has killed off any residual cleverness I had through sleep deprivation. So not only not a genius but an actual intelligence sapper.

SnugglySnerd Thu 19-Jan-17 08:43:00

That was a rude thing to say.
DD has always been a good sleeper but has had disturbed nights when she's been mastering a big new skill e.g. crawling, walking, first words and more recently potty training. It reminds me of when I was revising for my A levels and I kept waking up mulling over things about Henry VIII! I wonder if that's the sort of thing she means. If he's walking and other skills early maybe it does affect his sleep, for most children those skills would come a bit later and more spread out so the impact on sleep might not be as obvious. They are skills that all children develop when they are ready though so nothing to worry about.
This is completely my own theory based on observation of one child so probably complete rubbish btw!

namechangedtoday15 Thu 19-Jan-17 08:43:08

We were told that sleep was massively important to development (note, not necessarily intelligence) when we had babies on the neonatal unit.

originalmavis Thu 19-Jan-17 08:44:51

I could sleep for England as a child and was rather bright by all accounts. Bil can't sleep for more than 4:5 hrs and is very intelligent. Dad was incredibly smart and lived a good sleep...

I've been told that 'busy' toddlers are bright.

It's all nonsense really.

HarleyQuinzel Thu 19-Jan-17 08:44:52

I've heard this, mostly from others trying to console me when I'm so sleep deprived I could cry. FWIW I'd trade my 2 year olds intelligence for a good nights sleep any day of the week grin.

StealthPolarBear Thu 19-Jan-17 08:46:20

" Then she said smugly, "of course, they say poor sleepers are much more intelligent," at which"

They do say that, my mum was told that when I was a non sleeping baby. They say that to make the sleepdeprived parents feel better grin

Blu Thu 19-Jan-17 08:46:30

LOL, in her desperate, sleep deprived state she was probably just trying to offer herself some tongue in cheek compensation, rather than meaning to be derogatory to you.

Ds was a truly terrible sleeper, and eater, did talk very precociously at an early age, possibly because he spent more hours awake listening to it all and trying to yak rather than being asleep, so got more practice.

I do not recommend keeping your dd awake in the night in order for her to practice talking and listening grin

lovelearning Thu 19-Jan-17 08:48:32

Apparently, as a child, I needed less sleep for this very reason. grin What nonsense.

It also depends on how you define intelligence.

YakiUdonYumYum, oracle.

Trottersindependenttraders Thu 19-Jan-17 08:50:46

I drove my mum to distraction with my dislike of sleep. I don't think I slept through until I was about 3. I'm of distinctly average intelligence though, so blow your colleague's ridiculous statement out of the water. Take no notice.

HearTheThunderRoar Thu 19-Jan-17 08:52:52

My dd is 17 and is average academically in certain subjects (below in maths and science though) but was a terrible sleeper, she didn't sleep through until she was 3 and still has sleeping problems now.

So there goes her theory.

MLGs Thu 19-Jan-17 08:53:26

What tronald and others have said. It's what people say to comfort themselves when going through the actual torture of a badly sleeping baby.

Someone whose child barely sleeps is not likely to have been smug. Desperate maybe but not smug.

I actually think yabu. The form is that you are supposed to say it to her, as the parent for the sleeping baby.

Even though it is utter bollocks and not true at all, you have a duty to trot this out to comfort these poor people.

(slightly lighthearted. Mum of one awful sleeper and one good sleeper. I suspect they are of fairly equal intelligence grin )

BarbarianMum Thu 19-Jan-17 08:53:38

Dh has always been an excellent sleeper (from childhood) whereas I have always struggled with insomnia. I have 1 more IQ point than him. I would happily swap this point for all those extra lovely hours of delicious sleep!

BToperator Thu 19-Jan-17 08:54:15

It's certainly not been my experience, DS slept through from 10 weeks, and is pretty intelligent. He does bounce out of bed at 6am every day though!

AWaspOnAWindowInAHeatwave Thu 19-Jan-17 08:57:06

I've got one that didn't sleep longer than 3 hours until he turned 2, and one that's slept solidly most nights since about 8 weeks. Both seem to be hitting milestones around the same ages as one another, both seemingly bright and able, so my experience would suggest her theory is bollocks. That said, until DS was two (and on the rare occasion when he was asleep, I didn't sleep a wink throughout my pregnancy with DD) I might have been guilty of verbal diarrhoea through sleep deprivation too, so but her some slack and shrug it off.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: