Talk

Advanced search

To not understand the puréed fruit thing?

(57 Posts)
DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 20:59:54

So whole fruit is ok. Mashed fruit is ok. But puréed fruit is not.

Why? I've read something about sugars being released but it makes no sense to me.

Tarla Sun 09-Oct-16 21:04:26

The way I understand it is that it's to do with density. So you could juice/puree half a dozen peaches and drink them down but you'd struggle to eat six whole peaches as you'd be full after two, maybe three at most.

But, having said that, everything in moderation is key and a bowl of apple puree is still healthier than a bowl of Ben and Jerry's!

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:21:02

Really? It's just about quantity?

So what's the "sugar stored in cell walls pseudoscience stuff?

mikado1 Sun 09-Oct-16 21:23:20

By pursuing you are voiding the fruit of its fibre (and vitamins?!) and reducing it to pure sugar.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine Sun 09-Oct-16 21:25:14

How?

To me pureeing would involve taking fruit and whizzing it up. No difference in vitamins as no heating, no difference in fibre as all fruit is still there just in a different format.

Sugarcoma Sun 09-Oct-16 21:35:36

When you whizz it up you breakdown the fibre.

BarbaraofSeville Sun 09-Oct-16 21:40:19

Is whizzing really that different to chewing though?

Isn't it just that purees and smoothies make it easier to consume larger quantities and hence more calories?

But then people never make these accusations about soup. You can eat all the vegetable soup you like without any suggestion that it doesn't count as vegetables or is unhealthy.

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:41:43

Mikado1 you are kind of answering my question with my own question.

How does puréeing fruit reduce it to pure sugar?

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:42:23

Exactly barbara

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:44:13

A dietician (nutritionist? Not sure) once told me in answer to this question that "digestion begins in the mouth"

What's that about? Related to the chewing thing? Surely chewing and puréeing are sort of the same?

Talcott2007 Sun 09-Oct-16 21:44:34

I think it's to do with the 'work' your body has to do to digest it....whole means the body has to put more effort and energy into breaking down and absorbing everything and therefore uses more calories during the eating and digesting process...if it is juice or puree it's easier for the body to digest so more of the sugars are left over

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:45:58

I've heard that you should drink fresh juice / fruit smoothies right away as otherwise good stuff escapes

Stupid as it sounds, I can sort of believe that... The sugar thing though? Magicking up sugar where it wasn't before? Whhhhhaaaaa?!

lolalament Sun 09-Oct-16 21:46:26

Your teeth use energy to chew. But your blender is using electricity

Temporaryname137 Sun 09-Oct-16 21:46:52

When I had GD, the dietitian explained it to me like a parcel. The sugar is on the inside and the fruit itself is like the brown paper wrapping. So it takes your body much more time and effort to process it, whereas purée or juice is already in liquid sugar form!

LoisEighty Sun 09-Oct-16 21:47:59

Normal pureed fruit is fine.

'Sweetened with fruit puree' puree in baby yoghurts etc is super concentrated until it is basically just sugar with no other nutritional value.

Juices/smoothies lack fibre and have loads more sugar than you would consume if eating fruit eg. you wouldn't sit down and eat 6 oranges in one go.

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:49:13

Talcott I kind of get that, but not fully.

What work is involved in digestion? I can't believe that the act of chewing, or the action of the stomach lining really takes that much effort? Or does it?!

ClopySow Sun 09-Oct-16 21:49:25

It's to do with how your body deals with the sugar.

Whole fruit still has a fibrous structure which you absorb the sugar slowly from. Something different happens with pureed fruit and it makes your blood sugar spike which fucks with everything. And ting.

I just read that on the internet.

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 21:51:34

"Your teeth use energy to chew. But your blender is using electricity"

Seriously?! You can't honestly believe that the action of chewing uses up so much energy that to remove it (via purée) renders the entire fruit pure sugar?

What??

FrameyMcFrame Sun 09-Oct-16 21:54:50

When you purée or juice fruit the complex structures inside the fruit are destroyed.
Your body processes the sugar much more quickly, which means more insulin is released into your blood which causes fat to be stored in the body.

RafaIsTheKingOfClay Sun 09-Oct-16 21:55:10

You might regret asking this OP. I get the feeling this thread will end up making you more confused rather than less.

GerdaLovesLili Sun 09-Oct-16 21:58:17

Wait! Is it like if you eat sucrose your body turns it into glucose and then into energy.....but if you eat glucose the energy is already there without the extra work?

Grumpyaboutchristmas Sun 09-Oct-16 21:58:34

Clopysow sounds the most plausible so far, the other explanations don't make any sense to me whatsoever. Any scientist out there who can explain the difference?

As someone who has a smoothie for breakfast every day (God bless The Bullet) with a banana, berries, oats, yogurt, seeds and (a small glass of) fresh fruit juice all whizzed up, I'll be fucking gutted if I may as well start the day with a can of coke (although I'd bloody love that). I honestly thought my breakfast was as good as it got.

Grumpyaboutchristmas Sun 09-Oct-16 22:00:49

Ps I'm whippet thin, so the fat issue doesn't bother me Framey, does that make it healthy for me?

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 22:00:59

Clopy I can get behind that. So you can get to the sugar faster, so you spike. Ok. So the amount of sugar is the same but the access is different?
Which leads me to the next question which is if the amount of sugar is the same... Is spiking a bad thing? So, you get all the sugar at once. Is that bad? And why?

DeadGood Sun 09-Oct-16 22:02:04

framey that makes even more sense. So insulin is the baddie here?

I am prepared to believe this. I just needed compelling evidence!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now