Advanced search

What are the consequences for lying to the electorate?

(80 Posts)
Saxie007 Sat 25-Jun-16 20:53:25

What can we do to ensure that the facts given are true? If MPs, special advisors and those on the campaign trail lie and it can be proven to be untrue in a court of law is there some form of redress that the public could take?

I am primarily thinking of the £350M to the NHS claim which was clearly rubbish.

If it was advertising we could fine the company and ban the ad.

We are dealing with liers here. How can we flush them out of our political system to make sure the facts are clear and true in future debates. Politicians have no moral code. They should be ashamed and the good ones are.

OhStacey Sat 25-Jun-16 20:54:51


x2boys Sat 25-Jun-16 20:58:35

You realise politicians lie and spin doctor all the time right??

BikeRunSki Sat 25-Jun-16 21:02:31

Politicians have been lying to the electorate for centuries. There are no consequences, other than loosing the trust of the electorate.

ApocalypseSlough Sat 25-Jun-16 21:04:00

Normally politicians then have to go through various hoops to implement new laws and can then be voted out, so it's less important.

eyebrowsonfleek Sat 25-Jun-16 21:04:22

There's none if you can bury the lies until you get what you need.

wanderings Sat 25-Jun-16 21:05:57

Tony Bliar.

He's not in prison for war crimes. And nobody has assassinated him

exWifebeginsat40 Sat 25-Jun-16 21:08:01

well, it's the game of politics isn't it? sort of untruth brinkmanship - how outrageous a lie can we tell and have people believe it?

this is why the referendum is so fucked. in a general election with Proportional Representation all this bollocks has a chance of ironing itself out. with a yes/no game the side with the most appealing description of the outcome wins, regardless of whether or not they were telling the truth.

welcome to paradise.

ofshoes Sat 25-Jun-16 21:09:24

The usual consequence of lying to the electorate is reelection. There's nothing new here, It's what politicians do.

bloodymaria Sat 25-Jun-16 21:14:48

Well, judging by the Scottish independence referendum, the consequences will be absolutely eff all.

Politicians lie op.

RaeSkywalker Sat 25-Jun-16 21:19:29

Politicians lie all the time, or change their minds once in office. Look at Lib Dems and tuition fees, for example.

Seeing as the Leave campaign weren't voted into power on Thursday (at least not officially, thank goodness), I don't think there's any way to hold them accountable. We can't do what we'd normally do and vote them out at the next election. We could vote some of the MPs that campaigned for them out though.

TiggyD Sat 25-Jun-16 21:21:35

What are the consequences of cluttering up AIBU with referendum threads when there is a special section for them?

What exactly are you asking is unreasonable?

cheekyfunkymonkey Sat 25-Jun-16 21:22:32

The 350 million was clearly a lie, as was much of what went on, not only on leave side. You are right though, they shouldn't be able to get away with it and the public, no matter which way you voted, deserve so much better. They should be held to account.

ReallyTired Sat 25-Jun-16 21:25:24

Do you honestly believe that David Cameron et al are innocent as the driven snow of lying with the remain campaign. A referendum is about making difficult and life changing decisions and no one has a crystal ball. Vote leave is a leap into the dark, but sometimes risk taking pays off.

With a referendum that is so close its inevitable half the country will be very upset. Unfortunately that is how democracy work. Its one person, one vote. The illerate chav from the council estate has the same voting power as an Oxbridge graduate.

As a country we have to hold OURSELVES accountable for our actions and mistakes. The remain camp need to grow up.

BillSykesDog Sat 25-Jun-16 21:26:21

Did anyone ever actually say that the entire£350 million was going to be spent on the NHS? The slogan on the bus said £350 million per year, but underneath it said 'Let's invest in our NHS'. Nobody, as far as I'm aware, ever said 'We promise to spend the entire £350 million on the NHS'.

Ditto Farage, he said that putting £350 million on the side of the bus was a mistake, he didn't say 'Yes, we promised to put £350 million into the NHS and that was a mistake'. And there's the fact that Farage has absolutely no authority to either break or keep that promise because he has no power.

So, er, OP: it would appear that you and the people who are repeating are being deliberately misleading. I do hope you will be handing yourself in to the nearest police station immediately seeing as you disapprove of this so much.

Tiggeryoubastard Sat 25-Jun-16 21:26:32

Blair made millions and got away with murder.

BMW6 Sat 25-Jun-16 21:28:41


Sallyingforth Sat 25-Jun-16 21:35:12

It's no different to the lie that Brexit would stop immigration.
Lots of fucking idiots fell for that one too.

BestIsWest Sat 25-Jun-16 21:35:43

Re the £350 million. I have here a leaflet from Vote Leave that clearly states the following
'We will be able to save £350 million a week. We can spend our money on our priorities like the NHS, schools, and housing'

Delivered to my house about two days before the referendum.
Publish on behalf of Vote Leave.

mirime Sat 25-Jun-16 21:35:48

Politicians lie all the time, or change their minds once in office. Look at Lib Dems and tuition fees, for example.

A bit unfair given that they were the junior partner in a coalition. Not the same as if they'd got the majority of seats and then changed their minds.

hobnobsaremyfave Sat 25-Jun-16 21:37:22

A knighthood and a seat in the house of lords with a nice lucrative consutlancy sideline

BestIsWest Sat 25-Jun-16 21:41:29

Vote Leave ltd were designated the official Brexit campaigners by the Electoral commission and give public money to fund its campaign.

dangerrabbit Sat 25-Jun-16 21:42:09

What are the consequences?


ocelot41 Sat 25-Jun-16 21:42:44

In defence of the OP she has a point. If we cant hold to account politicians who base their campaigns in the run-up to a referendum or GE on barefaced lies, then our trust in political engagement is fatally damaged. That is different from common or garden spin, which is a question of emphasis and framing.I agree - it is a form.of fraud and there should be some sort of legal redress.

RepentAtLeisure Sat 25-Jun-16 21:44:00

Did the Leave team have any power to promise things, like money to the NHS, and here they apparently assured Cornwall that their funding would still be available (£60 million from the EU every year.)

I know Nigel is an MEP, Boris Johnson, IDS and Michael Gove are MPs, but none of them are even in the cabinet currently. Surely the decision making lies mostly with the PM and senior cabinet members, none of whom were on the Leave side?

And if Boris becomes the next PM what do we think the chances are of him delivering on Brexit promises?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now