Watching the early stages of the Olympics has provoked a debate in chez Dylan.
Are all the events in the Olympics actually sports? After watching the target shooting and the gymnastic events, there was some discussion whether they were sports or not. I argued weren't sports for different reasons.
It is a vexed issue and I admit that I have a narrow definition of sport, for an activity to qualify as a sport it must:
A)Require cardio-vascular fitness (a grey area I know,)
B) Be competitive and rank the competitors in order.(So that knocks out Yoga and cycling to work)
C) The outcome decided by the contestants, not an outside observer or judge. Sports have referees who enforce the rules, but don't decide the outcome.
I'm not doubting that both target shooting and gymnastics at the top level require a tremendous degree of skill, hardwork and dedication, but I'd question either of them were sports for different reasons.
Both activities meet the criteria that they are competitive and the competitors are ranked in order and the outcome decided by an objective criteria. But in the case of target shooting, the effort of aiming and pulling the trigger puts next to no extra strain on the cardiovascular system. If shooting is considered a sport, why not bridge or draughts?
Conversely gymnastics requires an astonishing degree of athleticism and cardio-vascular fitness, but the outcome of the contest is determined by a set of subjective criteria. The event is decided by an outside observer and a decision that x routine has a 7.3 degree of difficulty and another has 6.2. There's also the capacity for the judges to interpret how well the routine has been executed and scoring for artistry. If so, could Strictly or even the X Factor be considered sports events?
This is purely a mental exercise and I'm not doubting the commitment and talent of anyone who takes part in either activity. I realise that there is no way you could exclude all judged events from the Olympics such as synchronised swimming, diving, dressage and there are grey areas like whether boxing is a sport if the contest is won by a knockout and not if decided by a judges' decision and that's before you get onto the thorny issue of motor racing! However I am struggling to find another working definition of a sport.
How does everyone else define an activity as a sport and where do you stand on gymnastics and shooting as sports?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
AIBU?
To ask how do you define an activity as being a sport?
42 replies
LikeDylanInTheMovies · 08/08/2016 00:46
OP posts:
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.