Advanced search

To have told my son the truth (Santa)

(21 Posts)
CatchingBabies Thu 29-Dec-16 14:39:34

Don't read this with small children looking over your shoulder!

Ok so my son is coming up to 13 years old, he has autism and is very naive for his age. I didn't think he still believed in Santa for at least a couple of years now but we all play along for the sake of younger children in the house.

Anyway on Christmas Day I thought it was strange he wrote a card to Santa and put it in his stocking without telling anyone (I found it) and since then a few conversations showed that he still firmly believes in Santa.

So I told him the truth. I feel awful as he was so upset and even argued me a little with 'proof' that I had to be wrong.

I was worried due to his age he would be picked on if he went back to school with talks about what Santa brought him and I expect most children would have well stopped believing by now. Yet I can't help but feel bad about telling him. WIBU?

Awwlookatmybabyspider Thu 29-Dec-16 14:43:23

I'm sorry, but. IMHO you were being unreasonable. Children find out for themselves and you took the magic away from him.

That1950sMum Thu 29-Dec-16 14:45:31

You were right to tell him. Better coming from you than someone at school.

Floggingmolly Thu 29-Dec-16 14:45:49

No, I don't think you were. If he's at high school; talking about Santa wouldn't go down particularly well. Kids can be very cruel.

fecketyfeck Thu 29-Dec-16 14:46:41

You did the rest get thing. I also have a son with autism, he's 20 now but he was a similar age to yours when I told him the truth about santa.

Yes kids find out in their own way but my ds was so upset, the same as yours I was glad that I'd told him and we had the upset at home rather than him finding out at school, dealing with the upset there and possibly opening him up to bullying for a) still believing and b) being so upset about it.

I think you definitely did the right thing, and he will get over it.

illegitimateMortificadospawn Thu 29-Dec-16 14:47:02

I kind of let it slip to my 11 yo assuming he already knew & was playing along - he's in high school now FFS! DH told me on Boxing Day that DS1 had told him it had nixed his Christmassy feeling and he'd not been able to get it back. Oops!

CatchingBabies Thu 29-Dec-16 14:47:23

That's what I'm worried about and I honestly don't think he would have found out himself. His autism means he can't distinguish real from pretend very well and makes him extremely naive. I would have always had to tell him at some point or someone else would have done not as nicely as I did. When would have been the right time? I feel so guilty though.

TwoGunslingers Thu 29-Dec-16 14:47:45

I would probably have waited until the new year so he could still enjoy this Christmas Day, but otherwise not u

jaykay34 Thu 29-Dec-16 14:48:19

Of course YANBU.

I think you did the right thing. Despite his autism, he is 13, and it is probably better coming from you than somebody else.

I have a 40 year old cousin who has a learning disability, who still believes in Santa. My Aunt and Uncle have told him that Santa doesn't exist, and do not pretend in any way that he does - but my cousin doesn't believe them !

notangelinajolie Thu 29-Dec-16 14:53:00

Not told any of mine yet and the youngest is about to leave school. Santa still visits us every year, I know this because he always drinks the brandy we leave out for him.

Do people actually have a serious sit down conversation about this hmm

Evergreen17 Thu 29-Dec-16 14:54:25

I still remember how I found out. This girl from school cane to me mocking another child because he still believed in Santa, she was all "can you believe it??!! He didn't know???!!!!" sad so i played along.
Felt awful.
I was 6-7 I think
So at age 13 he would have been mocked eventually sorry. So I think you did well

titchy Thu 29-Dec-16 14:59:22

Do people actually have a serious sit down conversation about this

When the child has SN and believing leaves them open to ridicule then yes of course people do. It's responsible parenting.

With NT kids there's usually no need but the two situations aren't comparable, so not quite sure why the sneery face...

FinnegansCake Thu 29-Dec-16 15:06:29

I think you were absolutely right to tell him, he would have been at very real risk of being bullied if ever his classmates found out he still believed. I'm not very clear about when you had the conversation though. Was it before or after Santa came? I would have let him enjoy this Christmas but told him the truth before school starts again.
Don't beat yourself up about it, he had to be told. Far better that he heard it from his loving mother than from a jeering classmate.

CatchingBabies Thu 29-Dec-16 15:15:02

Thank you everyone! Yes we had a serious sit down conversation as I knew he would be upset and telling him in casual passing would have been far more upsetting to him. And I told him after Christmas (today), would never have told him just before!

I honestly thought he didn't believe anymore or I'd have dropped subtle hints over time but felt as an almost teen he needed to know.

alphabetaspagetti Thu 29-Dec-16 15:27:28

I did this last year with my autistic ds, and he is several years younger than yours - for exactly the same reason. He was mixing with older children for a weekly activity and I was worried he would be bullied about it (no doubt about it, he would have been). Santa still comes to him though!

catwoman0815 Thu 29-Dec-16 15:32:10

I think you were right.

DD is 8 and firmly believes in Santa. She has ASD and learning diffs. I will keep things as they are for the next few years but I think there will be a point where I will tell her.

Chelazla Thu 29-Dec-16 15:33:28

I think you did right thing but I'm so sad for you! Kids are mean! An older child told my 4yo Santa wasn't real and I had to physically restrain my hubby from finding said 9yo! Luckily we talked her round but once they don't believe it does steal some magic. X

Chelazla Thu 29-Dec-16 15:34:36

Notangelina I also think the sneer is really uncalled for and quite nasty. Op said her son is sn!

DancingDragon Thu 29-Dec-16 15:34:40

I think you did the right thing op.

mikeyssister Thu 29-Dec-16 16:33:07

I told DD12 who's NT yesterday. She half believed/half hoped I think.

If anyone mocks/teases her when she goes back to school she plans to tell them she always refers to Santa as she has young cousins and doesn't want to slip in front of them. It's a handy excuse for anything she said before they broke up.

I think she's delighted to know the truth, but I'm devastated as she was my baby.

heavenlypink Thu 29-Dec-16 17:57:28

The way I explained it to my SN DS was to say that Yes Santa was a real person but many many years ago and not in our country - and that Santa was not ever able to deliver presents to ALL the children ALL around the world. He's 19 down and (I think) still believes in the magic of Christmas 🎅🏼

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: