Talk

Advanced search

To think Alice in Wonderland is actually really shit.

(88 Posts)
HomerSimpsonsStubble Wed 29-Jun-16 11:43:11

Not EU related but maybe just as controversial.

I've started reading it to my 4 year old recently and have come to realise it's just a load of waffling and rambling thoughts of an obviously high/drunk person.

I wonder if something like it, written the way it is, would get published today...I don't think it's anything special.

No wonder the film was changed so much.

(I did really enjoy LOTR though and have read it 3 times)

HomerSimpsonsStubble Wed 29-Jun-16 11:44:24

Infact every adaptation bypasses the waffling.

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:45:57

YABVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVU!!!!!!!!!!!

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:47:39

I've got the original editions of Alice In Wonderland and Through The Looking Glass. It is a jumble I'll agree but it is also my favourite all time story, I refuse to even let DC look at them grin

timeforabrewnow Wed 29-Jun-16 11:47:51

YABU - and so what if you like Lord of the Rings - surely that is totally unrelated??

It's not written for a 4 year old to understand, perhaps more a 9 or 10 year with an imagination.

miaowmix Wed 29-Jun-16 11:48:29

YABU
I think LOTR is shit, for the record smile.

EdmundCleverClogs Wed 29-Jun-16 11:48:40

I don't like Alice in Wonderland, due the alleged horrible way he came to write the story. May not be true, but it certainly has a creepy 'Peter pan' vibe.

FaFoutis Wed 29-Jun-16 11:48:56

YANBU
It is boring drivel - like somebody telling you about their dream in drawn out detail.

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:49:07

Also, it was written back when written and spoken language was completely different to modern day written and spoken English, so no it probably wouldn't have been published as is in this day and age, however it wasn't published in this day and age

HomerSimpsonsStubble Wed 29-Jun-16 11:50:15

I wrote down I like LOTR because I know a lot of people think it's shit grin...so it was like a comparison grin

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:50:51

Edmund it was written for his daughter iirc, not sure how that's weird? I'm off to do research on the matter, I've never heard about any horrible reason for writing the story

Queenbean Wed 29-Jun-16 11:50:51

Edmund what is the backstory?

BeYourselfUnlessUCanBeAUnicorn Wed 29-Jun-16 11:51:12

YANBU. It makes no sense and is a load of nonsense. Really don't like it. I wouldn't even attempt to watch the new one with creepy looking Johnny Depp in it, he looks way too sinister.

LurkingHusband Wed 29-Jun-16 11:52:06

One of the best books in the English language IMHO.

YABU.

EsmesBees Wed 29-Jun-16 11:52:22

I love Alice in Wonderland! Opened up whole new worlds of imagination when I was a child. I was a lot older when I read it though.

EsmesBees Wed 29-Jun-16 11:52:46

Hated the Johnny Depp film though

HomerSimpsonsStubble Wed 29-Jun-16 11:54:16

letmehave I don't agree with that because there's loads of Charles Dickens books written around the same time and they're written brilliantly without the waffling. Not to mention all the Sherlock Holmes books written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Lewis Carol's AinW is shit compared to all other books written in the 1800's

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:54:39

www.historytoday.com/richard-cavendish/alice-wonderland-story-first-told Cation, may be upsetting

I feel like I've just been betrayed somehow... I'll never be able to look at it the same way sad

HomerSimpsonsStubble Wed 29-Jun-16 11:55:47

I watched the new movie with my dd and ds and they enjoyed it; because it was so far removed from the real story!

Letmehaveausername Wed 29-Jun-16 11:56:34

Doesn't mean it's not a good story Homer but everyone has different opinions. My opinion was that I thoroughly enjoyed the stories.

Except now I won't be able to read it again without thinking about pedophiles sad

NecklessMumster Wed 29-Jun-16 11:58:28

I loved it as a child and still do.Esp looking glass. I used to sit in front of our mirror and wish I could go through. I was scared of the jabberwocky picture
I liked the sheep in the shop and the train as well.

MargotLovedTom Wed 29-Jun-16 11:58:59

That's a shame that you've been disappointed; I thought it was common knowledge there were undercurrents to his friendship with the real Alice.

MetalMidget Wed 29-Jun-16 12:01:20

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/bbc/11368772/BBC-investigates-whether-Lewis-Carroll-was-repressed-paedophile-after-nude-photo-discovery.html

MaddyHatter Wed 29-Jun-16 12:04:03

LOTR is shit, love the story, cant read the books.. the rambling is ridiculous, i can never get passed the Tom Bombadil stuff, its like trying to swim through treacle getting through those books.

And thats coming from someone who will happily sit and read the whole GoT series in 8 days!

EdmundCleverClogs Wed 29-Jun-16 12:04:22

Sorry guys. It was well known around where I grew up (though obviously a hearsay story).

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now