Talk

Advanced search

to think that Nicola Sturgeon is a liar

(90 Posts)
mamamea Sun 26-Jun-16 12:10:38

She has said 'Holyrood could veto Brexit'

www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-36633244

However, the Scotland Act 1998, from which all her powers are derived, makes it clear that foreign affairs, including, explicitly, relations with the EU, is not something over which the Scottish Parliament has any authority.

She says ' would there have to be a legislative consent motion' (i.e. a motion accepting UK legislation in a devolved area to be valid in Scotland). The answer is no, as foreign relations are not devolved.

She obviously knows this, why is she lying?

georgetteheyersbonnet Sun 26-Jun-16 12:13:04

She isn't a liar. See paras 70 and 71 here:

www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld201516/ldselect/ldeucom/138/138.pdf

ny20005 Sun 26-Jun-16 12:16:02

If you read the report on the process of withdrawing from the EU, you'll see that Scottish Parliament has to consent to this ...

CaptainCrunch Sun 26-Jun-16 12:16:20

She's not lying. And we're currently in a situation without precedent. ATM she's the only one protecting the interest of the electorate, unlike Cameron who has basically fucked off and left everyone to flounder.

sandrabedminster Sun 26-Jun-16 12:18:04

She's just a nasty bully and troll.

peachpudding Sun 26-Jun-16 12:18:46

what is there to veto? the westminster government initiates article 50 and 2 years later we are gone! Scotland can do whatever they want but the EU will have cut ties with the UK so, she is lying.

lilydaisyrose Sun 26-Jun-16 12:19:16

Please stop cluttering up the whole of mumsnet with referendum threads!!! There is a whole section! I've hidden about 40 this morning!!!

TriniRedVelvet Sun 26-Jun-16 12:19:55

What's concerning is that she doesn't want Scotland to be forced out of EU against theirby England and Wales but is happy to force us to stay against our will.

53rdAndBird Sun 26-Jun-16 12:20:25

That's ok, I'm sure the Leave campaign factored in the legislative consent requirements for devolved administrations as part of their detailed and well thought through plans. Right, Boris? Boris? Boris... are you there?

TriniRedVelvet Sun 26-Jun-16 12:20:38

their will

mamamea Sun 26-Jun-16 12:21:01

She has no power to stop Article 50 being invoked. Once that is invoked, the UK will leave the EU.

There is very plainly, no 'veto'.

What Paragraph 70 is discussing is the primacy of EU law in Scotland. Although that is an issue in relation to Brexit, it does not mean that Scotland can refuse to withdraw from the EU.

mamamea Sun 26-Jun-16 12:22:50

The consent that is being referred to is consent to amend the Scotland Act 1998. It is not consent to leave the EU.

HumphreyCobblers Sun 26-Jun-16 12:23:05

Gosh! Imagine if she did.

Politics has never been so dramatic. Despite my strong feelings in one direction, I am certainly agog at all the drama.

ny20005 Sun 26-Jun-16 12:23:18

NS's job is to protect Scotland's interests, she has never once said that she wants to force England & Wales to stay

Juliancopescat Sun 26-Jun-16 12:23:45

To call someone a liar in this way for simply voicing her opinion in the legalities involved is really coarse and indicative of the fairly low level politics in the UK has stooped.

Her job is to investigate all the avenues available to her to safeguard her country and majority of her citizens who voted to remain.

Sturgeon is the only politician right now who seems to have a clue (or a plan)

I'm not Scottish and have never given her a second thought really but calling her a liar!!?? For real! Do you do that in real life?

peachpudding Sun 26-Jun-16 12:26:11

Who would she send her veto to, The European court of human rights?

Lol can you imagine that trial Scotland v England, Judge rules England cannot leave EU and we are to be subsumed by Germany.

LaurieFairyCake Sun 26-Jun-16 12:27:17

She has to do the best for Scotland

The gap between Leave and Remain in Scotland is much wider than the rest of the UK

I'm quite sure if there's any way to secure the interests of the Scottish Electorate who voted then she will

If there's a chance she can block it legally, she absolutely must make a legal argument - doesn't mean she will win the argument but she has a duty to make a legal argument if possible

toomanypetals Sun 26-Jun-16 12:32:54

Pissed off with people who are pissed off with lots of EU threads. What do you expect? Biggest political event of our time. It's huge.

It needs and warrants discussion.

GhostofFrankGrimes Sun 26-Jun-16 12:36:17

Sturgeon's mandate is to look after the interests of the Scottish people. That is what she is doing. Her response was inevitable.

Brexiters would have known this would happen - due to doing research prior to the vote right?

museumum Sun 26-Jun-16 12:40:50

There is no precedent. She's not lying. Just investigating all possibilities. Denmark is in the EU while Greenland and the Faroe Islands are not despite being ruled by Denmark.

PanEuropeanPan Sun 26-Jun-16 13:02:40

She is emerging as one of the very few UK politicians actually doing her job this weekend.

StopShoutingAtYourBrother Sun 26-Jun-16 13:08:38

53rd ha! Love it!!

StopShoutingAtYourBrother Sun 26-Jun-16 13:09:12

Yes, yes paneuropean

LassWiTheDelicateAir Sun 26-Jun-16 13:10:11

If there's a chance she can block it legally, she absolutely must make a legal argument - doesn't mean she will win the argument but she has a duty to make a legal argument if possible

I dislike Sturgeon only marginally less than I dislike Farage but she has to get credit for this.

expatinscotland Sun 26-Jun-16 13:11:31

Oh, you again!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now