Skip to main content
Skip to main navigation
Skip to talk navigation

Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Add post

Watch this thread

Save thread

Start a new thread

Flip thread

Hide thread

My feed

Saved Active Unanswered threads

Getting started FAQ's

Unanswered threads Acronyms Talk guidelines

Hide shortcut buttons

Talk

Flip

1 2 3

AIBU?

Not to want sister and family for Christmas

55 replies

Breastbeaten · 03/11/2016 23:38

I feel awful to say this but I don't want my sister, bro in law and 1 yo nephew to come for Christmas. They want to stay for 4 nights but:

Baby is a terrible crier - it's pretty much constant. He doesn't interact with anyone and I am worried too much attention would be focused on trying to stop him walking in to things, knocking things over and generally being a danger to himself, my daughter and dogs.

But more delicate issue probably..... my sis and bro in law are awful to each other. They snipe, bitch and outfight argue and insult each other in front of all of us, including our 7yo.

We like a calm environment and don't argue in front of kids.

So what do I say? How do I say it? Can it be done without huge hurt?

OP posts:

Report

Domino20 · 03/11/2016 23:40

Did you invite them? Or did they invite themselves?

PurpleDaisies · 03/11/2016 23:41

Did you invite them or have they invited themselves? Do you live close enough that they could come for the day or part of it?

Antifrank · 03/11/2016 23:42

Feign death. Or emigrate

Pallisers · 03/11/2016 23:43

you say "we are planning a quiet family christmas with no visitors".

If she pushes (and who pushes for an invitation), I think you might want to say that you don't enjoy the dynamic between sis and her husband and find their fights and sniping stressful and unpleasant - it might be a wake up call for them. But it will definitely cause upset.

So ask yourself are you willing to trade your family's nice christmas for a crap christmas just to avoid telling the truth to your sister? Do you children have to sacrifice their holiday because she can't be hurt in any way?

Don't mention the baby. The truth is if your sister and her husband were lovely people, you'd probably enjoy the baby, crying and all.

Why do they want to come to you?

IMissGrannyW · 03/11/2016 23:44

what is the proposed plan/your family's understanding of what is going to happen at Christmas this year?

peppatax · 03/11/2016 23:45

Oh god just say no. Life's too short. She probably wants to come to dilute the bickering but that's not your responsibility at Christmas with DC

BadKnee · 03/11/2016 23:48

I wouldn't tell sister that I don't like the way she and her husband talk to each other. How would you feel if she said that to you? If someone judged my relationship with my spouse in that way and refused to invite me on that basis I would be very hurt indeed.

By all means say that you are busy/ what ever but don't criticize their relationship, (unless you want to lose a sister)

llangennith · 03/11/2016 23:51

I wouldn't want them over at Christmas either. Sorry, no solutions, but I don't blame you for feeling this way.

Breastbeaten · 03/11/2016 23:53

Thanks for the fast replies.
The plan, that they suggested, is for them to come Christmas Eve and stay til 28th. They only live 30 mins down the road but the baby doesn't cope well with car journeys. He has issues and I feel horrible even thinking about him being a chore - I love him, you're right.
It IS the constant tense atmosphere with the sister that I (and my husband and kids) hate.
She wants to come to us because

I can cook and have enough money to make sure all the food and drink is lovely whereas they are hard up.
My mum from the North will be staying for 6 nights and sis wants to see her. She's taken for granted that everyone staying is not a problem because we have a reasonably large house - we can accommodate everyone. I'm just worried there'll be no let up in the behaviour and I will end up feeling like it's been a wasted Christmas - maybe my lo's last as a believer? Is it ok for me to say they can come over on Christmas Eve, have Christmas lunch and come Boxing Day when we always have a little party, but that's it, and no staying past baby's bed time unless they're prepared to deal with him crying in a calm manner, in a room away from us all so we don't hear them arguing!

Thanks for the help.

OP posts:

Trojanhorsebox · 04/11/2016 00:00

If they only love 30 min away there is absolutely no need for you to host them overnight unless you want to - as for 4 nights, they are pushing their luck.

Let them come in the day time on specific days you choose for specific meals and have a clear end point to the visits - ie come for lunch and leave before supper or come later in the day for supper and go home for the night. They can see your Mum at those times and if they want to see her more they can come and pick her up and take her out for lunch etc, or if she has a car she can go to them.

Staying with you for 4 days when they live 30 min away - love it - plenty of people do a much longer daily commute to work or school than that !

PurpleDaisies · 04/11/2016 00:05

I agree with trojan. Can't they do the journey at the baby's sleep times?

I wouldn't raise the arguing-do you really think you'll get anywhere?

QueenLizIII · 04/11/2016 00:06

30 mins away? WTF

I would tell her straight you cant stand them arguing and you dont want them spoiling christmas. She is old enough to be told the truth.

Trojanhorsebox · 04/11/2016 00:08

She's taken for granted that everyone staying is not a problem because we have a reasonably large house - we can accommodate everyone

Just because you can accommodate everyone it doesn't mean you have to. The size of your house is irrelevant - it's not space that's the issue, it's their behaviour, though you may not want to say it quite like that. Your husband and kids don't like it either, don't ruin their Christmas as well as your own, set some boundaries with your sister.

Is she likely to pull your Mum into it to petition on her behalf if you do say no to her? If so, be ready for that too. No doubt your Mum will want to see her daughter and grandson, but you're not stopping her from doing that, just declining to host them for 4 nights at your house. As I said in my earlier post, 30 minutes away is plenty close enough for your Mum to spend lots of time with them.

AlwaysInTheMiddle · 04/11/2016 00:11

Just say no

blowmybarnacles · 04/11/2016 00:20

4 day holiday in your house when they live 30 mins away? Fuck that for a game of soldiers.

Put your children first. What will give them a happy chilled xmas?

A crying baby and arguing family is not on anybody's list.

EverySongbirdSays · 04/11/2016 00:22

This is difficult - criticising the way someone takes care of their baby is a big no, unless it's your DM, and even then not well received.

Is she the kind of sister you can "get real" with over the state of her marriage? I'm dreading Chrsitmas myself, probable flair ups.

Again, saying no to an overnight if you've got a big house is also hard. As it means they can't both drink.

Can your Mum not have a word?

blowmybarnacles · 04/11/2016 00:25

Let them stay over xmas night only.

Pallisers · 04/11/2016 00:30

I wouldn't tell sister that I don't like the way she and her husband talk to each other. How would you feel if she said that to you? If someone judged my relationship with my spouse in that way and refused to invite me on that basis I would be very hurt indeed.

yes of course you would be hurt. But what if you also were opened to the idea that the way the two of you relate it actually quite toxic and many people don't want to be near you as a result?

Might it make you change your behaviour or maybe think about your relationship.

If everyone goes along with every toxic relationship for fear of hurting the people in them, how will they ever know that this is not normal? How will their children ever know that this is not normal?

AcrossthePond55 · 04/11/2016 00:37

What do you think your mum's feelings are about this? Does she feel that Sis and BiL are, um, not restful to be around? Would she take your part in this?

I vote say NO. And I don't think there's anything wrong with telling your Sis that you don't enjoy the sniping and arguing. But be prepared for her to either argue about it ('no we don't' or 'it's not that bad') or say 'We'll be careful and not do that' (they will).

Breastbeaten · 04/11/2016 00:40

Pallisers that is a great summary of the conflict in my head. I need to be brave and say no deal on the long stay and when they are here, they need to respect other people's space.
I will comment on their relationship because by making arguments a constant bloody feature of every weekend at my house, they've effectively tabled it for discussion. I'm going to ask her how it's going and advise gently at first that they need to start listening to and respecting each other and possibly even Relate. They are lovely people but I am when I think of them coming for more than a few hours and the fact my 7yo asked me two weeks ago "do they have to come today? I hate the bickering".

I will find a good way of dealing,not avoiding.
Thanks guys
X

OP posts:

Bogeyface · 04/11/2016 01:13

Someone needs to bring up the arguing, if only for the sake of the poor child.

girlywhirly · 04/11/2016 08:48

OP, yanbu to want an argument free Christmas. I agree that DSIS and her family could visit without staying the nights at your home.

I also agree that they need to know how their behaviour impacts much more on people than they think. I think they would be shocked to know that their own young niece is so upset by it she would rather they didn't come. In fact, their own baby must be picking up on the atmosphere and is irritable and cries a lot, regardless of special needs. Is this the reason why they argue so much, and do they get support to cope from the health visitor and any other services, if not why not.

It's not nice, but better to have it out now before they alienate their family. DSIS minimising the sniping as not that bad means that subconsciously it really is.

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Email address

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

PigletWasPoohsFriend · 04/11/2016 08:55

He has issues and I feel horrible even thinking about him being a chore

So your DSis has a child who has SN and that is your opinion

Of course you don't have to have them there, bit as for thinking of a baby as 'a chore' how would you feel if your sister felt that way about you.

BarbarianMum · 04/11/2016 09:02

I think if you tell your sister how you feel about her child that will probably sort the problem. I realise that they are a difficult couple but reading that made me feel slightly sick, sorry.

Trifleorbust · 04/11/2016 09:06

Maybe a gentle word in her ear about keeping calm for the sake of your kids while she is there would be better than a) a lecture about her relationship and b) telling her not to come. You could say, "You are very welcome of course. I just want to make it clear that we are after a calm atmosphere and I know things can be a bit tense between you and DP sometimes. You're going to need to keep it to yourselves." Or similar.

Flip

1 2 3

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.